What if? - PINNEAPPLE - Wattpad

Story cover for What if? by PinaColada100

What if?

Reads 521
Votes 29
Parts 7
Time 22m

Reads 521
Votes 29
Parts 7
Time 22m

fanfiction fiction kotlc

What if Sophie Foster never got discovered by Fitz? What if the Foster family went on a trip when Sophie was 5 and Amy was 1 and Sophie never returned... Well umm, read to find out...


This all starts BEFORE the first Kotlc book, but you still need to have read enough of the series to know about the characters and plot and stuff...
I am not Shannon Messenger!!!

(the title and cover will be changed later... Give me ideas if u want for a title...)All Rights Reserved

fanfiction fiction kotlc

Table of contents

7 parts

Sign up to add What if? to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Keeper of the Lost Cities: Forgetten by CresentMaiden

Betrayal after betrayal after betrayal. Three weeks since Keefe was seen by Sophie and her friends. Three weeks since Sophie's best friend turned his back on her. Three weeks since Sophie's heart was shattered. One day, a horrific incident happens and the Neverseen are to blame. But will Keefe be with them? Will he be his normal, fun loving self? Or someone completely different? Read this small fanfiction set between Shannon Messenger's Book 4 (Neverseen) and Book 5 (Lodestar). (This is my story set between Neverseen and Lodestar. I just imagined what the characters would do while they wait a year to get their next adventure and wrote it. Please don't steal it from me, it's not good enough to steal anyways.) *WARNING* TYPOS AND RUN ON PARAGRAPHS. READ AT OWN RISK. Cover by @ElvenNoir/SioCynder (tumblr)

Sokeefe - Until She Was Ready For More (unedited) by TeamFosterKeefe195

"Okay. Let's get this straight. For some bizarre reason, we wake up in the same bed and a six-year-old girl claims that we are her parents and refers to us as 'mommy and daddy'. This girl called us 'Sophie and Keefe Sencen'. She has your eyes and both of our hair. We also have absolutely no clue where we are." *** What happens when Sophie and Keefe are transported into an alternate dimension where they are married with kids? Will being stuck together cause their friendship to become something more or will everything crash and burn? Will they ever find their way home? *** All credits to @huntersofartemis109 for the story idea! Thanks so much for letting me use it too! Make sure to check out their story, 'Ms. Sencen?', which is what this book is based off of! Oh and credits to Shannon Messenger! Obviously! **Just a heads up, there are a few mature themes mentioned briefly, but I don't feel this story warrants a mature title. The mature bits are few and far between, and they're not graphic.

(Version1) The Protector Of Shadows - Kotlc by emmathekeeper

DISCONTINUED AND BEING REWRITTEN with minor plot changes (and with much better writing - hopefully) Newer version can be found on my profile. Thank you! Sophie Elizebeth Foster has no clue about her past what-so-ever. Her attempts to find out about it always ended in disaster. But just as she was about to give up, the truth found her instead.

The Aftermath by fumiguro

This story takes place after Sophie has defeated the Neverseen and before the elite levels. They have also never met Lihn and Tam. Sophie has defeated the Neverseen. But what happens when the universe decides it wants Sokeefe to happen? How many coincidences? How many accidents? At what cost will it take for the universe to get what it wants? new cover 2/20/2022 {|||||||||||||} #3 in sophiefoster 12/10/18 #2 in sophiefoster 12/11/18 #1 in sophiefoster 12/13/18

Impossible - KOTLC Fanfiction by somerandomhuman88

PLEASE NOTE - YOU DO NOT HAVE TO READ THE KOLTC BOOKS; THIS CAN BE READ ALONE. But, of course, there will be spoilers but I WILL try to limit it. ------------------------- *I've tried to keep this book as close as it can to the real Keeper books, but I am not Shannon Messenger, but, hey, I tried* Following the sixth book, Impossible is a twist of plots, and it starts at Alvar's Tribunal. Something terrible happens, so terrible that Sophie has decided to make a decision. One that will not only impact herself, but her family, not only her family, but her friends, not only her friends and family, but the whole Lost Cities. "These past few years... they've been amazing, you guys," Sophie started off. "...wait for it, you guys... going to be a 'but.'" Keefe said. "But.." Sophie choked on her words. "But what?" Biana asked. "But... all good things come to an end. I've decided to go back...and I think it's permanent." Everyone in the room held their breath. Finally, Keefe had the courage to ask "Back where?" Sophie took a breath. "Back to the Forbidden Cities." What will happen to Sophie? What will happen to the Lost Cities, now that their moonlark is gone? What HAD happened that made Sophie make this life-changing decision? Read to find out! After Sophie fixes her conflict as mentioned above, more and more mayhem cooks up in the Lost Cities. Will Sophie ever find a way to have a normal life?

We're Forever: A Sophitz Story by happyperson081

(Takes place after Flashback; Sophie isn't unmatchable) Fitz ruined his relationship with Sophie on a dare- but can he fix it and still get his happily ever after with the girl of his dreams?

Reborn by sophiethetelepath

Due to unknown reasons, Sophie Foster has just woken up in Book 1 at the museum with all her memories still intact. Now as a 12-year-old, Sophie must figure out how to make everything go right this time and try to stop the Neverseen in the process. This fanfiction was started in late 2018, right before Flashback was published. Please keep in mind that some of the ideas will reflect this. Everything in this fanfiction takes place before Legacy to avoid any confusion. Some ideas, wording, and dialogue are taken straight from Shannon Messenger's Keeper of the Lost Cities in order to make the plotline make sense. All rights for characters and general plot belong to Shannon Messenger.

A New Flame (Sotam Fanfic) by Tam-is-my-song

An alternate ending to Lodestar (Caution, may contain Lodestar/Nightfall spoilers!) (But you might have to read Nightfall to get it. You'll see.) What if Fitz didn't go through the mirror with Tam and Sophie in Lodestar? What if Fintan was slightly less sadistic but more cuckoo? Sophie and Tam have to go through a trial by fire (literally) and our multitalented moonlark and favorite shade discover a bond that only a select few experience. This is a Sotam fanfic as a heads up. Per usual, a disclaimer. Characters belong to the marvelous Shannon Messenger.

Nightfall (KotLC) by OwlieBoo

This is my version of what would happen after the end of Lodestar. I try to keep it true to the stories and how the characters would act. I'm so excited for the actual Nightfall book to come out! There are definitely spoilers from Lodestar, so don't read this if you haven't finished the series. *All characters, settings, and this cover belong to Shannon Messenger* *The quotes I put in each chapter belong to me (well the quotes are from kotlc but I made them like that so yeah)*

Everything Keeper Of The Lost Cities by SparkleDemigoddess03

The title says it all. There is a Part 2 on this account called Everything KOTLC 2 Also you may choose the cover. Would anyone like for me to do a Part 2 or just continue this until the next book comes out or until I loose intrest? Ships to expect in here #Dexiana / #Dizznacker / #Vackizznee / #Bex (Ship) / #Biana Vacker × Dex Dizznee, #Lylie / #Linh Song × Wylie Endal, #Rayni Aria × Tam Song, #Farella/ #Mitz / Marella Redek × Fitz Vacker and any canon ships plus #Vina / #Salin /Stina Heks × Valin and #Jaruca/ #Mensi/ #Maruca Chebota × Jensi Babblos. Etc tags #Sophie Foster × Keefe Sencen I also went to the limit so there will be a Part 2 that I will try to update whenever.

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Keeper of the Lost Cities: Forgetten cover

Sokeefe - Until She Was Ready For More (unedited) cover

(Version1) The Protector Of Shadows - Kotlc cover

The Aftermath cover

Impossible - KOTLC Fanfiction cover

We're Forever: A Sophitz Story cover

A New Flame (Sotam Fanfic) cover

Nightfall (KotLC) cover

Everything Keeper Of The Lost Cities cover

Keeper of the Lost Cities: Forgetten

Betrayal after betrayal after betrayal. Three weeks since Keefe was seen by Sophie and her friends. Three weeks since Sophie's best friend turned his back on her. Three weeks since Sophie's heart was shattered. One day, a horrific incident happens and the Neverseen are to blame. But will Keefe be with them? Will he be his normal, fun loving self? Or someone completely different? Read this small fanfiction set between Shannon Messenger's Book 4 (Neverseen) and Book 5 (Lodestar). (This is my story set between Neverseen and Lodestar. I just imagined what the characters would do while they wait a year to get their next adventure and wrote it. Please don't steal it from me, it's not good enough to steal anyways.) WARNING TYPOS AND RUN ON PARAGRAPHS. READ AT OWN RISK. Cover by @ElvenNoir/SioCynder (tumblr)