Ugly sweaters create romance. Michelle finds an awkward man in her department store who buys an ugly sweater. His purchase nabs her attention for longer than her shift. This young lady has a handsome boyfriend, who has style and suave. This new guy has none of it. Worst is his bad taste in clothing. However, Michelle cannot get this guy from her mind. Eventually, she helps him with his situation and they set the course for romance among ugly sweaters.