What if Puck was in Finn's position in season 1? What if Puck was recruited into glee club as the male lead? What if Puck was dating Quinn Fabray? What if Quinn cheated on Puck with Finn and fell pregnant to Finn's child? What if Rachel Berry fell for Noah? Season 1 re-write. HummelBerry friendship. Puckleberry and Fuinn endgames. NOT MY ORIGINAL STORY I DON'T OWN ANYTHING INCEPT THE PARTS I'M CONTINUING!