Why Me, Not Her? || Reader Insert - 𝔸𝕦𝕥𝕙𝕠𝕣 | 𝔽𝕒𝕚𝕣𝕪 - Wattpad

Story cover for Why Me, Not Her? || Reader Insert by Midnight_Melody906

Why Me, Not Her? || Reader Insert

Midnight_Melody906

Reads 199,342
Votes 105
Parts 3
Time 18m

Reads 199,342
Votes 105
Parts 3
Time 18m

Midnight_Melody906

Mature

fantasy femalereader harem healer isekai kings knight magic medieval ocs ocxreader otome prince reader readerinsert reverseharem slowburn slowupdates xreader yandere yanderexreader

[undergoing mass re-writing. no further updates till every chap is rewritten 💕]

Getting reborn as a knight of a game you once played with an extremely annoying System was fine and all until you realized that you were the same knight who died in every single route there ever was in that game. 

How fun, now with you doing your best to survive the crazy love interests of the heroine, how were you supposed to survive along with the System who seemed to hand out punishments like candy on Halloween? 

Especially when they all start to give you the same look as her. 

                             ~•○•~•●•~•○•~
 

DISCLAIMER: WE DO NOT OWN ANY OF THE PICTURES USED IN THIS STORY UNLESS STATED OTHERWISE. 



.All Rights Reserved

fantasy femalereader harem healer isekai kings knight magic medieval ocs ocxreader otome prince reader readerinsert reverseharem slowburn slowupdates xreader yandere yanderexreader

Table of contents

3 parts

Sign up to add Why Me, Not Her? || Reader Insert to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Knight in bloody armor by pipsqueaks89934

{Yandere male x female chubby reader} In a world with magical beings, there is a kingdom, far, far, away where a servant named Y/n lives. You work in the Palace and one day when you're tending to the flowers your friends come up to you saying that there's gonna be a ball at the end of the week that they're super excited about it but you're not. Since you have low self-esteem you think that no one's going to take you but there is someone who wants to take you (in more ways than one.) and has a BIG thing for you and will do anything for you, even kill for you. will you accept his feelings or not? [Remember that there is only one right answer.] ⚠️ WARNINGS⚠️ -Kidnapping -Swearing -Rape -Gore -Manipulation -Blood -Murder -SA -Violence -and more Please don't report or write anything mean or nasty, if you don't like it don't read it. Thank you for reading if you did and enjoy the story. STARTED: approx. August 22, 2023 ENDED: August 19, 2025

[Discontinued] Oh, my Emperor! (Yandere Emperor x reader) by Tokugawa-Lacrimosa

(Yandere Emperor x reader) Upon a near-death experience, you were running for your life from a killer who you rejected on top of a bridge only for it to collapse beneath the two of you, transporting you both into another world filled with a medieval fantasy fan's dream. Magic, horses, knights, royalty, nobles, and even mythical creatures! A world you would have never perceived as possible unless through fiction. Upon you and your killer's entrance, you both were greeted with the presence of an old emperor and a young prince-one being cautious, and another being curious. They immediately arrest your killer and took him away to the imperial prison and sentenced him to the gallows as a potential dangerous threat to the empire's safety. The others are wary of your presence and hope you are not like him. Most were curious about what kind of person you are whereas others did not take your appearance kindly. Among those who are curious is a handsome young prince whose eyes finally light up after years of mediocrity. Throughout the years, the people of this planet of Valtoria have been plagued with a dark king who is terrorizing the people of the planet and it is up to the prophesied Saintess who appears from another world to save everyone. You, on the other hand, would much prefer to go home... (I don't own any pictures used; cover is from ENA. Inspired by Empress of Another World and A Capable Maid.).

The Butterfly Bracelet [Yandere Prince x Female Reader] by J_C_Coltt

"A single night can change the course of your entire life." . . . [Yandere Prince x Female Reader] Once upon a time, in the tiny kingdom of Vascini, there lived a beautiful girl by the name of Y/N Magnifico. Y/N was born into one of the five most influential families in the whole country, but as the years passed the cruelty of her father only grew. Eventually, Y/N was forced to become a maid in her own home, and serve her new stepmother, and stepsisters. Y/N had given up hope for ever escaping her wicked family, until one day, a kind and handsome stranger rescued her and brought her to the Castle Vascini. Once there she discovered that her rescuer was actually the Royal Tutor, who had been ordered to find the prince a bride in the next three months. Indebted to the man for saving her from her terrible situation, Y/N had no choice but to agree to the tutor's crazy plan to turn her into the perfect bride for the prince. But what if this plan ended up working a bit too well? Despair and hopelessness lay behind her, while trickery, danger, and obsession wait in masquerade for Y/N. Will she be able to survive this re-telling of an old fairytale and life long enough to find true love, or will something much more twisted take its place? ⚠WARNING⚠ there will be a few mature themes in the book including (but not limited to): -domestic violence and abuse -trickery -sexual references -violence -mental illness -politics -murder -manipulation -obsession -gore Reader discretion is advised. ~J. C. Coltt.~

Reincarnated as the Villainess in a BL NOVEL!? by ItsSuzume

𝗧𝗛𝗜𝗦 𝗜𝗦 𝗠𝗬 𝗢𝗥𝗜𝗚𝗜𝗡𝗔𝗟 𝗦𝗧𝗢𝗥𝗬!! ✦━━━━━━༺༻━━━━━━✦ ➥ 𝑰𝒏 𝒘𝒉𝒊𝒄𝒉: I got reincarnated into a novel as the stupid villainess that every reader hated to the core. Basically, the most unloved character, even by the author. Santina Rubelia del León gets killed by her yandere fiancé who is also the male lead. Hahhh... It could be worse, right? WRONG! Why does it have to be a BL novel, for god's sake? The trashy male lead falls in love with the crown prince of another nation and causes the biggest war history has ever seen. "Santina, I want you to be my Empress." WAIT, WHAT? Why now? Does he want to use me to his advantage? Yeah, that's probably it! But then...? "I'll start a war." E-eh? What is this? "I'll kill him and destroy his entire kingdom. In fact, I'll erase it from the map, so... look at me... I beg you." Is he completely ignoring the crown prince? But why and for what reason, all of a sudden? Let me go, you crazy punk! I'M THE VILLAINESS! "...." He broke my other leg as well. When they say Angels have wings they mean they have legs. For humans legs are like wings. They take you places. This devil had broken my wings. ✦━━━━━━༺༻━━━━━━✦ 𝗪𝗲𝗲𝗸𝗹𝘆 𝘂𝗽𝗱𝗮𝘁𝗲𝘀!! ➥ mature themes and language ➥ status: finished! ♔ ───────── ♔ 𝑯𝑰𝑮𝑯𝑬𝑺𝑻 𝑹𝑨𝑵𝑲𝑰𝑵𝑮𝑺 (so far): ♔ ───────── ♔ #1 in maleyandere #1 aristocracy #1 crazy #1 reincarnated #1 noble #2 pastife #7 obsession #7 yandere #14 reincarnation

𝐅𝐢𝐜𝐭𝐢𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐮𝐬 by The_Dark_Mist

【 ꜰᴏʀᴍᴇʀ ʏᴀɴᴅᴇʀᴇ! ꜰ. ʀᴇᴀᴅᴇʀ x ᴍ!ʏᴀɴᴅᴇʀᴇ 】 This world has never felt real to you, especially when you found yourself obsessed with a certain boy in your class. It doesn't help that you felt some kind of force whispering to you to kill him in order to prove your love. So, you did. Strangely, the world seemed to be against him dying, because you found time kept repeating itself each time he died. You kept murdering him until a sudden epiphany dawned on you, as if you had broken away from the force controlling you. You were a character in a game-a villain who would always kill the protagonist. However, as if the developers knew you were no longer controllable, they replaced you so the boy you were obsessed with would still die and time would never move forward. Hence, you took it upon yourself to protect him. But why does the protagonist seem to be acting strange?

Til Death Tears Me Apart Once Again [Discontinued] by Neverxinagain

"If I'm going to die anyway, there's no point in trying to live." A typical reincarnated into a villainess story, except the protagonist isn't your typical 'I want my happy ending protagonist', but a death seeker. XX 《'Til Death Tears Me Apart, I Will Always Love You》is a very successful otome game. As much praise and admiration the game recieves, it is also, however, notorious for being absurdly difficult. One wrong step and the player would be drowning in an ocean of death flags, for both the Heroine and the Capture Targets. Anything short of perfection wouldn't even get the player a glimpse of a happy ending for the Capture Target the player chose. Enter me; Just a simple, normal girl reincarnated into a game as dangerous as that, as the villainess no less. Destined to die no matter what, I think there's no point in me trying to fight fate. If I'm going to die regardless, might as well die sooner rather than later. But that desire for death causes more than just a few changes to the definite plot; From little ones that have no effect at all, to life changing ones that may destroy the world of Arraxus. So the God of the world makes a deal with me: They'll give me a peaceful and happy afterlife, as long as I get a happy ending for myself. "Let the game begin!" -- Discontinued.

Crowns on the Floor by Cookie_fake_cookie

(Yandere!princes x reader) When (Y/N) finally returns to Earth, she expects to find a rebuilt world where her people can thrive. Little does she know, five princes are ready to do anything to get her, even kill and hurt her people. Where love is religion and mistakes lead to death, can (Y/N) really escape with her people? Or is she too far gone? 20th Nov 2025--- #1 in #yanderereverseharem 2nd Dec 2025-----#1 in #princes, #yanderereverseharemxreader

♡𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓥𝓲𝓵𝓵𝓪𝓲𝓷 𝓪𝓷𝓭 𝓨𝓪𝓷𝓭𝓮𝓻𝓮 ♡ by Akira_is_Poor

Fugitive!Mute!Yandere male x Villain!Reader "Do you...love me too?" - ♡ - Oh, how oblivious you were. If only you had recognized your mistakes sooner. Shamelessly ridiculing in front of him, tugging at her hair, leaving her in the shadows... You did all of this while thinking he saw her the same way. A worthless peasant. You thought your fiancé cherished you, but your mind distorted the reality and created a false image of him, which resulted in him falling for her without you even realizing it. You find yourself on death row for offenses you didn't commit, and you've lost all your support. With only three months remaining before your execution, you've resolved to put up a struggle, but first, you need to win the trust of a particular fugitive... Warnings: Blood, stabbing, slight manipulation, starvation, disturbing themes + Spelling mistakes, the writing isn't that good. Cover art is from pinterest! Started: 2/19/23 Ended: 11/24/23

The Obsessive Villainess Vol. 1 ✔ by youslippedaway

"Don't touch that man." "Why not?" "He has a beast guarding him." I am that beast; Nora. I woke up as the villain of this book, destined to die after going crazy due to my love for the main lead. "I spent my last life wanting to die, and now that I've decided to survive, this world is after me?" No. I won't die such a pathetic death. I will survive this time. No matter what. But first, I need to survive these main leads. One won't leave me alone; the other keeps fighting with me; another is destined to kill me... Even my superpowers are so weak! Surviving in a world that hates me... Is kinda difficult. *** I got tired of reading about 'special' and 'pure-hearted' heroines so I decided to write about a character I could relate to. Writing gets better after first few chapters. [#1 Angst] [#1 Obsession] [#2 Yandere] [#1 Villain] [#1 Antagonist] [#1 Superpowers]

You may also like

Slide 1 of 9

Knight in bloody armor cover

[Discontinued] Oh, my Emperor! (Yandere Emperor x reader) cover

The Butterfly Bracelet [Yandere Prince x Female Reader] cover

Reincarnated as the Villainess in a BL NOVEL!? cover

𝐅𝐢𝐜𝐭𝐢𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐮𝐬 cover

Til Death Tears Me Apart Once Again [Discontinued] cover

Crowns on the Floor cover

♡𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓥𝓲𝓵𝓵𝓪𝓲𝓷 𝓪𝓷𝓭 𝓨𝓪𝓷𝓭𝓮𝓻𝓮 ♡ cover

The Obsessive Villainess Vol. 1 ✔ cover

Knight in bloody armor

{Yandere male x female chubby reader} In a world with magical beings, there is a kingdom, far, far, away where a servant named Y/n lives. You work in the Palace and one day when you're tending to the flowers your friends come up to you saying that there's gonna be a ball at the end of the week that they're super excited about it but you're not. Since you have low self-esteem you think that no one's going to take you but there is someone who wants to take you (in more ways than one.) and has a BIG thing for you and will do anything for you, even kill for you. will you accept his feelings or not? [Remember that there is only one right answer.] ⚠️ WARNINGS⚠️ -Kidnapping -Swearing -Rape -Gore -Manipulation -Blood -Murder -SA -Violence -and more Please don't report or write anything mean or nasty, if you don't like it don't read it. Thank you for reading if you did and enjoy the story. STARTED: approx. August 22, 2023 ENDED: August 19, 2025