Winchester at the Pony Express
- Reads 243
- Votes 6
- Parts 8
Ongoing54m
Last published Mon, Aug 18, 2025
Isabelle Winchester, better known as Belle, has had some crazy things happen in her life.
After all, her and her older brothers Dean and Sam are the best hunters the world has ever seen.
But when things go awry during a case, Belle finds herself in a predicament.
She has been sent back in time to the Wild West.
With no way home to her brothers.
While she tries to learn to blend in with life style, she discovers that this world and hers are extremely different.
Will she be able to find a way home?
And if she does, will she want to return to a world where monsters exist while leaving her new family behind?
*a mix of two of my all time favorite shows:
Supernatural and The Young Riders*
All Rights Reserved
#895
buck
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Moments (TVD/SPN crossover)*discontinued*
Layla Winchester, one of the best hunters in the world after training from a very young age, as well as being Sam and Dean Winchester's sixteen year old sister. She's not scared of almost anything, but there's a few things that have scared her, and the thing that scared her the most was the idea of losing her brothers. Anyhow, after a few months of having Sam back on hunts with them, she had become more fun and carefree according to Dean. One day they get a call about a haunted house in Mystic Falls, Virgina. Layla found the name to be almost like a fairytale, but the town itself was nothing like a fairytale. While in Mystic Falls, Layla meets Elena and they instantly become friends. Hearing from a local in town, Layla is told that supernatural accurances popped up all the time in Mystic Falls, so Layla tries to convince her brothers into letting her stay with Elena, promising to take on hunts locally as well as in different states when she finds them. Will her brothers agree? Will she find out about the supernatural creatures in Mystic Falls? Read and find out...Complete
Graceful Jack (Supernatural)
On a what was supposed to be fun family outing, Dean, Sam, Cas and Jack stumble across a succubus that is terrorizing a town. Running into another group of hunters, Sam and Dean make the decision to work alongside of Syd and Fee, who seem to have a pretty good understanding of hunter life. While Syd works closely with Sam, it is Fee and Jack surprisingly get closer. Jack has a school-boy crush on her while Fee is out living her best life. SPOILERS! (This is season 14.) Please note: *While I have seen every episode of Supernatural, I do NOT have a large understanding of the world. Apologies for things that will be wrong. *I wrote this in five hours because procrastinating about life. It isn't my best work, but it's okay. *Jack is adorable in the TV show. If you're interested, please vote and comment. I would love to hear back from you. As well as, my other stories are located below.Complete
Running with the wolves (Supernatural x Wolfblood) BOOK 1
Leona was not like your average girl. She was running away but what happens when she runs into two of the most infamous hunters? Best rankings #1 - Jaredpadalecki (01/18-22) #1 - Jimbeaver (08/12-20) #1 - Wolfblood (02/04-21) #1 - Winchester (03/05-21) #2 - Jensenackles (08/25-20) #4 - Impala (10/17-20) #12 - Deanwinchester (02/23-21) #20 - Samwinchester (08/25-20) #75 - Supernatural (10/18-20) Takes place in Season 3. Some dialogue and scenes may not be totally the same. I am taking inspiration from Wolfblood to create my own character. English is not my first language so sorry for any mistakes. All rights goes to CW and WB as well as BBC for Wolfblood. I don't own anyone besides Leona and her storyline.Complete
Maddison Winchester: Journal 6 {Supernatural} (Editing)
All hunters know that the only way out of "the life" is through death. Dean and Maddison, on the other hand, appear to have managed to simply step away and retire. Will a life behind a white picket fence be enough to keep them occupied, or will something drag them back into hunting? * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Maddison Winchester is the much younger half-sister of Sam and Dean Winchester. Her story takes place from seasons 1 to 15 and is told through her eyes. This is my version of Supernatural if Sam and Dean had a younger sister. If, for some reason, you have come across this story and have not yet watched the Supernatural series, you should definitely start binge-watching it on Netflix right away. If you don't want to, that's perfectly fine too. My story will follow along very closely with the storyline of the series. I do not own the Supernatural series in any way. Maddison Winchester is the only main character that I own. Please leave comments and let me know what you guys think. 😊 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Completed 03/27/2020Complete
Not so Natural
Maddison Harris is a bit of an unusual girl, always has been and always will be. When she meets the two young lads, Sam and Dean Winchester will she finally find someone who accepts her for who she is and what life she has been taught to lead. Or will they find out her secret to early before she can explain. All of the rights go to the original owners. I do not claim any of the characters in this story (except for my own) to be my own. DO NOT READ IF YOU HAVEN'T AT LEAST FINISHED SEASON 4. (But hey I'm not stopping you if you wish to read) It doesn't follow the story line what so ever just I need Cas so it has to be at least after season 4. I'm only not following the story line because it will be way to painful to go back though 11 seasons just to write this. So it will only follow monsters they hunted (in later seasons as well) but won't contain any major spoilers. Won't even follow how they defeated said monster/supernatural being. Will even add some of my own if my imagination is working.Complete
Reawakening || Book 1 of 'Reawakening Series'
I felt sick to my stomach, nerves overcoming me at the thought of seeing him again after all these years. I know he's going to be angry, furious in fact and I know this will be one of the most difficult moments of my life, which is big seeing what I've been through. But I will see him again, and that is something I've only ever dreamed of. Addison Jones wasn't born a hunter, she was thrust into it against her will. After John Winchester was involved in hunt that left Addy an orphan at the age of fourteen, he took her in and made her apart of the family, t aching her the family business. There she met Dean Winchester, where the two madly fell in love. But after unforeseeable circumstances overcoming her, she was forced to leave behind the one man she would ever love. Three years on and now she's back due to orders, much to the confusion and anger of Dean. Old feelings emerge mixed with anger and resentment. Will the two ever get back together? Will they ever make it past this incident? Will Addy ever tell Dean the reason she left and broke his heart? I do not own any of the 'Supernatural' characters or plot lines, however I do own my original characters and plot lines and I will not tolerate them being stolen. This is the first book of the 'Reawakening' series, Fortitude is Book 2, and Denouement is Book 3. Copyright ree_louiseComplete
The Forgotten Winchester (Gabriel Fanfic)
Cassandra Winchester. The youngest Winchester. The forgotten one. While Sam and Dean were raised to be hunters, Cassandra was left behind like an afterthought no one wanted to claim. After her mother died giving birth to her, John Winchester buried himself in revenge and grief-leaving Cassandra to grow up invisible in the shadow of her brothers. Ignored by her father. Overlooked by Sam and Dean. The only person who ever truly cared was Bobby Singer. Dragged from town to town her entire life, Cassandra learned early that nobody notices the quiet girl sitting alone in the back of the classroom. The bruises from bullying faded eventually... but the damage never did. Now at 20, Cassandra lives with depression, anxiety, PTSD, insomnia, and selective mutism. Nightmares keep her awake. Scars hide beneath her sleeves. And every day feels like a battle just to exist in a family that barely remembers she's there. Still... some small part of her keeps hoping. Hoping her brothers will finally see her. Hoping someone will realize she's drowning before it's too late. But when a certain archangel becomes the first person to truly notice her pain, Cassandra's world begins to change in ways she never expected. In the middle of monsters, angels, and the apocalypse itself, she may finally discover what it feels like to be wanted... to be loved. The question is- Will Sam and Dean realize what they've done before they lose their sister forever? Or will the forgotten Winchester finally disappear for good?Complete
Nothing Done Right (Benny Lafitte Fanfic)
*YES I KNOW JO AND ASH AREN'T RELATED BUT THEY ARE FOR THE SAKE OF THE STORY SO SHUT UP* Mona Harvelle has spent her whole life feeling like she can't get anything right. Timid, clumsy, and haunted by a father she never knew, she hides her pain behind awkward smiles and quiet apologies. Life has been lonely, boring, and full of mistakes she can't seem to fix. Then a group of hunters arrives at the Harvelle Roadhouse-and for the first time, Mona feels alive. Laughter, danger, and excitement pull her out of her rut, but they also force her to face the fears she's been running from. Will she finally find love, courage, and a place she belongs... or will everything she holds dear be lost forever?Complete
𝗕𝗢𝗬𝗦 𝗗𝗢𝗡'𝗧 𝗖𝗥𝗬 , supernatural
The day Sam and Dean met their younger brother, Landon Winchester, their lives all changed. For better or worse has yet to be determined. ◦•◦ seasons 3 - ?? *slow updates* ◦•◦ WARNING ; bloody/gory descriptions, major character deaths, minor characters deaths, alcohol/drug abuse, sexual content, mentions of physical/mental abuse, triggering topics. ◦•◦ all rights of supernatural characters and plots -minus the ones i've created/added- belong to the creators of supernatural
Of Heaven and Hell (Gabriel)
Summary: While dealing with a brother off the rails and a brother in Hell, on top of her Prophet of the Lord powers developing more. Harlene "Harley" Rose Winchester, the youngest of the Winchester siblings, strives to reunite her family once again. But what will happen when a certain Archangel takes an interest? Disclaimer: we do not own anything that is shown in supernatural. All that belongs to us is our OC Harley and any changes we make or any other OCs. Sam is eleven months older than Harley, which means Mary dies when Dean is 5 years old, Sam is 17 months and Harley 6 months. Set from season four onwards. Gabriel Love Story! COMPLETED!!!! Cover made by @vintagewanda {started: 10/06/2021} {finished: 30/05/2023} #1 Claire Novak 27/02/2023😁😁💚💚 #5 tv show fanfic 6/11/2022 #6 tv show fanfic 4/11/2022 #13 Bobby Singer 6/8/2022 #1 Claire Novak 4/4/2022😁😁💚💚 #1 Claire Novak 7/1/2022😁😁💚💚 #12 Gabriel 5/12/2021 #14 Gabriel 17/10/2021 #46 Lucifer 25/9/2021 #27 angels 5/8/2021 #10 heaven 1/8/2021 #24 Bobby singer 17/7/2021 #2 Claire Novak 17/6/2021Complete
Layla Winchester, one of the best hunters in the world after training from a very young age, as well as being Sam and Dean Winchester's sixteen year old sister. She's not scared of almost anything, but there's a few things that have scared her, and the thing that scared her the most was the idea of losing her brothers. Anyhow, after a few months of having Sam back on hunts with them, she had become more fun and carefree according to Dean. One day they get a call about a haunted house in Mystic Falls, Virgina. Layla found the name to be almost like a fairytale, but the town itself was nothing like a fairytale. While in Mystic Falls, Layla meets Elena and they instantly become friends. Hearing from a local in town, Layla is told that supernatural accurances popped up all the time in Mystic Falls, so Layla tries to convince her brothers into letting her stay with Elena, promising to take on hunts locally as well as in different states when she finds them. Will her brothers agree? Will she find out about the supernatural creatures in Mystic Falls? Read and find out...
More detailsContent Guidelines