How Lucky Am I?

Amanda O'grady just wants to enjoy her summer cruise to the Bahamas but it's spoiled when the annoying Conner Baker ends up on the same trip. After the ship is captured by two armed robbers, Amanda and Conner end up being thrown overboard and wash up on a deserted island. As her feelings grow towards Conner, a plane crashes into a lake nearby. As luck would have it, Amanda's life-long crush, Dylan Rider was on that very plane and joins the two teens in their hope for survival and rescue. Now that Dylan has come, he presents a threat to Conner and an opportunity for Amanda to reveal her feelings. Will she be forced to choose sides or will her unbelievably annoying luck get in the way of her first love and their hopes of rescue?