Fae Evans is forever getting her heart broken - falling in love only to be thrown aside like a child's toy and forgotten - but her hope for true love lives on in the form of the hopeless romantic stories she writes in her spare time. Trevor Michaels is forever wooing a woman as entertainment for the night - at least before he got stuck with the incessant brat, Margaret Karol - but then he meets a nameless beauty that's more than what meets the eye. Fae can't resist a good heartbreak when she sees one, and she sees one in a particularly attractive stranger who decides that he wants to show up in her café; Trevor can't resist the challenge of winning over a certain woman, one so different from the rest.