Forgotten Prey (Male Reader × Eyeless Jack)

The knife burned lines through your skin. Engraving a permanent smile across your pale skin. You screamed and thrashed, anything to stop the monster who had you.

he let out a sickening laugh, releasing his grip around your neck.

"There! look at that smile!"

you opened your eyes to see a tall man in a white hoodie. His face scared with the same smile he had given you. "You fucking monster!" you yelled, ignoring the pain from your cuts. He frowned. "it's not very nice to call people names." He smiled again. "it's late ya know... I think, maybe you should." he paused to laugh. his hand made its way back to your throat. He laughed as he stabbed you. over and over, your body covered in blood. your eyes widened as he did so. you were overwhelmed with pain. He stopped stabbing and brought his face closer to yours. "go to sleep" he smirked as he whispered in your ear. He jerked away, letting your body slide down the tree.

You watched as his body faded away into the darkness of the forest. You were scared to move. Scared that if he saw you he'd come back and finish you off.

You laid there for hours, crying silently. You were just about to give up, just about to let your eyes shut and let the darkness of death consume you. But something emerged from the darkness. It was a person. He was dressed in black, the only splash of color being the Blue mask he wore. You couldn't tell if you should be relieved or scared. But soon, it didn't matter. You shut your eyes, falling unconscious as the figure approached you.