After Livvie Locke's plan to get Caleb Morley to seduce her with a love spell fails and leads Caleb to make love to Allison Barrington instead, Caleb falls head over heels in love with Allison, leaving Livvie out in the cold. Livvie desperately tries to break the spell to make Caleb hers again as Caleb becomes more and more obsessed with Allison, despite the objections of Allison's fiance, Rafe Kolvitch. Will Livvie break the spell she put on Caleb, or will Caleb be destined to live his immortal life obsessed with Allison?