A SOULMATE WHO WASN'T MEANT TO BE; fear street 1994, 1978, 1666 x fem!reader

"Stranger, who knows all my secrets
Can pull me apart and break my heart
A soulmate who wasn't meant to be"

1994 | Living in Shadyside isn't exactly ideal. According to townspeople it's "cursed by the witch". But those are just stories, right? The brutal killings that happen every few years have nothing to do with Sarah Fier. They're just coincidence.
But after a car accident Y/N L/N finds herself with her friends, being chased around by the long dead killers from years before. But the witch isn't real. There's no way.

1978 | Y/N L/N and her brothers are sent to Camp Nightwing for the Summer. Lots of fun like swimming, archery, being brutally murdered by one of the councelors, arts and crafts and the annual colour war of Shadyside vs Sunnyvale.
Y/N had barely spoken to Cindy Berman since the snitching incident when they were kids, but she couldn't help how she felt. But she doesn't stand a chance when Cindy's dating Tommy Slater. But maybe things will change this Summer.

1666 | Strange things had begun to happen in Union, and the people who live in the town are blaming it on witchcraft. Especially after Mad Thomas saw Sarah Fier and Hannah Miller.
Y/N L/N had fallen in love with Isaac, a boy her age who lived in the settlement. The two of them seem to work, but would her parents allow it?

1994 | simon x reader
1978 | cindy x reader
1666 | isaac x reader