The Grave Mistake
- Reads 58,761
- Votes 2,390
- Parts 28
MatureOngoing6h 47m
Last published Mon, Jun 22, 2026
What if Lily hadn't had one but two baby boys? Harry James Potter and his brother Wilson Fleamont Potter were twins yet it was always easy to spot the difference in the boys. Harry had their mother's green Avada Kedavra eyes while Wilson had their fathers Hazel eyes. Harry had his fathers poor eyesight while Wilson had perfect vision. Harry looked like his father while Wilson looked more like Lily while he still had bits of his father in him. What if Dumbledore thought of Wilson to be the child of the Prophecy? Is there even a prophecy? What if Voldemort and Harry had a connection deeper then most would believe to be true?
He may not be The-Boy-Who-Lived. But he is The-Boy-Who-Loved. The world would soon know it too...
....
All rights belong to J.K. Rowling
This idea was somewhat inspired by so many fics I have read about Tomarry but it will also be original in my own way
Do not be offended and do not hate if it is bad. I am not a good writer
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Bud
What if a certain red headed girl had a twin brother? What if said twin brother was a seer and didn't know it? Lily Evans' twin brother Bud finds out the hard way the future isn't very bright. He does, however, find out it can be changed. Now can it change for the better is the question. See what happens when Bud Evans does to change it ((I did update the description, hope this one is better then the last. I am also planning to make this a long book so please bare with me if it takes a while to update. I'm actually really into this story I just don't always update when i know i should))Complete
A Different Sister (Editing)
Everyone knows about Harry James Potter, the Boy who Lived. But what if he had a sister, who no one even bothers to mention, just because she doesn't have a lightning bolt scar? Emma Lily Potter HATES her brother. Stupid Harry with his stupid scar and stupid broomstick. She's convinced that she's a hundred times better than he is. She's a natural at Quidditch, excellent at Potions and Transfiguration, and is Slytherin's star student. So why is her brother still getting all the attention for something he doesn't even remember he did? Harry James Potter doesn't want this attention. Not when his sister hates him for it. He'd do anything to get out of the spotlight and push his sister into it. But reality is reality, and he's the one with the scar, not Emma. To be honest, Emma would be an awesome Girl who Lived. Compared to her, Harry was nothing. So what if he could catch a Snitch? So could she. He wasn't particularly good at anything else, and Snape hates him amd makes his life at Hogwarts miserable. One wrong thing said, and the twins' relationship shatters. They go their separate ways, and when I say separate, I mean separate. But evil lurks at Hogwarts, inside them and in their pasts. Will they face it together, or will they succumb to evil because they aren't strong enough without each other?Complete
Rose Lily Evans (H.P. FanFic) 1
Book One ---------------- Prophecy series ---------------- Harry James Potter. The boy who lived. What if there was another person who lived that night. Someone that no one knew about. Rose Lily Potter. The girl who survived. She might not have a scar like Harry, but that doesn't mean she's not important. But shes not the chosen one, what could possibly make her so important? _-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_ Based off of year one and year two ------------------------- Written in 2013 Published in 2014. Lightly edited and Completed in 2020. -------------------------- I don't own anything except for Rose, and anyone else along the way. Everything is originally from J.K. Rowling. If you got complaints take it up with her!!! Not my comments! Thank you for giving this a chance! Lots of love ~ snowflake ;-)Complete
What If ✔
What if James and Lily Potter came back alive? What if Sirius Black, Remus Lupin and Fred Weasley returned? What if there was a prophecy made that if Harry Potter defeated Voldemort then his closest friends and family will return from the dead? What if... (This is a story set after Voldemorts defeat) 𝐃𝐢𝐬𝐜𝐥𝐚𝐢𝐦𝐞𝐫: ⚠️ I own none of the characters made by J.K Rowling except for the ones I make up. I own nothing but the storyline. All credit goes to J.K Rowling for creating the HP World, characters and places mentioned in this story. ⚠️ 𝐁𝐄𝐒𝐓 𝐑𝐀𝐍𝐊𝐈𝐍𝐆𝐒: #1 hedwig 14 Sep 2021 #1 ministryofmagic 7 Dec 2022 #1 afterthewar 6 Feb 2023 #2 return 20 Oct 2021 #2 nymphadora 2 Dec 2021 #2 ronaldweasley 17 Aug 2023 #3 hinny 16 Mar 2022Complete
The Thunder without Lightning [ Tomarry
Lighting without thunder. Night without day. One without the other would be unnatural. An anomaly. A warning. A battle cry. Lightning would serve as the warning. If you are in close enough range, you will see the flashes- and inevitably hear the thunder. The closer you are, the louder it gets. One without the other would be an unnatural phenomenon, signalling the apocalypse. In Harry Potter's sixth year, he was sent back in time to Tom Riddle's sixth year to try and help him see the light before he ventured too far into darkness. But what if the plans stray a little bit too far from the omniscient eyes? A three-chapter oneshot for the pairing Harry x Voldemort / TomarryComplete
I'm a what?! - rewrite (HP/Marvel crossover)(Complete)
What if Harry potter wasn't actually Harry potter? What if he wasn't the son of Lily and James potter? What if he wasn't a boy at all? What if he is the daughter of Loki and Bruce banner? When Harry comes into an early inheritance after a strong beating. He finds out everything is a lie. And Dumbledore is the real dark lord? (WARNING I HAVE DYSLEXIA SO SPELLING AND GRAMMAR AREN'T VERY GOOD)Complete
So Many Secrets.
Harry Potter. The only survivor when Lord Voldemort attacked his home. His parents died, the house was destroyed, but he made it, with nothing more than a scar on his head. Now, Harry Potter is starting Hogwarts. His family is glad to see him go, and the Wizarding world is happy to see him come. But what if, the Wizarding world was wrong about Harry Potter? What if he isn't as strong as they thought? What if his home life isn't as grand as they all expected? Why does Harry Potter have so many secrets, and will anyone be able to uncover them? TRIGGER WARNING!!!: STRONG MENTIONS OF SUICIDE, SELF HARM, ABUSE, S*XUAL ABUSE, ECT. ECT.! DO. NOT. READ. IF. THESE. MAKE. YOU. UNCOMFORTABLE!!! PLEASE!!!! Also... THIS IS NOT SNARRY! ABSOLUTELY NOT SNARRY!!! DO NOT ACT AS IF IT IS SNARRY! THIS IS AN ELEVEN YEAR OLD CHILD! If that is your thing that is perfectly fine, but as I said, this is an underaged child and a thirty something year old adult. It makes me very uncomfortable, so please do not act as if this is Snarry or associate it with Snarry in any way. Do not repost on any other website/account without my permission! Thank you!Complete
Freckles || Drarry
Harry Potter has his mothers red hair and his father's hazel eyes. He constantly gets told how much he looks like his mother. His eyes have little flecks of green that remind him of something from when he was a baby - and he can never quite pinpoint what. When he gets his letter to Hogwarts he finally finds out. He meets a boy called Draco Malfoy, and despite a misunderstanding (and something about a weasel?) They become fast friends. A few years later they decide that just isn't enough. Harry can't stop thinking about Draco's stormy eyes and Draco simply adores Harry's freckles. (Just a PSA for the hardcore fans, this won't follow much of the original story and will most probably be filled with non-canon things that will be canon for this fic. If you find any mistakes that seem way too out of reach, please tell me and I'll alter it.)Complete
What if a certain red headed girl had a twin brother? What if said twin brother was a seer and didn't know it? Lily Evans' twin brother Bud finds out the hard way the future isn't very bright. He does, however, find out it can be changed. Now can it change for the better is the question. See what happens when Bud Evans does to change it ((I did update the description, hope this one is better then the last. I am also planning to make this a long book so please bare with me if it takes a while to update. I'm actually really into this story I just don't always update when i know i should))
More detailsContent Guidelines