Torn Between Choices
- Reads 190
- Votes 19
- Parts 1
Ongoing5m
Last published Sun, Dec 21, 2014
I have to choose.
My brother's best friend. Or my brother's enemy.
I'm Lyric Potter, younger sister of the famous James Potter.
I'm in Gryffindor like him. Like our parents expected me to be.
Yeah, they expect me to be just like 'perfect James.' Gosh, I never hear the end of it, "Why can't you be more like your brother?" or "But James did it so you should be able to."
I get sick of it. Nobody understands that I'm NOT James. Or so I thought.
I met Severus Snape.
My brother's arch enemy.
I started hanging out with him. He was nice, kind, and underestimated.
But then, when I look at Remus Lupin my heart skips a beat. His perfect laugh his small smile. It's all so perfect.
Who should I choose.
If I choose Severus James will hate me and I'll never hear the end of it.
But I'm scared what James would do to Remus. James is so protective of me. But his ego get's in the way of him realizing I'm 14 years old. I'm not a little girl anymore.
I'm afraid. But what happens if something happens that I can't control? What then? Also, Sirius Black is living with us and my parents think he too is perfect. Why? I'll never know. They think that James is a star student and a role model. The teachers think so too.
If one more person says that I should be like my brother or that my brother is perfect or that I should be just the same I swear I'll scream. I AM NOT MY BROTHER! And I won't remain torn between choices for long. I WILL choose.
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
James Potter's Durmstrang Twin: Marauders/Remus Lupin Fanfic
Hi!!! My name is Oswin Christina Potter. Yup, you heard right. I'm the twin of the famous James Potter. I have brown hair and bright blue eyes. However, I'm famous at my own school. No, I don't go to Hogwarts. I am the only girl at Durmstrang, the wizarding school in Bulgaria. I play on their Quidditch team as the Keeper, and I love pranking, so I tend to do subtle pranks when I'm not at the school. There, I am prank crazy, and friends with all the guys. Unfortunately, I am also part Veela, which can be annoying in a school full of boys, but they know not to try anything. The last guy who did ended up in St. Mungo's for almost the entire year. I also have a dragon friend Laelynn, who's name means hope. When I touched her when she was first born out of her golden egg, she turned my palm of my left hand a brilliant silver, which I have to hide under a glove, and gave me the ability to do magic without a wand. I have also mastered non-verbal spells. Anyway, I just found out I will be going to Hogwarts for the last two years of my education, meaning I get to see my twin and do some pranking! Yay! I will be riding Laelynn there, and we will definitely make an entrance, especially into the Great Hall. We have a whole routine worked out where I will be the main part of the big finale. Can't wait to make an impression! My brother has written to me and told me he found some great prankers, let's see if they live up to my standards. I only own my characters and storyline. Any other characters belong to their creators, and other similarities are not meant as copyright infringement, only inspiration and fanfiction. There will be some drama between Remus Lupin and Oswin Potter when they finally get together. I may or may not have them not tell the others about them for a while, but I'm not sure yet. I hope you like it!! (Completed)Complete
Loving the Moon (Marauders Fan Fiction)
The name's Potter, Harper Quinn Potter. My brother is James Potter. I've gone to Beauxbatons for the past 5 years of being a witch. I'm 15 years old and transferring to Hogwarts to go to school with James and his friends. I was expelled for pranking the headmaster too many times, 24 times to be exact and I'm proud of it! I'm 1/8th veela but I still have the veela qualities of enchanting beauty, graceful movements, and the smarts of being a veela. I hate it. That's why I prank, to let people focus on another side of me. James has made sure to never let me have a boyfriend but I'm a great flirt to those boys who play with girl's hearts. Payback's a pain. I'm a werewolf with a little twist. Beautiful but dangerous, just like me. I'm stubborn and when people try to tell me what to do, I rarely listen. Well behaved women rarely make history.Complete
The Other One | Sirius Black
"I'm sorry, I just... remembered something," she muttered as her fingers traced the scars on her throat. He placed his hands on her shoulders before whispering, "It's just me." "It's just you," she sighed. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Joanna Potter has always been in the shadow of her older brother and his friends, but when she befriends both of the Black brothers it's more than she bargained for. At Hogwarts, the war seemed far away, but she gets pulled right into the middle of it with a huge betrayal from one of them. Has Jo been placing her trust in the wrong person or is there more they aren't letting on? Spotify playlist: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3yOjU2CRHM1ztBy8eqix7n?si=SlKUDz-tQQ6LXRr34HrR4Q&utm_source=copy-link (I do not condone Rowling's transphobic beliefs, so let's set aside the person from the work.)Complete
𝕴 𝖉𝖔𝖓'𝖙 𝖑𝖔𝖛𝖊 𝖞𝖔𝖚 ~ Regulus black x reader
***in editing*** ***sequel in progress*** you were James potter's little sister only there's one problem, you're a Slytherin and he's a Gryffindor. who will you choose when the dark lord rises? your friends and boyfriend who have supported you no matter what. or your family, who is slightly dysfunctional, but still we're related right? when it comes down to it though, love is blinding and will trick even the smartest of people.Complete
Selfless
"I love you and I want you to be happy... even if it's not with me" Remus was your first love and you were his. But what happens when you start to see him look at someone else the way he used to look at you? Do you ignore it and try to keep something you know isn't real anymore from falling apart? Or do you love him enough to let him go? This year... you have to decide between his heart and yours.Complete
Dangerous Game ~Mattheo Riddle~ Tome 1
🥇and 🥈#mattheoriddle 06.2025 🥇#dracomalfoy 08.2025 🥇#spying 09.2025 🥇#task 09.2025 🥇#alcohol 09.2025 *- You know what ? I'm sure you're in love with me. You just don't want to admit it. - Yeah, that's it. I said sarcastically. Even for a million Galleons, I'd never date you. You're disgusting, Riddle. - Well, let's see how much I disgust you, Princess. I've got a proposition. We're gonna play a game. Here are the rules : the first one of us to fall in love with the other loses. We can flirt, kiss, even fuck each other, no strings attached. Are you in, or are you afraid to lose to my natural beauty ? - I'm already the winner, Riddle. - We'll see, Wilson. - Okayyyy ! This is gonna be interesting... Game's on, everyone ! Theodore added, practically cheering. ~~ Tessa Wilson, born into a Death Eater family, is entering her sixth year at Hogwarts. But this year won't just test her skills, it will shatter her certainties. Her biggest challenge? Her own mind. Her confusion. The feelings she's afraid of. Mattheo Riddle, heir to a cursed name, is trouble wrapped in charm and arrogance. Love ? He doesn't know it. Doesn't trust it. Doesn't want it. They'll hate. They'll bet. They'll play. They'll hurt. But will they learn how to love? Hate will bind them. Love might break them. But nothing will leave them unscarred. ⚠️TW : explicit sexual scenes, cursing, bad mental health, self harm, bullying, torture⚠️ I'll put a ♤ whenever there's hot fluff or smutt. Don't stop on the first chapters ! My writing gets better by the time and the story too since I started it more than a year ago. this is JK ROLLING'S universe ! I only own Tessa Wilson, her life, every things that turns around her and Emily and Timothy Lerson . The chronology won't be totally respected (like Snape is still the potion professor, there's gonna be a yule ball, ect...). English isn't my first language, I'm French so I apologise for the spelling, grammar or conjugatComplete
Dumbledore's Heir-Remastered
My name is Ariana, but lately everyone around me had been calling me Black. That's what they call me. That color they labeled me with means nothing to me. It's Ironic since I am the complete opposite of it. I have snowy white hair and blue eyes. Why did they give me that name then? I don't know but I am tired of taking that from them. I'm leaving and hopefully my life get's a little more enjoyable. I am not going to be the black stain for anyone. No more. Today I am free. -THIS IS NOT A SEQUEL, JUST AN EDITED VERSION.- I do not under any circumstances own Harry Potter or the world of Harry Potter. J.K Rowling does. I am just a fan making my own representation of the story that we came to know and love.Complete
Nyctophobia - Sirius Black
Ruby Snape vowed to protect her younger twin brother to the very end, but when he goes to Hogwarts, she is stuck at home, despite being a witch. Now she's finally able to learn at the school instead out of her brother's textbooks on his vacations, only to find out that her brother is being bullied by four infamous pranksters. How far will she go to protect her brother? And what will happen when one of his bullies starts to fall for her? Disclaimer: the entire Harry Potter universe belongs to J. K. Rowling, not me. I only own my OC, Ruby Snape, and any other I add that aren't in the Harry Potter universe, and my story line. Warning: Abuse! I'm not sure how descriptive it will get, but probably very descriptive, so please proceed with discretion. There will also be panic attacks, phobias, and bullying scenes. I work hard to make my stories original. Please do not plagiarize. This story is also on Quotev, so if you see it there, it's not plagiarized. #2 in marauders 4/3/2020 #1 in luciusmalfoy 4/14/2020 #1 in narcissablack 4/14/2020 #1 in carrow 1/1/2021 #1 in alicefortesque 1/1/2021 #1 in siriusblackxoc 1/1/2021Complete
Sirius Black's Sister
Sirius Black has a twin sister who always want to impress her parents. So when they get accepted into Hogwarts their parents are happy for them. So when Sirius is sorted into Gryffindor he expects his sister to be happy for him but all he see's is disappointment. Sirius's sister is sorted into Slytherin and he's a happy for her. Since Sirius didn't write to his parents, his sister did instead and they send their son a howler. Sirius's sister meets lots of new people but she and Severus Snape fall for each other. Her parents don't care that he's a half-blood since he's a Voldemort follower. Marauders Era.Complete
Regulus x Marissa(OC)
Everyone saw me as perfect, I always had been my whole life. I was Regulus Black, I was raised to be perfect. I was everything that my parents wanted me to be. Pureblood, Slytherin, and the opposite of my brother. My brother was Sirius Black, known as the heart throb of Hogwarts. My parents hated him. He had been sorted into Gryffindor. He had been set free. I have always been jealous of him, he isn't stuck being controlled. He has forgotten about me, moved on completely. He once promised me that we would both escape together, but he broke it. How could I forgive him for that? He ran away over the summer and left me there. "Sorry." I was pulled out of my thoughts when I heard that oh so beautiful voice. "Sorry Marisa, I didn't mean to bump into you!" Some random kid who I didn't know exclaimed. "It was my fault, I should have been more careful." Marisa smiled. My heart skipped a beat at the sight of it. Marisa was a Hufflepuff, and she was one of the most popular girls in the school. She was in the year just above me. She was another one of Sirius' friends. She is also the girl I've had a crush on since third year, but I've never even spoken to her. The harry potter world belongs to J.K. Rowling unfortunatelyComplete
Hi!!! My name is Oswin Christina Potter. Yup, you heard right. I'm the twin of the famous James Potter. I have brown hair and bright blue eyes. However, I'm famous at my own school. No, I don't go to Hogwarts. I am the only girl at Durmstrang, the wizarding school in Bulgaria. I play on their Quidditch team as the Keeper, and I love pranking, so I tend to do subtle pranks when I'm not at the school. There, I am prank crazy, and friends with all the guys. Unfortunately, I am also part Veela, which can be annoying in a school full of boys, but they know not to try anything. The last guy who did ended up in St. Mungo's for almost the entire year. I also have a dragon friend Laelynn, who's name means hope. When I touched her when she was first born out of her golden egg, she turned my palm of my left hand a brilliant silver, which I have to hide under a glove, and gave me the ability to do magic without a wand. I have also mastered non-verbal spells. Anyway, I just found out I will be going to Hogwarts for the last two years of my education, meaning I get to see my twin and do some pranking! Yay! I will be riding Laelynn there, and we will definitely make an entrance, especially into the Great Hall. We have a whole routine worked out where I will be the main part of the big finale. Can't wait to make an impression! My brother has written to me and told me he found some great prankers, let's see if they live up to my standards. I only own my characters and storyline. Any other characters belong to their creators, and other similarities are not meant as copyright infringement, only inspiration and fanfiction. There will be some drama between Remus Lupin and Oswin Potter when they finally get together. I may or may not have them not tell the others about them for a while, but I'm not sure yet. I hope you like it!! (Completed)
More detailsContent Guidelines