What Ifs (Sonadow)
AshleytheHedgehog723
  • Reads 126
  • Votes 5
  • Parts 2
  • Time 6m
  • Reads 126
  • Votes 5
  • Parts 2
  • Time 6m
AshleytheHedgehog723
Ongoing, First published Oct 24, 2021
amyrosesalamysallyacornshadowthehedgehogsonadowsonicthehedgehog
It's well known amongst all that Sonic has always been a ladies man, but when he decides to finally settle down he chooses Princess Sally Acorn. Though it was true, Sonic did love Sally, that love only went so far. 30 years & 2 kids later, Sonic thought he was the luckiest Hedgehog alive, but truth was... he was constantly thinking about what might have been had he not married Sally. Had he not chosen to take the throne. After Silver's most recent "visit" Sonic takes the opportunity to go back. Back to the ARK.


I do not own any characters seen within this story unless stated otherwise, all characters belong to Sega.
Public Domain
amyrosesalamysallyacornshadowthehedgehogsonadowsonicthehedgehog
Table of contents

2 parts

Sign up to add What Ifs (Sonadow) to your library and receive updates
or
#790sonadow
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Dark SonAmy Boom: 2 Differences of Pain, Can You Change Me? by flamyblue
14 parts Complete
After another failure attempt of Eggman defeating team Sonic, he decided to retire for good. However, since Egghead retired everyone's lives have been great, until Amy has been starting to get harassed and or bullied by other boys beyond 'Hedgehog Village'. Sonic has been oblivious to Amy's feelings and what the boys have been doing to her (except for Tails' and Knuckles). Tails has been asking questions of why Sonic just doesn't want to admit his true feelings of love towards the fair sakura hedgehog. But one day all of that changed, Sonic finally found out about boys trying to do stuff to Amy and he had enough of their foolishness that something happened to him. Find out in this Dark Sonamy Boom Story ? P.S I don't own Sonic Characters in the Story they belong to SEGA, but I might add some of my own Characters in the future?
The Perfect Rose {A ShadAmy Story} by TheCelestial1
35 parts Ongoing
A pink hedgehog named Amy Rose who moved back to Mobius after a year. When she arrives back in Mobius, she goes in her old house and settles in she visits Sonic and was hoping for a welcoming back... but instead Sonic argues with her and says she should of stayed away from Mobius. It breaks Amy's heart. Amy was devastated.. until she met a mysterious black hedgehog with red stripes and fur as dark as coal. The black hedgehog is cold hearted and selfish. Something is happening between the two hedgehogs. Sonic notices Amy and the mysterious hedgehog together and starts acting strange towards her. What is Sonic up to? What will Amy do? How will the black hedgehog feel? Who will Amy choose? Started: August 11, 2019 Ended:
Unwritten Roads (Sonadow) by Maystars22
14 parts Ongoing
A Few Years After Shadow And Sonic Met, Shadow Slowly Grew Feelings For Sonic, When Shadow Realizes This, He Runs Away, Leaving Sonic And The Team. Sonic Becomes Anxious Trying To Find Shadow And Misses Him Every Second He's Away, Not Realising He Has Feelings Towards Shadow, As He's Completely Unaware, Shadow Has Been Hiding Out In An Abandoned House Within The Forest, Trying To Keep Himself Hidden Away From Everyone Else. What Will Happen When Eggman Kidnaps Shadow? - SFW - Cover Isn't Mine - Mischaracterization - Messy Grammar - Sonadow/Shadonic (Sonic x Shadow) All Characters Belong To Sega!!<3
The Blue Comet by SetForthADream
21 parts Complete
After three years, I finally came around to finding the rest of this story!! So here it goes!! After Sonic's noble sacrifice to his friend Shadow, four years later there's a blue comet that crashes to Mobius that's got everyone in a quick race to investigate and take possession of what this comet holds! What can I say, Shadow759 from Youtube was all my inspiration! (Who can't admit he's just super freakin awesome!?) Sonic adventure 2 battle: What if Sonic died and Shadow lived???
💜💫The Shooting Star💫💜 by BLUE_BLAZE101
11 parts Ongoing
"So, what's your name?" "My name?" "Yeah, what is it." "I don't have one?" ... "What even is a name?" _______________________________________________________ In events of a metor shower, a mysterious hedgehog fell from the sky with a purpose. Now, if only they can remember what it is. ‼️⚠️ All Sonic characters belong to SEGA except for my creative storyline and OC⚠️‼️
SonAmy: Can I love again ? by BibleBubba20
11 parts Complete
Sonic is hearbroken about his past after finding out Sally was cheating on him.He runs away and meets Amy.He tries to run from his true feelings for her but ends up hurt. Now for 6 days he is trapped with n he keep his promise or fall in love?
Prove To Me by NightOwl0906
11 parts Complete
Amy Rose never expected this to happen. The butterflies, the rush of adrenaline when she sees him, and all of these emotions inside of her for this cocky, arrogant and slight egomaniac of a hedgehog. But she did. He introduces himself to be the infamous Olgilvie "Sonic" Maurice Hedgehog, and Amy soon realizes she actually goes to school with him. When he finds out she's a tsundere from her friends, Sonic becomes more determined to make him fall for her. Will he succeed in proving to this girl that he's serious? Or will he ultimately fail in breaking the ice with the stubborn Pinkette? *CAUTION: STORY CONTAINS ALCOHOLISM, SUGGESTIVE CONTENT AND ABUSE!*
Shadow: Awakening by ShadowAceSonic
15 parts Complete
This fan fiction will go into detail about Shadow's complicated past, and will start with his creation on the ARK. Shadow is battling memories, mind-control, and struggling to find his true identity. Is he a Hero? A Villain? A Mercenary who cares for nothing but self gain? Or will he withhold nothing in his quest for revenge? He must discover who he truly is, and in the process, unearth the truth behind Maria's TRUE last request. I portray Shadow as a character who is torn between personalities. Even I don't know if he's innocent, or guilty. Only the end will tell true, and there is a journey awaiting for those who will follow it until the finish. Please comment with your opinions!
The Man Out Of Time [A ShadAmy and Silver Story] by depressoexpresso15
17 parts Ongoing
Ranked #2 in 'silverthehedgehog' stories! Ranked #1 in 'taiream' stories! - It has been seven years of peace following the grueling war with Eggman and his army. Though it took time to rebuild what they have lost, life for the Freedom Fighters could not be better. Whether it's finding love or trying to run from their past, celebrating post-war times has been different for each them. All is well until a silver hedgehog comes knocking on Amy Rose's door to deliver the tragic news about an incredible force that seems to be the cause of the future's destruction. Will anyone believe the mysterious hedgehog's cry for help? Or will he be left to fight for his future alone? Read to find out!
Lost in Shadow's Embrace (A Shadamy Story) by MerasShade4
29 parts Ongoing
Amy Rose and Sonic the Hedgehog have been dating for quite some time now. Amy can hardly believe that the man who has saved her life multiple times throughout her life is her boyfriend. The blue hero of Mobius with a regular girl who lives far out on the city's outskirts. Amy believed that when Sonic finally accepted her, he would begin to warm up and match her affection for him. However, it seems her daredevil hedgehog boyfriend hasn't changed much since the days of her chasing him around. He's distant, rarely comes to visit her, and barely ever mentions his relationship with her outside of dates Amy plans for them. Shadow the Hedgehog is widely seen as a loner hedgehog that no one outside a few people can interact with successfully. The Ultimate Lifeform is still haunted by his past visions of Maria, his best friend, and granddaughter of Gerald Robotnik. He doesn't enjoy being around people, particularly Sonic due to his annoyingly enthusiastic personality contrasting to his own serious, focused one. No one has ever been able to make Shadow feel the way Maria has. No one has been able to make him hope again. On the night of Princess Sally's Birthday Ball, a truth is revealed to Amy about Sonic. Something...unexpected, causes her to run away from the party ashamed. That same night she shows someone the extent of her strength that she holds back. It's safe to say he's impressed... Amy has loved Sonic for so long that she could never bring herself to leave him...could she? I DO NOT OWN ANY OF THE SONIC CHARACTERS, THIS IS ESSENTALLY MY OWN AU!!! Updates every week on Wednesdays!
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
Dark SonAmy Boom: 2 Differences of Pain, Can You Change Me? cover
The Perfect Rose {A ShadAmy Story} cover
Unwritten Roads (Sonadow) cover
The Blue Comet cover
💜💫The Shooting Star💫💜 cover
SonAmy: Can I love again ? cover
Prove To Me cover
Shadow: Awakening cover
The Man Out Of Time [A ShadAmy and Silver Story] cover
Lost in Shadow's Embrace (A Shadamy Story) cover

Dark SonAmy Boom: 2 Differences of Pain, Can You Change Me?

14 parts Complete

After another failure attempt of Eggman defeating team Sonic, he decided to retire for good. However, since Egghead retired everyone's lives have been great, until Amy has been starting to get harassed and or bullied by other boys beyond 'Hedgehog Village'. Sonic has been oblivious to Amy's feelings and what the boys have been doing to her (except for Tails' and Knuckles). Tails has been asking questions of why Sonic just doesn't want to admit his true feelings of love towards the fair sakura hedgehog. But one day all of that changed, Sonic finally found out about boys trying to do stuff to Amy and he had enough of their foolishness that something happened to him. Find out in this Dark Sonamy Boom Story ? P.S I don't own Sonic Characters in the Story they belong to SEGA, but I might add some of my own Characters in the future?

More details