Is it worth it? (Eyeless Jack x Fem! Y/N) - June 8th - Wattpad

Story cover for Is it worth it? (Eyeless Jack x Fem! Y/N) by June_8th

Is it worth it? (Eyeless Jack x Fem! Y/N)

Reads 217
Votes 8
Parts 12
Time 40m

Reads 217
Votes 8
Parts 12
Time 40m

Mature

bendrowned creepypasta eyelessjack hoodieandmasky horrorromance jeffthekiller killer masky runaway ships slenderman ticcitoby yourname zalgo

What happens when your met with a killer? What if that killer so happens to be your fictional crush? 

Sneak peek: 

"W-who are you?" I said, while starting to fear the figure in the dark. When the figure walked out of the dark my eyes froze on the blue mask they wore. i knew who it was instantly, my 'fictional' crush: Eyeless Jack. I stood there quietly staring at him...........

⚠️Warning: Swearing, triggers, gore, and sexual activity! If you read this book, you have been warned! 16+⚠️

Started: 12/06/2021
Edited Start: 10/01/2025
Published: ???All Rights Reserved

bendrowned creepypasta eyelessjack hoodieandmasky horrorromance jeffthekiller killer masky runaway ships slenderman ticcitoby yourname zalgo

Table of contents

12 parts

Sign up to add Is it worth it? (Eyeless Jack x Fem! Y/N) to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Bloody Romance | Eyeless Jack x Reader by amyau_08

Y/n was always considered different too everyone except their Nanna who dies unfortunately. However, Y/n meets the creepypasta's who are similar too them and is welcomed by Slenderman. Some of the creepypasta's don't exactly like this new arrangement at first and others welcome you with open arms. During this time, Y/n is determined too find out what they truly are. However a small love blossoms in between Y/n and the man behind the blue mask. A/n: I'm sorry but not all the famous creepypasta's you know of (cause I'm dumb) will be in this story, but I'll try too add as many as possible, and this is my first story so dont judge me. ⚠️Warning⚠️ *Swearing *Blood, grotesque imagery !Don't read if easily triggered!

The Innocent Eyes (Jeff The Killer X Reader) by MusicIsGreat678

*100,888 words* Strange things happen under strange circumstances and sometimes the most unsafe people make you feel the most safe. When you meet Jeff, he's not exactly like the stories you've heard. Perhaps he's just broken, but aren't we all? Can you fix each other? Will he finally be able to love something, despite his insanity? What are the true stories of him and other creepypastas?

The Knife In My Attic by LunaDoomed

I'm not a normal girl, heck they all say that. I come face to face with something out of this world and I don't laugh I don't scream cry or run. I am curiosity and I want to find out more. This boy how ever, he's not what I thought he was. Jeff the killer? I've seen you before. Why don't we find out together from where our first meeting leads?

Truth With Light by chasinqcomets

{ 𝐂𝐑𝐄𝐄𝐏𝐘𝐏𝐀𝐒𝐓𝐀 𝐓𝐇𝐄𝐎𝐑𝐈𝐄𝐒 & 𝐀𝐍𝐀𝐋𝐘𝐒𝐈𝐒 } 𝘄𝗼𝗿𝗱 𝗰𝗼𝘂𝗻𝘁: 𝟮𝟴,𝟱𝟲𝟳 |✓| As an enthusiast in the paranormal, it came naturally to be enticed into the grotesque, macabre world of Creepypasta experiences in 2014. Among the divide of a community deluded, I burned out into obscurity along with its members. Four years later, I rose from the ashes to inform where others failed, and to give closure where needed. Experience journals may never be seen the same again. ▂▂▂▂▂▂▂▂▂ Slender Man © Eric Knudsen, Jeff the Killer © Jeffrey D. Case, Ben Drowned © Alexander D. Hall, Sally Williams © Shilo Rose, Laughing Jack © Steve Aikins, Eyeless Jack © Azelf5000, Ticci Toby © Wade Kastoway, Masky / Tim Wright © Tim Sutton, Hoodie / Brian Thomas © Brian Haight, Skully / Jay Merrick © Troy Wagner, Alex Kralie © Joseph DeLage, TribeTwelve © Adam Rosner Copyright © 2018-2021 by Cheyenne Lee. All Creative Content Reserved.

The Cannibal and The Mute | Eyeless Jack x Mute! Male! Reader by Lucifers_Gentleman

(M/N). A young boy who is unable to speak. Not able to make a sound. To make up for it he has amazing art skills. His parents hated it. They didn't want to pay for lessons to speak.They wanted a child who could talk. Not someone who "waists their time on childish things like drawing." They didn't want to have this.... mistake of a child. They thought they deserved a normal child. So they had another child. Who COULD speak. And they absolutely spoiled and loved him. So Rick naturally was a jerk. Which caused (m/n) to one day crack and lose his sanity after a long beating. He becomes the true demon inside him when it comes to killing. His inner psychopath. As (m/n) walks through the forest, unsure of what to do next, he meets a tall man. A man who could enter (m/n)'s mind. A man who had no face. That man took (m/n) in, into a mansion of killers just like himself. And (m/n) couldn't feel more like at home. (M/N) makes lots of friends. But one caught his eyes the first time they met. The tall man was introducing (m/n) to the rest of the killers. (M/N) saw that most of them had masks. But one particular blue mask caught his eyes. He walked over to the taller male and stared at him in curiosity. He then lifted his hand and reached for the mask. Only to be stopped by a strong hand. "What are you doing?" The taller male lowly growled. (M/N) backed up in fear. Will (m/n) and Jack become friends? Enemies? Or.... Lovers?

Our Prince (Creepypasta × Male! Reader) by SquishySmithIII

All the stories are true. All of the sightings, the myths, the legends, the encounters. Deep inside the darkest forest, is a mansion full of killers who feast on the blood of the innocent and not so innocent. There really is a man with long arms and hands, whose face is as blank as death. This band of misfits truly considers themselves the last family that have left. Until they met you. Slenderman saw great potential in you when, even on your last beats of strength, managed to take down his Proxies and Jeff the Killer. Slowly, but surely, the Pastas nursed you back to health and sharpened your abilities to their maximum. This was it, you finally had a group of friends you could call family. All was good. Well, in your life, at least. The truth is, you're being hunted. By none other than the most powerful demon that could ever roam this earth, Zalgo, Lord of the Underealm. And, to your uncomfort, your father. Ever since you had fought him and fled his kingdom, he has done everything in his power to torment you into returning home. You vowed to Slenderman that you would never leave and betray the Creeps. You couldn't. After all they had done for you? But how long can your promise last? Will Zalgo manage to break you? And who will be strong enough to stay by your side? Warning: major swearing *cough cough* Jeffrey Woods *cough cough* This is also a Male!Reader × Jane the Killer story. Even though, yes, I know she's lesbian but let a guy dream (even though I'm not a guy)!

𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢? [✔] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader} by Lesbesbean

In order to save your life, Slenderman does what he swore he'd never do - he makes you his proxy. Little did you know how much it would change your life... - - - The reader is kept gender-neutral throughout the whole story and smut chapters always have two versions (one for male and one for female anatomy). Tldr; this is a creepypasta x reader fanfic, let's not take it *too* seriously. Characters here are probably very OOC, I shaped them as I wish to create a fun story ;3

Creepypasta Headcannons Book 2 by kjm126316

Well whaddya know whaddya know I actually managed to fill up an entire book with these bloody headcannons. And, surprise surprise, I have an overactive imagination, so here we go again! NOTE: Read the first headcannons book before this one. You'll thank me later

Creepypasta x Reader One shots by OfficialGoryGremlin

REQUESTS ARE CLOSED Highly recommended if you are 18+ This story contains smut/ fluff/ and boyfriend/ Girlfriend scenarios. This book is mostly written for girls and I'm sorry. ❌- 18+ ✔️- Your safe 👫 Characters👫 🕴️Males🕴️ -Slenderman -Jeff The Killer -Ben Drowned -Masky -Hoodie -Ticci Toby -Laughing Jack - Eyeless Jack -Liu/Sully -Puppeteer -Jason the toy maker -Bloody Painter -Dr. Smiley -Trenderman -Offenderman -Splendorman 👠Females👠 -Jane the killer -Nina the killer -Clockwork -Pinkamena -Suicide Sadie -Zero -Judge Angel -Lulu -Nurse Ann -Kate the chaser

Our New Addition - A CreepyPasta Fanfiction. [DISCONTINUED] by cinnabunny08

I'm no longer working on this story. Truth be told, I don't like it. I kept telling myself that once I got it started I'd sort of warm up to it, but at this point I've given up on it. I have no motivation nor desire to continue it. I do, however, have other CreepyPasta-related story ideas. Stay tuned for those. <3

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Bloody Romance | Eyeless Jack x Reader cover

The Innocent Eyes (Jeff The Killer X Reader) cover

The Knife In My Attic cover

Truth With Light cover

The Cannibal and The Mute | Eyeless Jack x Mute! Male! Reader cover

Our Prince (Creepypasta × Male! Reader) cover

𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢? [✔] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader} cover

Creepypasta Headcannons Book 2 cover

Creepypasta x Reader One shots cover

Our New Addition - A CreepyPasta Fanfiction. [DISCONTINUED] cover

Bloody Romance | Eyeless Jack x Reader

Y/n was always considered different too everyone except their Nanna who dies unfortunately. However, Y/n meets the creepypasta's who are similar too them and is welcomed by Slenderman. Some of the creepypasta's don't exactly like this new arrangement at first and others welcome you with open arms. During this time, Y/n is determined too find out what they truly are. However a small love blossoms in between Y/n and the man behind the blue mask. A/n: I'm sorry but not all the famous creepypasta's you know of (cause I'm dumb) will be in this story, but I'll try too add as many as possible, and this is my first story so dont judge me. ⚠️Warning⚠️ Swearing Blood, grotesque imagery !Don't read if easily triggered!