(Ticcimask) One In The Same
- Reads 2,780
- Votes 104
- Parts 9
Ongoing2h 31m
Last published Mon, Sep 1, 2025
Toby had never been one to thrive in a public environment, school was his own personal Hell. No one would give him the time of day because of all his outward oddities that were difficult to hide. However, he prefered to be left alone. Until one day, someone was just too friendly and persistent.
An AU in which Toby and his family move to Alabama for a fresh start after losing Lyra. To which Toby is reintroduced to Highschool and a few familiar faces right before the events of Marble Hornets.
All Rights Reserved
#280
tobyrogers
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Tim Wright × Brian Thomas × Female Reader
I do not own Marble Hornets!!! I am just using there characters!!! I have already watched Marble Hornets!!! If you haven't watched it I highly recommend you watch it! There will be some trigger warnings!!! I will warn you before you read the chapter and before the paragraph!!! Published: December 4, 2023 Finished: Unknown
(TicciMask) What else is there to lose?
After being found by the Operator and his "supposed" Proxies and having no memory of his past life, Toby starts to dig deep into finding out the truth behind who the faceless one is, who his companions really are, and where he came from. Meanwhile, Tim starts to under go a crisis when an old friend returns and his past comes back to haunt him. Things are getting dangerous, and there are only two options in the end.Complete![Bloody Flowers [TicciJack]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/396652643-256-k700985.jpg)
Bloody Flowers [TicciJack]
⚠︎There will be mental health struggles, suicide, attempted suicide, death, abuse, violence, and other triggering topics. If any of this is a trigger, please do not read this fan fiction.⚠︎ [insert description] I did not come up with Ticci Toby or Eyeless Jack, they aren't my ocs. Credit to their creators (Azelf500 & Kastoway) 💪 The art isn't mine either 😞 (Yasmim.Killer_UwU) #1 in Marble Hornets - Nov. 8th 2025 #1 in ticcitobyxeyelessjack - Dec. 12th 2025 #1 in proxies - Feb. 10th 2026Complete![Camp Creepypasta {Ticci Toby x Reader} [BOOK 1]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/199778371-256-k707889.jpg)
Camp Creepypasta {Ticci Toby x Reader} [BOOK 1]
Basically, you're 18. You were homeschooled your entire life but you were fine with that, you preferred to be alone. Your parents never cared to spend time with you and they neglected you which was part of the reason you were so used to being alone. You loved creepypastas and read them whenever your parents would neglect you. One night, when you snuck out of the house and towards the lake to go clear your mind, some girls pushed you in and you almost drowned but you were saved by who you thought was a fictional character. Then, you receive a letter, telling you about a camp that was perfect for you. You went and even made some friends, but more and more happens and everything keeps getting worse. You need to try and fix things before things spiral beyond your control, There has to be a way to stop this, right? Read the story to find out what happens! -------- « Book Status: COMPLETE » completed on 03/11/2020 This is a series of books, this book is the first thus why it says 'BOOK 1' in the title. The second book and the rest of them will be on my profile. - BOOKS OUT SO FAR: 2/7 [ also, this is a Marble Hornets and Creepypasta crossover, so expect some Marble Hornets related chapters :) ] [ cover art by Lynnarty ] (!) [TW/CW: strong language, self-harm, suicide, drugs, described gore, long mf chapters lmao] (!) All your support truly means a lot to me! -------- Rankings: hoodieandmasky - #1 ! [wOW] hoodieandmasky - #4 😔 Creepypasta - #595 ouch :,( hoodieandmasky- #3 👀 Creepypasta - #820 seriously- hoodieandmasky- #3 👁-👁 hoodieandmasky - #2 ! Toby - #148 hoodieandmasky - #326 (HOW THE FU-) Toby - #114 :D ticcitobyxreader - #5 ! proxy - #1 ! proxies - #1 !✨ creepypasta - #279 sally williams - #1 (why tho lmao she's like not mentioned once i don't think) creepypasta - #592 toby - #23 :)Complete
Until the Day I Die- A Ticci Toby x OC Story
Cole and Toby have known each other since Ablaze brought Cole to the Underrealm, despite some hiccups they became fast friends. Over the passed two years Toby has developed feelings for Cole, however his last relationship didn't end well so he hasn't brought them up. Cole has been showing signs of feeling the same, however he won't go the next step. After a near kiss their friendship seems to fall apart.Complete
Eyeless Jack x Ticci Toby
He killed his dad, found a new home, finally settled in, even made some new friends. What else? Oh yeah, and watched his crush get brutally murdered and sacrificed by a cult.Complete
⨂ ~ * M a r b l e H o r n e t s O n e s h o t s * ~ ⨂
This story is a bunch of random oneshots ranging from one AU to the next. I will do any ships, but I am strictly against X Readers. If you only like X Reader stories, this isn't for you. So settle down with a brain full of the whole series, and all of Marble Hornets explained. ⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂Complete
⟨⟨A Different Kind Of Love⟩⟩ ⟫Eyeless Jack X Ticci Toby⟪ ❴CREEPYPASTA❵
After Toby and Jack have many unsuccessful roommates, They agree to be each other's roommates. At first, Jack almost completely ignores Toby, but as time goes on, things change. HEAVILY INSPIRED BY @theblackmailruler, MANY CREDITS TO THEM!! CREDITS TO @calicowillow_ ON TIKTOK FOR THE COVER THIS IS FILLED WITH *MY* HEADCANNONS, PLEASE KEEP THAT IN MIND WHILE READING. if you don't like it don't read it ;3Complete
Won't You Stay? {COMPLETED}
Ticci Toby x Reader I do not own most of these characters. Hoodie and Masky (Brian and Tim) belong to Marble Hornets. The rest of the Pastas belong to their rightful owners. I don't own the you in the story. That'd be weird- and it's truth. So. Any side characters that I may add are most likely gonna be made up by me, so those characters I do own- I guess. The story cover was not made by me. I just found a photo on Google. This story will be using She/Her pronouns, meaning the you in this story is female. You have been warned. (If this does well, I may make another CreepyPasta x Reader with the reader being male. 👌) --------------- His name was Toby. He was a generally quiet boy around strangers, but was more than annoying and loud around people he knew. Though, he didn't know very many people other than the people he lived with. Kinda rare for a killer to make friends with someone that wasn't like him. Her name was (Y/N). She was sarcastic and generally grumpy towards everyone. She didn't like where she was in life and didn't even know what she wanted to do with it. This lead to her having a generally boring life. She acted as if death couldn't come soon enough. But, things changed. This wouldn't be much of a story if it would've gone otherwise. What happens after one quick encounter? Eh, guess you'll find out soon enough, right? (Please don't have high expectations for this story, I suck at writing. ;-;)Complete
Tear In My Heart (COMPLETE)
Tim finds himself lost to the Operator after the events of Marble Hornets; caught up in a lone life of travel and covering up the Operator's tracks. He's been so used to being alone, his friends long gone or having moved on with their own lives. But what would happen if a friend long gone would return to him in the most unconvential of ways? And what of his life living under the Operator and meeting more horrific monsters than he ever thought existed? And what of the newest Proxy the Operator decides to bring in, in the hopes of lessening the burden of his two highest ranking members? Tim could only suppose, at this rate, that the more he wasn't surprised with life, the better. ( If you like this story, make sure the read the rest I have on my profile in the series for this ship! There's 3 others!Complete
I do not own Marble Hornets!!! I am just using there characters!!! I have already watched Marble Hornets!!! If you haven't watched it I highly recommend you watch it! There will be some trigger warnings!!! I will warn you before you read the chapter and before the paragraph!!! Published: December 4, 2023 Finished: Unknown
More detailsContent Guidelines