Creepypasta Love Stories: Ben x Jeff x Reader
- Reads 53
- Votes 4
- Parts 4
Y/n was just a average girl tryn' to live life broke af. But one special thing about her was her love for the famous Creepypastas Ben Drowned and Jeff the Killer. She thought she would never have a chance with them until she discovers that they have been stalking her for a long time. Will she be able to let the two killers calm down and love eachother or will conflict happen and they destroy eachother? Read to find out!
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Eyeless Jack X Jane The Killer: Murderous Love
Eyeless Jack is in love with the newest creepypasta. He knew he was from the moment he laid "eyes" on her. But she does not appreciate his advances, or comfort. Jane seems to have a history with Jeff The Killer, and Jack must stop them from butting heads, while also trying to win the stone cold heart of the new Killer. Can he make Jane fall in love? Or will her mysterious history with Jeff prevent her from noticing the eyeless demon? ************ All images in this story are put together by me, used by photos I found on the internet, and edited by me. All poetry in this story is written by my best friend Courtney Lesa Minto, and is completely her copyright works. I'd like to say a big thank you to her for being my editor and backbone during this story ❤️ @CourtneyLesaComplete
Killers Can't Love (A Jeff The Killer Romance)
Jeff is a cold-blooded, insane murderer who only feels the urge to kill. But what happens when he meets a girl that couldn't relate to him more? Now Jeff has this strange feeling in his chest that he can't seem to identify. Could it be...love? But his arch rival soon finds out about his love for the girl and uses it against him. What will happen when Jeff has to rescue the love of his life in less than 24 hours?Complete
Does Love Sink or Swim? ( Ben Drowned X Suicidal Reader!)
He's a notorious villain in this little game we all call love. A man who lost all the hope and mercy from his eyes. A cold blooded demonic killer. Who winds up living in a house of other killers as well. Is there some sort of chance that this killer can understand the feeling of love? Can love break through the oceans of pain, death, and despair? Can a beloved town girl with masks to hide behind and a will that can be easily broken accept a painful twisted love? Can she love like a killer can? A type of emotion both parties had forgotten long ago, reappear? Can you call it love? Or an empathetic understanding? Will this "love" sink or swim?... Suicidal Reader X Ben Drowned WARNING:: Contains swearing and suicidal thoughts, may trigger some. May contain gore, since it is a creepypasta fanfic Otherwise, I hope you enjoy!![Is it Wrong To Fall for a Serial Killer? [EDITING]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/86601710-256-k843098.jpg)
Is it Wrong To Fall for a Serial Killer? [EDITING]
A romance creepypasta, compared to Jeffery, Eyeless jack, Ben and much more.Complete
...
Complete
Jeff The Killer X Reader
Who says a killer can't love someone? Jeff was suppose to kill a girl one night. But he didn't something made him stop. He took a good look a the girl and before he knew it he was in love. But when the two were in love a tragic situation splits them up and pulls them back together and soon war will come upon on them. Could Jeff and y/n make it out of Zalgo's war and love their lives peacefully or will it become a disaster?Complete
The killers II
Continuation of the killers. Jeff has been in the hospital for five years after killing Jane. Will his regret cause him to do the unthinkable? Also join other creepypasta ships start to bloomComplete
Knives and Scars (CreepyPasta x Killer Reader) {EDITING IN PROGRESS}
(Y/N) becomes a killer known as (C/P/N) after she releases her anger out to her backstabbing parents. She goes alone and unstable until she comes across the creepypastas. She fights through pain and new relationships. Sooner than you think, she'll soon find herself in a dangerous path but who will she side with? Most importantly, Who is siding with her? Find out in Knives and Scars Enjoy Reader-Chan!!!~ ~YsaComplete
Sanity is Just a State of Mind (18+_A Jeff the Killer fan fiction)
This is not a love story of a psycho killer turned lover boy. No, this is a story of what happens when a psycho killer takes great interest in a woman he is unable to kill. Jeff has just entered a new state. Things take a different turn for Jeff when he is unable to kill one of his target's. Jessie, a local girl, has her whole world turned upside down when Jeff decides to invade every aspect of her life. What kind of hell will he put her through? And what will happen to her once he gets what he wants? Find out what happens when these two worlds collide. !!!WARNING!!! This book has been rated Mature 18+ and may not be suitable for some readers. The contents in this book includes; controversial issues, graphic violence, gore, course adult language, and strong sexual content.Complete
Bloody Romance | Eyeless Jack x Reader
Y/n was always considered different too everyone except their Nanna who dies unfortunately. However, Y/n meets the creepypasta's who are similar too them and is welcomed by Slenderman. Some of the creepypasta's don't exactly like this new arrangement at first and others welcome you with open arms. During this time, Y/n is determined too find out what they truly are. However a small love blossoms in between Y/n and the man behind the blue mask. A/n: I'm sorry but not all the famous creepypasta's you know of (cause I'm dumb) will be in this story, but I'll try too add as many as possible, and this is my first story so dont judge me. ⚠️Warning⚠️ *Swearing *Blood, grotesque imagery !Don't read if easily triggered!Complete
Eyeless Jack is in love with the newest creepypasta. He knew he was from the moment he laid "eyes" on her. But she does not appreciate his advances, or comfort. Jane seems to have a history with Jeff The Killer, and Jack must stop them from butting heads, while also trying to win the stone cold heart of the new Killer. Can he make Jane fall in love? Or will her mysterious history with Jeff prevent her from noticing the eyeless demon? ************ All images in this story are put together by me, used by photos I found on the internet, and edited by me. All poetry in this story is written by my best friend Courtney Lesa Minto, and is completely her copyright works. I'd like to say a big thank you to her for being my editor and backbone during this story ❤️ @CourtneyLesa
More detailsContent Guidelines