What Should've Been - B 📎💜💙 - Wattpad

What Should've Been

Reads 6,785
Votes 252
Parts 20
Time 1h 4m

Reads 6,785
Votes 252
Parts 20
Time 1h 4m

Mature

badlisanna fairytail mystery nalu romantic

When Lucy and her mother moved after Lucy's near death experience, they had hoped that their troubles would cease.

Sadly they weren't very lucky.

Especially Lucy.

Her ex-best friend, Lisanna, had followed suit and moved to the same school that Lucy was moving to.

Her ex-best friend was the one who started the rumors about the poor blonde at her old school. She tormented Lucy to the breaking point.

She's taken or hurt many of Lucy's loved ones and now has Lucy, captured. She's being punished.

What will happened next?

Will the group find her in time?

Will Lisanna win?

Book One: What Could've Been
Book Two: What Should've Been

Enjoy~

~kitty_barbie~ &lt;3All Rights Reserved

badlisanna fairytail mystery nalu romantic

20 parts

Sign up to add What Should've Been to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

$Lucy Heartfilia, My Strong Daughter {Discontinued, I made a new version} by Silly_Little_Chump$

Lucy Heartfilia had the time of her life when she was little. But her mother dies. Lucy's home becomes dark and lonely, as if the light which shone bright had burned out. Hating her father for not caring about her, she runs away. But then, she meets Levy McGarden, and enters the school named Magnolia High. The Magic Council thinks there's too many magicians in the one place, so they decide that everyone should be separated into guilds. But what will happen when Isamu takes Lisanna for his own gain? (Isamu is a character that I made up). Will Lucy be able to comfort everyone in Fairytail? Or will they blame her? Will they be true nakama and find a way to help Lisanna? Um... Sorry but my tenses always mix up. So please tell me how I can fix them up! Thank you. And I'm sorry for the NaLi haters out there, I have to add that or my story won't sound as good.

The Runaway Prince (NaLu) [COMPLETED] by NutMeg20

Once upon a time there was a beautiful kingdom... Scratch that. this was a kingdom ruled by a malicious king. Once the Good king of the land past the queen had no choice to marry someone to help her rule the kingdom. Her son was too young and she couldn't keep it up on her own. The prince was mistreated and locked away in the castle by his evil step-father. The mystery remains why. When the prince escapes, having the knowledge that the king is locking him away out of fear of the power he possesses, and tries to leave. The guards are constantly searching for him and he is trapped in the town of Magnolia. When the beautiful maiden, Lucy Heartfillia, helps him away from the guards, he contemplates telling her that he is the prince. Before he can do anything strange events occur possibly reveling his true power. She helps him through all in his troubled times, and the prince cant help but fall in love with the beautiful maiden in the times of trouble. [SLOW UPDATES] Characters belong to Hiro Mashima. Storyline is mine And I suck at descriptions so hopefully this will suffice.

Fairy Tail: Shadows (3rd Book In the "Intertwined Fates" Series!) by Cryptic_Eyes

Book #3 Lucy sacrificed herself to save Fiore; to stop the machine Loren and Lores constructed to destroy everything. But in order for it to have been destroyed, Lucy forced Natsu to let go of her over the cliff, falling to her death. But...wait. When Loren approaches a devastated Natsu she says that the one responsible for their mind control was a man long forgotten, who's true purpose was to get his one and only true prize: Lucy. And, Loren tells Natsu and the others they can rescue her, but they have to go to the place where shadows lie; the Black Stars. {Used from my previous story, Fairy Tail: The Luminous Star of Caballeen!} There, Lucy is trapped, being held as a trophy by the man and frozen in time. If Loren and Lores open the portal, they can go inside and save her. However, there is a catch; only one person can go inside. And, as soon as they enter the Black Stars, they would be overrun with Shadow monsters; hundreds of them all over the place. The man who has Lucy has control of the Black Stars, and would send the pursuer into different realms to battle different monsters. But Natsu doesn't care. He'd do anything to get Lucy back, and to save her from being trapped all alone forever. Automatically claiming he'd go and not let anyone else take his place, Natsu dives in to the land of the shadows; the Black Stars. Will Natsu save Lucy and bring her home, back to him and the others? Find out what happens in all the chaos in Fairy Tail: Shadows. (A NaLu Fanfiction) ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ First, Second, and Last In the Series: 1)Fairy Tail: With Me 2)Fairy Tail: End of My Days With You 3) This one 4) Fairy Tail: The Legend of Etheoria (completed!)

Regret by MagneticWarrior

Lucy Heartfilla was always surrounded by friends. Well that's until a certain transformation Mage named Lissana comes back from the 'dead'. She is ignored and bullied at the guild. She then leaves for a couple of years and returns. She was then stronger and happy to be back. Until the guild is threatened to give Lucy up. She feels like she has no other choice but to leave, but she doesn't leave alone. Two people that always had her back go with her. Changes happen. Revenge is set and a dark force is out there and getting closer. Love is tested and betrayal is stepped forth. --------------------- Agh!! Will NaLu ever happen again!! \(~.~)/ Read to find out this first fairy tail fanfic of mine.

$Kidnapped {Nalu} ~Complete~ by Satan_Is_Me_$

Lucy was taken from her family, but was given love. Her situation is confusing and lonely. Until a younger boy comes along to give her another sense of love and will eventually save her from her solitude. Was once 10-Nalu This is a Nalu Fanfic. I do not own these characters, I simply own the plot. (Mature-ish)

Fairytail's Trump Card by Silly_Little_Chump

Hello! This is the re-make of my old fanfic! Lucy Heartfilia had the time of her life when she was little. But her mum dies. Lucy's home becomes dark and lonely, as if the light which shone bright had burned out. Hating her father for not caring about her, she runs away. But then, she meets Levy McGarden, and enters the school named Magnolia High. The Magic Council thinks there's too many magicians in the one place, so they decide that everyone should be separated into guilds. But what will happen when Isamu takes Lisanna for his own gain? (Isamu is a character that I made up). Will Lucy be able to comfort everyone in Fairytail? Or will they blame her? Will they be true nakama and find a way to help Lisanna? I suck, so I'm telling you early that my tenses mix up.

Fairytales with Fairy Tail (part 2) Completed by Moon_goddess47

"Levy," Erza asks, "Do you still happen to have that book?" Levy stills for a moment, thinking. "Actually, I might!" She moves the giant book from her lap-not without some struggle- and jumps up from her previous seat on the couch next to Juvia. The other girls waited excitedly, chattering about random happenings around town. The sudden rise in visiting relatives, for instance. It seems that the sudden increase in jobs is a direct result of this strange occasion. "Lu, Juvia, Erza come quick!" Levy shouted urgently. The useless chatter instantly ceased as all three girls rushed in the direction the petite bookworm went, the attic. "Levy?! What is it?! What's wrong?!" Erza beat the other two into the musty room and instantly a very audible gasp came from her tall frame. After a great deal of struggle Juvia and Lucy managed to push the redhead aside so they could squeeze into the room. When they finally made it neither of them could believe their eyes. The whole dusty attic was bathed in a bright, magical light. It seemed to swallow everything whole as the girls stood there in shock. Erza was the first to snap out of her shock. "Levy, what is going on? What is causing this?" "It's the book, Erza, the book of fairytales! Something's wrong! They're missing-" Levy tried to warn them but the book started producing winds near the speed of a hurricane, drowning out her words. Papers and random clutter flew around the room in a whirlwind of debris. "Levy! Girls, we have to get out of here, fast!" Erza shouted over the wind. But before they could run the light grew to blinding levels and the girls' visions went black. ~~~<•>~~~ *Trigger Warning* - Mental and physical abuse. *DISCLAIMER* I do not own Fairy Tail or the cover shown above. I do not claim to own any of the characters in this book or on the cover. All rights go to the proper owners.

it's not the end - nalu | ✔️ by -luxanne

[𝐑𝐄-𝐄𝐃𝐈𝐓𝐈𝐍𝐆] "You deserve a happy ending." ------------------------------------------ Lucy Heartfilia was best friends with Natsu Dragneel, yes, was. After his childhood friend Lisanna Strauss came back, Lucy decided to go do things on her own--after all, she wasn't wanted. Lucy thinks that she loves someone and she is torn between jealousy and love. But after being cursed while out on a job--losing the one she loves most--she forgets about her one and only. But will she remember? And will he return her feelings? -------------------------------------- please do not plagiarize. do not take this story and call it as your own.

In Too Deep {NaLu story} by writingmyfics

Lucy Heartfillia is daughter of Jude Heartfillia of the Heartfillia company. After years of being bullied because of her money and body, Lucy and her father decided it'd be ok for her to move somewhere by herself. After starting her senior year at her new school, she makes very good friends as well as enemies. One is Lisanna, she basically rules the school and is dating one of the hottest guys there. Natsu Dragneel. One day Lucy and Natsu talk to each other at Blue Peg Café. They get flirty, rather Natsu does. Lucy doesn't realize who he is until she leaves. Natsu keeps up with flirts but Lucy suddenly doesn't want to play along. One day Natsu found out that Lisanna cheated on him and he decides to take revenge, by using Lucy. Lucy doesn't know this and begins to slowly fall for him. Will she find out the truth? Will Natsu actually fall for Lucy? •Disclaimer• ~I don't own Fairy Tail~

What Love Is (NaLu fanfic) by bluecieloo

Lucy started her new semester at her school. New classmates, new friends, what happened if her personality can't fit in toward new people? She met Natsu, the genius from her school. But things didn't go quite easy. He has cold attitude to everyone except to his childhood friend, Lisanna. As the time went by, Lucy began to know Natsu. Will Lucy fall for Natsu? Or her past will get her? They met some new friends and discover that there were people who want to destroy the world. Will they be able to saved the world? [Cover by: @FlamesxKeys]

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Lucy Heartfilia, My Strong Daughter {Discontinued, I made a new version} cover

The Runaway Prince (NaLu) [COMPLETED] cover

Fairy Tail: Shadows (3rd Book In the "Intertwined Fates" Series!) cover

Kidnapped {Nalu} ~Complete~ cover

Fairytail's Trump Card cover

Fairytales with Fairy Tail (part 2) Completed cover

it's not the end - nalu | ✔️ cover

In Too Deep {NaLu story} cover

What Love Is (NaLu fanfic) cover

Lucy Heartfilia, My Strong Daughter {Discontinued, I made a new version}

Lucy Heartfilia had the time of her life when she was little. But her mother dies. Lucy's home becomes dark and lonely, as if the light which shone bright had burned out. Hating her father for not caring about her, she runs away. But then, she meets Levy McGarden, and enters the school named Magnolia High. The Magic Council thinks there's too many magicians in the one place, so they decide that everyone should be separated into guilds. But what will happen when Isamu takes Lisanna for his own gain? (Isamu is a character that I made up). Will Lucy be able to comfort everyone in Fairytail? Or will they blame her? Will they be true nakama and find a way to help Lisanna? Um... Sorry but my tenses always mix up. So please tell me how I can fix them up! Thank you. And I'm sorry for the NaLi haters out there, I have to add that or my story won't sound as good.