Six Feet Under the Stars - Rudy Pankow

"Meet me on Thames street, I'll take you out. Though I'm hardly worth your time, in the cold you look so fierce but I'm warming up because the tension's like a fire. We'll hit South Broadway in a matter of minutes and like a bad movie, I'll drop a line. Fall in the grave I've been digging myself but there's room for two. Six feet under the stars" - "Six Feet Under the Stars" by All Time Low (So Wrong It's Right, 2007)

If you were to ask a seventeen year old Rudy Pankow where he'd be five years from that moment, the answer would be anything but what he's looking at - his high school best friend yelling at him in her apartment on the morning of the table read for season two after he saw a photo of a little girl that looked like he was looking at one of his own childhood photos.

There's just one thing - they hadn't hooked up since her junior year and she never explicitly told him she was pregnant.