My Favourite Mistake | ongoing
- Reads 92,417
- Votes 1,100
- Parts 33
MatureOngoing5h 19m
Last published Sat, Nov 18, 2023
I had sex with someone I shouldn't have had sex with, that someone being my brothers best friend, Lucas. I gave into the fun for a bit, we messed around and had fun. I thought he was a meaningless hookup and a fun friends with benefits, but I didn't expect our relationship to evolve into what it did. We became close, too close.
And I fell for him.
When it ended, I thought my feelings were gone. I was convinced I'd never see him again, but here he is. After risking my future and leaving me for his job six months ago, he's back and he wants to play. It's tempting. He's tempting, but I'm not giving in this time. Not again.
© All Rights Reserved
***
#3 summer vacation 13/03
#1 mistakes 23/03
#1 time pass 08/04
#1 sport romance 14/04
#1 summer vacation 07/05
#2 friends with benefits 09/08
started: 21st jan 2023
completed: ongoing
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Summer Changed - A Jeremiah X Reader story.
...'Memories of last summer flooded your brain as your stomach tied itself in knots thinking about the last 4th of July, you and Jere stood looking out on the sunset as he stared into your eyes and kissed you. That moment you will never forget. The moment you realised you loved Jeremiah Fisher.'... Jeremiah and Y/n have always been best friends. You always look forward to your stay at cousins each summer. But this year it's different, ever since you and Jere kissed. You go to cousins every year, flying in from England as you moved there with your mother when you were young. Your best friend Belly, her brother Steven, and their mom Laurel (who is basically your second mother) take you to Susannah's house over summer. You're best friends with Conrad and Jere, but this year it feels different. Over the last year you have had a huge glow up and have become even more gorgeous than you already were. I'm this story you will find yourself travelling through heartbreak, fights, makeups and breakups but will you end up with the one boy you started it all with. Jeremiah Fisher. A/N: This book may contain sensitive references and some 18+ chapters (smut included) but there will always be a warning. This is my first ever book so please tell me feedback, please tell me if I make mistakes and leave suggestions if you want to. I love you all so much and thank your for choosing my story. I will attempt to post as frequently as possible but will notify you all if I have any delay. Thank you so much~ Author.Complete
Side Note: I Think I Love You
Side note: never fall for your fake boyfriend. When my best friend convinced me to write a love letter to my crush, I didn't expect it to all go south. Because instead of the most realistic scenario-him reading the letter and rejecting me privately-the last thing I'd ever expected to happen did. The letter doesn't end up in his locker. But in the locker of one of the most popular football players in the senior class, Ian Bale. Who also just happens to be my crush's older brother. Luckily, he promises to keep it a secret. But our actions start spreading rumors about us and in the next minute, I'm thrown into a fake relationship. But it works out for the both of us. Ian saves me from potential embarrassment while I help get his friends off his back about his dating life (or lack thereof). However, as the month progresses, I find myself enjoying more and more of his company. From his cheesy pick-up lines to his sense of wonder and even his nerdy glasses. My priorities begin to shift and I can't help but be a little terrified of the prospect of trusting another guy again. But I think I can make an exception. For fans of Jenny Han, Cookie O'Gorman, and happily ever afters with a sprinkling of real world problems, get ready to dive into the first installment of this beachside romance.Complete
Casual Intimacy
He's a player. I'm a player. So it's only natural that we're best friends. We both share many of the same traits and hobby's. He can't stay with the same girl for more than 2 days, I can't stay with same guy for more than 2 days. We're both noncommittal teenagers, who both love to party. But, what happens when one night, we party a little too hard, and have a drunken night of lustful passion. And now can't keep our hands off of each other. Highest rankings 🥇#want! 🥇#benefits! 🥇#inlove! 🥇#player! 🥇#secretromance 🥇#alcohalComplete
Dirty Little Secret
Being in an abusive relationship is hard, but leaving is even harder. I never thought my sweet, charming boyfriend I met freshman year of college would've ended up this way, but he did, and I don't know how to get out of it. But on my twenty-first birthday when his older brother and I are left alone, we make a mistake. A big mistake. It should've just been a one-time thing, but some things are just too hard to stay away from. Maybe, just maybe, Lucas Weston can be my dirty little secret. And I can be his. (#2 in hefallsfirst) - 5/16/23 (#2 in marinebiology) - 5/16/23 (#2 in brothersgirlfriend) - 5/15/23 (#3 in animallovers) - 5/15/23 (#11 in secretaffair) - 5/16/23 (#10 in veterinarian) - 5/16/23 (#147 in collegeromance) - 5/15/23 (#135 in hockey) - 5/16/23 (#751 in abusiveboyfriend) - 5/15/23 (#40 in boyfriendsbrother) - 5/15/23 (#685 in sportsromance) - 5/15/23 (#131 in beach) - 5/16/23 (#67 in secret) - 5/16/23 (#172 in girlxboy) (#878 in college) (#74 in texas) (#487 in truelove) (Complete
My Boyfriends Brother
I'm sleeping with my boyfriend's brother. But if you knew what my boyfriend does behind closed doors... you'd understand. ˚ ✦ . . ˚ . . ✦ ˚ . ★⋆. ࿐࿔ . ˚ * ✦ . . ✦ ˚ ˚ .˚ ✦ . . ˚ . [18+ Mature Warning] [Smut Warning] [Mentions of sexual assault, abuse, affairs, alcohol and drugs]Complete
Nepenthe
*COMPLETED* He's my best friend. The one person I run to when I don't want to face the world around me, because I know I can hide with him. In the comfort of our silence. Of his touch. My heart has always been his, if only he'd see that I'm right here waiting for the day he will finally notice me. Then, perhaps, he could be mine. But I'm just out of a relationship. And he's unavailable. -•-•-•-•-•-•-•-•-•-• #3 IN MUTUALFEELINGSComplete
Chasing You
-"Fuck I can't wait to taste you." He says under his heavy breath. Excitement courses through my body as Tyler wraps my legs around his waist so he can pick me up. He carries me across the room and rests me down on a table. I can feel his hard cock against my now throbbing pussy as he uses his hips to shift me back. In this moment I realize I want him- all of him. - ••• Let's face it- everyone has "that person". That person that you can't forget about, no matter how hard you try. That person you would have done anything for, or anything to be with.. but, what happens when you and that person can't be together? B is a naive young girl who would do anything to have the perfect high school fling- until she meets Tyler. Tyler is older, more mature, and off limits. B faces many hurdles, twists, and turns as she tries to keep her relationship with Tyler a float. ***BOOK TWO, (Tempted by you) IN PROCESS***Complete
Silent Temptation ✔️ || 18 +
Temptation has an uncanny resemblance to Leon Collin's • • • She was supposed to leave him behind. Instead, he followed her home-with a grin and a proposition she can't refuse. • • • Leon and Charlottes story (can be read as a standalone but is part of a series - read sinful liabilities first if you want to) • • • Leon Collins has an uncanny resemblance to temptation - and Charlotte Hudson knows better than to touch it twice. As maid of honour to her best friend and sister-in-law-to-be, Charlotte's only job is to keep the wedding week flawless. But that's easier said than done when the best man is Leon: her brother's best friend, her best friend's brother, and the one mistake she swore she'd never make again. They danced too close once - too drunk, too messy, too young, and far too unforgettable. Now they're walking down the aisle together, tension simmering under every glance, every brush of skin, every drunken confession that never should've left her lips. When the week ends, Charlotte thinks she's leaving the past - and him behind for good. She's wrong. Because Leon Collins just got traded to her new team. Now he's in her office, in her space, and in her head - all charm, smirks, and a proposition that shouldn't sound as tempting as it does. One rule. No feelings. Just a physical arrangement to burn off the heat neither of them can seem to ignore. But desire this dangerous doesn't play by the rules. And the closer Charlotte gets to Leon, the more her carefully built walls begin to crack. She promised herself she'd never fall for him again. But Leon Collins has always been the one risk she can't resist.Complete
My best friends brother
"Just forget about it, please" I beg, serious. As I looked into his dark blue eyes. He scoffed, and pulled me closer to him. His hands on my waist, mine over his. "And what if I can't?" he whispers, softly, as his gaze dropped to my lips........ Oh I fucked up, I fucked up bad! I can't believe I slept with Ryan last night, and enjoyed it, at least from what I can remember. Oh but to make matters worse, he's my best friends brother. And my boyfriends best friend. This can't happen again, and no one can find out. That's the last time I ever get drunk! 🥇in #want! 🥇in #sneaking 🥇in #drunk Spin off-'My Crush, His Brother and My Best Friends Ex'Complete
BROKEN HOPE (Lucas & Emilia Book 2)
I was so damn naive it's no wonder I've ended up here. Kidnapped by the man who promised me forever, just as I'd begun to understand the depths of his betrayal. It's a sad truth I didn't marry my husband for love. I married him for the life he promised to provide, and if I'm honest with myself, I married him in hopes one day he'd fill the void Lucas-my first love-left behind. Now after so many years, they're both back. And in my desperation to feel loved, to be wanted and chosen I've walked straight into this trap. All because I forgot life's harshest lesson... I'm not enough. No matter how much or how fiercely I love, the choice will never be me. Especially now. Surrounded by danger and at the mercy of my husband's enemies, I'm forced to face one final bit of truth. Much like love, hope is for the weak. I was a fool to believe in the vows and promises they made. In the Broken Redemption Series, one man's vow to protect the woman he lost becomes a battle between redemption, forgiveness, and the kind of love that refuses to let go. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ This is Book 2 of Lucas & Emilia's Broken Redemption arc. For the complete experience, start with Book 1: Broken Vows.Complete
Strip Game - A Whirlwind Summer
My life was a whirlwind of privilege and innocence until everything changed. As the only child of wealthy parents, I'd always had everything I needed, but never really connected with the girly scene. My best friend Travis, the ultimate playboy, was my rock, and we shared a bond that went beyond siblings. But when my dad's business went bankrupt and my parents left me in Travis's care, and my world practically turned upside down. Living with Travis all alone in one house. I struggled to cope with the loss of my old life and the secrets Travis kept from me. Little did I know, our summer of solitude would lead to a truth or dare game that would change everything..." •[ 𝑺𝑻𝑰𝑳𝑳 𝑬𝑫𝑰𝑻𝑰𝑵𝑮]•••• ( Coming Soon....) For those who are just starting to read this book, I want to promise you that I'll make sure I finish this book this year, no matter what.....
Almost
Sometimes I catch myself wondering how I ended up juggling early morning swim practices, a full course load, and the whirlwind of campus life-all while carrying the weight of expectations from a dad who once dominated professional hockey and a mom who's a force in the fashion world. Maybe that's why I'm so good at keeping my guard up, hiding behind perfect times in the pool and a quick, practiced wit. I first crossed paths with Cam Reid after being dragged to a party the night I moved into my freshman dorm. He was everything the rumors promised: a hockey phenom with a magnetic pull and a reputation for effortless charm, especially with the ladies. But after a horrible pick-up attempt, I did what the rest of the girls at the party would deem unthinkable-I turned him down, making it clear I wasn't interested in being just another story for him. But instead of turning away, Cam proved himself to be more than a headline or a rumor. We built something real-a steady, solid, and surprisingly uncomplicated friendship. But that's the thing about lines drawn in friendships-they're not always as permanent as you think. One night, everything changed, and the laughter and late-night talks began to blur into something I couldn't quite define, and suddenly, every instinct to keep things platonic began to feel impossible to follow.
Icarus
Summary: This story is about an incredible unique autistic girl and her two equally incredible best friends. Will they ever get out of the friend zone? A little taste of the story: Is it a sin to love someone too much? To say I miss her is an understatement. I can't eat. Can't sleep. Can't function. She is constantly on my mind as she dwelled herself deep inside my heart. My heart aches for her. Every time I think of her, I smile but my heart hurts like hell because she lives far away. Too far. Sometimes all I can do is lie in bed and hope to fall asleep before I fall apart. Is it wrong to love someone this deeply at such an early age? I have inappropriate thoughts about her...about us. Not, as we are presently but grown up as adults. I'm jealous of my twin brother because he wants to take her from me. I can't let go of what's making me sad because its also the only thing that makes me happy. Her. I cannot lose her, because if I do, I will lose my best friend, my smile, my heart, my soul mate, my everything. If it is a sin, I don't think I want to be forgiven because I truly believe that God has sent her into my life to give me something to fight for, to show me there is love in this world, to give me hope and to bring me joy. All the proof I need in God is in her. She is a gift from heaven." ⚠️WARNING ⚠️ * language *drugs & alcohol * violence *assault & rape *nudity & sexComplete
A Girl Can Dream (Dreams Series Spin-off)
Since they were kids Everly and Ryot have been best friends, but as they got older Everly fell in love with him, and she couldn't take the pain of seeing him with other girls so she pulled away and tried to move on. When they see each other again for the first time in years, she's the new physical therapist for his hockey team and needs a place to stay. What could go wrong with being roommates with your childhood best friend you had an unrequited love for? Everything. Tampa Bay Lightning player Ryot James has everything a guy could ever ask for, we'll except for finding love, but that dream got crushed when his parents decided to get a divorce when he was a kid. When his childhood best friend becomes the physical therapist for his team he takes the opportunity to reconnect with his old friend, but can rekindling their friendship and crossing a decade long line make him break his rule about falling in love? * The water sloshes around us as he grabs me to straddle him. He runs his hands up and down my thighs then settles them on my hips. He leans forward and places kisses up my neck while he plays with the strings of my bikini bottoms. I grab ahold of his face, pulling it back from my neck. "Once we do this there's no going back Ry" I said looking into his green eyes. Inappropriate language Sex scenes Mature contentComplete
The Goalie's Good Luck Charm
A one-night stand turns into a high-stakes game of survival when a dental hygienist battling Type 1 diabetes becomes the secret lucky charm of a grumpy goalie. -------------------- One night, fake names, and no strings was supposed to be my escape. Now, I'm the last hope for a pro hockey goalie who thinks I'm some lucky charm capable of flipping his abysmal season. As a Type 1 Diabetic, numbers govern my life: glucose levels, carb counts, and the low balance of my bank account. I moved to San Francisco for a fresh start, not to become the "lucky charm" of a professionally notorious grump. After our steamy, anonymous night, I did the sensible thing: I ran. But the universe flexes a cruel sense of humor. My new job as dental assistant for the San Francisco Bears' pro-hockey team puts me face-to-face-and finger-to-mouth-with the man I can't forget. Connor Schmidt's convinced I'm the cure to his career-worst slump. He's closed-off, stubborn, and way too hot for my professional safety. I need this job to survive. Literally. But with the coach hunting for "distractions" to fire, and Connor refusing to let me go, I'm stuck in a game I can't afford to lose. He's playing for redemption. I'm playing for my life. And the more we lose ourselves in his "luck-with-benefits agreement," the more falling for him is the most reckless thing I've ever done. 18 + for explicit sexual content #1 sports, #1 spicy, #1 hockeyplayer, #1 magurethemes Story is complete.
Serena
I look at him with bewilderment. Emotion floods through me as he looks at me with boredom lacing his eyes. His entire body is calm as he leans against the brick walls and stares down at me. " Oh yeah? Then why did you ignore me today after that moment at the beach? " I say crossing my arms. " What fucking moment? We were all just having some fun. I didn't ignore you, I was busy getting ready for my date. I didn't know the princess needed attention twenty-four seven. " This whole time I have been imagining things? Imagining that he feels the same electricity I do? Growing angry , I take a step forward and our noses barely touch. " Princess? " 2022 #1 in LustComplete
Claimed By My Billionaire Ex
Keeping my baby a secret from my brother's best friend felt right. Until I got knocked up again. My brother warned me to stay away from his arrogant best friend. I should've listened because the jerk ghosted me and left me pregnant. Never to cross his path again, I kept my daughter a secret. Fate had other plans when he pops back up in my life. Lucas Wilson, dominant, bossy and hotter-than-hell. I won't cave into his luscious lips, insanely hot body with rock-hard abs. But the butterflies stirring in my stomach under his intense gaze tell me otherwise. One explosive bed-rocking night and I'm a hot mess. Then he sees my little girl has his deep blue eyes and sweet dimples. Cue, major hyperventilation. My senses tell me to run, but uh, oh...I'm pregnant, again!Complete
The Accidental Art of Sleeping with Your Best Friend
Can a decade-long friendship survive one impulsive night? What was supposed to be a small mishap, one night, one bed, two best friends too drunk to draw the line, suddenly ignited long-buried feelings neither of them dared to confront. Now, caught between the comfort of the past and the uncertainty of something more, they're forced to ask: Can they go back to being just friends? Or has the fire they thought they'd put out already turned into flames they can't control? Will they hold on to what they've built, or let it all turn to ash?Complete
Sudden Seduction
I was never meant to sleep with my best friends dad. I had never met him before. How could I have known? I came to England to get away from my overbearing mother; my best friend Grace told me I could move in with her until I got myself sorted. Then one night, she ditched me for her boyfriend whilst we were out. That's when I met Owen alone at a bar. One thing led to another, and I ended up in a hotel room with a handsome mystery man only to wake up alone. I never expected to see him again year's later at my best friend wedding as the bride's father. The only thing is the night we spent together; I got pregnant. He has a daughter he never knew about. (Please note that I am dyslexic, so they will be some grammar and spelling mistakes.)
Worth the Risk
August & Colin | WRU series | book 1 We take risks. We make mistakes. We lie. We love. We hurt. We lose total control. I took a risk. I paid the price. I made a mistake. I felt the guilt. I lied. I lie. I loved. I try not to. I hurt. I still do. I lost control. I'm losing again. I try to stick to my plan, I try to follow my rules, I try to silence my heart, I try to keep control of the domino stones that represent my life. But one domino fell and the rest just followed. *** "We shouldn't do this," he whispers against my lips. I should applaud him for having the strength to act on that thought because I haven't been able to. At one point I wanted to, but his touches made the impulse to stop vanish. Now, the only thing I want to act on is the longing inside my chest as I think about demolishing the space between us. "Do you want to stop?" I can feel his frown against my forehead. He nudges my nose before placing a featherlight kiss on my mouth. His hands slide over my jawline, his thumbs slowly caressing my cheeks. He gives me another kiss. Slow and deliberately, as if he's still debating the answer to my question as he slicks his tongue over mine. He softly sucks on my bottom lip, dragging it with him when he pulls away. "I can't," he confesses before he presses his lips back on mine. *** All Rights Reserved (Do not copy this story, thank you :))Complete
...'Memories of last summer flooded your brain as your stomach tied itself in knots thinking about the last 4th of July, you and Jere stood looking out on the sunset as he stared into your eyes and kissed you. That moment you will never forget. The moment you realised you loved Jeremiah Fisher.'... Jeremiah and Y/n have always been best friends. You always look forward to your stay at cousins each summer. But this year it's different, ever since you and Jere kissed. You go to cousins every year, flying in from England as you moved there with your mother when you were young. Your best friend Belly, her brother Steven, and their mom Laurel (who is basically your second mother) take you to Susannah's house over summer. You're best friends with Conrad and Jere, but this year it feels different. Over the last year you have had a huge glow up and have become even more gorgeous than you already were. I'm this story you will find yourself travelling through heartbreak, fights, makeups and breakups but will you end up with the one boy you started it all with. Jeremiah Fisher. A/N: This book may contain sensitive references and some 18+ chapters (smut included) but there will always be a warning. This is my first ever book so please tell me feedback, please tell me if I make mistakes and leave suggestions if you want to. I love you all so much and thank your for choosing my story. I will attempt to post as frequently as possible but will notify you all if I have any delay. Thank you so much~ Author.
More detailsContent Guidelines