"But I love you both"/b1
  • Reads 4,260
  • Votes 28
  • Parts 10
  • Time 18m
  • Reads 4,260
  • Votes 28
  • Parts 10
  • Time 18m
Complete, First published Feb 08, 2022
Y/n lives in a nice neighbourhood. They are friends with all the sandlot boys and has a little crush on Benny. But when Phillips and his team comes to the sandlot it all his done hill 

Book 1!
All Rights Reserved
Sign up to add quot;But I love you bothquot;/b1 to your library and receive updates
or
#1bennyyrodriguez
Content Guidelines
You may also like
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
You're Such a Dream to Me{Benny x reader} cover
It's Obvious  cover
It All Started with Baseball cover
Eyes On You // Benny Rodriguez cover
Benny Rodriguez; 1962 cover
Whatever Yeah-Yeah cover
The baseball dad cover
THE BASEBALL CONTEST ; THE SANDLOT - benny r. x black fem reader cover
Never Again cover
The summer of a life time  cover

You're Such a Dream to Me{Benny x reader}

16 parts Complete

{Benny "the Jet" Rodriguez x reader} This is my first story so sorry if it's kind of trashy :D I've seen many Benny Fics that are not x reader so I decided to make one myself for you guys to enjoy ~Story takes place in the 90's~ "Before you speak don't move cause I don't wanna wake up.." You moved from Manhattan, New York to California(I know the sandlot is in Utah but In this story it will be in Cali)and met this group of guys that clearly play baseball. Personally you love baseball and softball and used to play for your school. You go outside to your yard and meet both Benny and Smalls. They ask if you'd like to play with the guys and you finally agreed. You then began to catch feelings for him and you come across a situation that brings you all together. Hope you like it :) I do not own the sandlot characters Completed✅ Highest placement: #2 bennyxreader #1 bennyxreader