I Loved Her First - Syd - Wattpad

I Loved Her First

Reads 4,209
Votes 196
Parts 15
Time 1h 24m

Reads 4,209
Votes 196
Parts 15
Time 1h 24m

Mature

adamcole aew jaywhite lovetriangle njpw originalcharacter originalstory romance wrestlers wrestling

Adam Cole cashes in a favor with an old friend and brings Jay White to AEW. But he never imagined that Jay would bring so many problems along with him. Adam's been in love with Samantha Jackson for as long as he can remember, but fear of losing both her and her brothers has kept his mouth shut. But now Sam is under Jay's spell, and Adam is losing her every second that he keeps his feelings to himself. Does he keep his mouth shut like he always has and watch the girl of his dreams be swept away by Jay? Or does he take a chance and fight for the woman that he loved first?All Rights Reserved

adamcole aew jaywhite lovetriangle njpw originalcharacter originalstory romance wrestlers wrestling

Table of contents

15 parts

Sign up to add I Loved Her First to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Broken Wings by Wrestlinglover12

When Wardlow signed with All Elite Wrestling, he vowed to himself that he would do everything & anything in his power to become world champion... even splitting up from the one woman who had always kept him grounded and calm. However, when he did... What he didn't realise was the pain it would cause. Fast forward to under two years later, and Anastasia Wren Anderson has changed from the girl she once was and is to make her debut in a company that has given her the contract of a lifetime What will happen when the exes come face-to-face for the first time in years , and the Wardog finds out that not only has the woman he still loved with all of his heart was not the woman she was, but that she had had a child. Will old feelings reignite or will the woman finally find someone that will truly accept her... scars and all

Birth Of A 200 Pound (WWE Fanfic) by 1D_WWE

Kim is over 200 pounds and is in love with schoolmate Dean Ambrose who is dating Renee Young. She dreams of one day being his girlfriend and maybe marrying him. Dean's best friend Roman Reigns cares for Kim and comforts her when she's left for embarrassment. One day Kim disappears after being hurt and embarrassed by Dean; Roman searches for Kim, but no signs of her. 1 year later Kim returns back to UCLA under the name Kansas Milwaukee to get her revenge on Dean. Dean comes across Kansas and is interested in her, he befriends her and introduces her to Roman. Roman and Kim soon clicks like the old days, and slowly he opens up to her about his feelings for Kim, which makes her thinks twice about wanting to be with Dean. Renee soon picks up the friendship of Kansas and Dean and starts to get jealous. Kim later reveals to Roman that she's Kim and Renee puts the puzzle/stories together and hints Dean which makes him confront Kansas being Kim. Will she reveal she is Kim or hide it

Mudshock (Cole x Jay x Nya) by SmallGothClifford

[**PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE READING FANFIC** Cover is by me, I drew it! Please ask me first before using it in anything! My discord is JACK DØN#8705, don't be shy to ask me! I will not update this on a regularly basis, I have other things going on in my life and im doing this for fun!] When the time comes for Nya to choose between Cole or Jay. Nya can't find it in herself to choose either without leaving the other, so she proposes a third option. Will it work out? Who knows! They certainly don't! :D

Was It All Worth It? by incorrectTryagain

After being together for 12 years, Kayla thought she knew her husband like the back of her hand. She thought he was loyal, and faithful and had devoted his life to her. Of course, that's what she believed but boy was she wrong. It took one text from a friend for all of that to go away. All those things she fantasized about. The person she thought she knew more than anyone, who was supposed to have her back through it all, betrayed her. After deciding to file for divorce, she started to get her life back on track. She decided it was time for her to live for her, but her plans were derailed when a childhood crush reenters her life. Her husband decided he wasn't going to give up on his wife so easily which caused a battle between the two men. Two men fighting to win her heart and in the end Kayla asked herself. 'Was it all worth it?'

We Are Your Mami by JDJoker19

Jared and Tay have been in an open relationship for over 6 months now as they got married just 2 months ago but a certain friend of Tay got Jared's attention so he decides to win her over and get her to fall in love with him and Tay Will Jared succeed and get the hottest and toughest women that will choke anyone out? All characters are over 18+ (Mature content)

In a Heartbeat by LifeBlood93

One day, Ryan Bowman was invited by his brother-in-law to hang out with some of his friends who are wrestlers in the WWE on a show called NXT. He meets his brother-in-law's friends who take a liking to him. One person in particular takes more of a liking to him than anyone else and they get along pretty quickly after they get to know each other and they find out that they have some things in common and over time as they get closer and closer, Ryan starts to worry about telling her all about his childhood as in the past he has told people and after finding out about it, they wanted nothing to do with him. But what happens when he eventually does tell her all about his childhood ? As they get closer, will they end up developing feelings for each other ?

My Unexpected Lover *Completed* by Mrs_Orton25

WWE Diva AJ Lee thought she would never find love........until she meets the guy of her dreams, CM Punk. But as time goes on, the relationship gets rocky. He's really just using her to get the WWE Championship. He goes from this loveable man she met on NXT to the boyfriend from hell. But then as Punk starts spending time with her, he starts catching feelings. She confides in her good friend, Randy Orton. But after a storyline kiss and she starts seeing him more, she starts catching feelings for him, and he feels the same way. Soon they are in this spicy love affair. Will her acts catch up to her, will she break up with her abusive and controlling boyfriend and have a happy relationship with the REAL man of her dreams, or will CM Punk reconsider his plan and ask her out?

3 Wishes of Thunder by Sunnyninja13

Plot: After all of the crazy events, Jay went out alone to talk to Ed and Edna about his real parents until Nadakhan appeared in front of them and threatened Jay to go with him or else he end up killing Ed and Edna in front of him. Afraid of letting the people he love die in front of him, Jay end up going with Nadakhan. Meanwhile, Nya got back from the doctors and got shocking news! (You readers can guess of what happened to Nya). Realizing her boyfriend haven't come back, she and the rest of the Ninja figure out what happened to Jay. "Jay!" -Nya "I'm not Jay, dear, call me Thunder" -Jay "Nya! Look out!" -Cole "I wished for my friends to be away from us" -Jay "Your wish is yours to keep" -Nadakhan "Nya, you okay?" -Kai "Yeah, I'm okay except the part I'm........................." -Nya "Jay have 2 more wishes and he can do anything for those two wishes for me to grant to him. All I need is for Jay to feel more heartless than ever. I'll do everything to kill Nya!" -Nadakhan "Ninjago's lives are in stake. We have to kill Jay in order to stopped him for Nadakhan to prevent granting his 2 wishes" -Zane "It's risky but it's for Ninjago and we won't let Ninjago fall" -Lloyd

Last shot to redemption [a Adam Cole story] by Joy_of_life88

~ A Adam Cole Story~ How can the actions of a single person change the lives of many others? Adam makes the biggest mistake of his life by trusting a person from his past more than his fiancée. Will he be successful in making redemption? ~Sequel "After the redemption"~ Special shout-out to @wrestlingfangirl2593 for the suggestion to turn this into a book. Startet August 28, 2020 Finished October 19, 2020 Word count: 25.890 Time to read: 103 minutes

Undeniable Treasure | Ninjago Bruise by lightningearth

Cole's feelings for jay keep getting in the way, it tears their friendship apart but then they're in love?? yeah im confused too

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Broken Wings cover

Birth Of A 200 Pound (WWE Fanfic) cover

Mudshock (Cole x Jay x Nya) cover

Was It All Worth It? cover

We Are Your Mami cover

In a Heartbeat cover

My Unexpected Lover *Completed* cover

3 Wishes of Thunder cover

Last shot to redemption [a Adam Cole story] cover

Undeniable Treasure | Ninjago Bruise cover

Broken Wings

When Wardlow signed with All Elite Wrestling, he vowed to himself that he would do everything & anything in his power to become world champion... even splitting up from the one woman who had always kept him grounded and calm. However, when he did... What he didn't realise was the pain it would cause. Fast forward to under two years later, and Anastasia Wren Anderson has changed from the girl she once was and is to make her debut in a company that has given her the contract of a lifetime What will happen when the exes come face-to-face for the first time in years , and the Wardog finds out that not only has the woman he still loved with all of his heart was not the woman she was, but that she had had a child. Will old feelings reignite or will the woman finally find someone that will truly accept her... scars and all