Addalynne Shields is a 16-year old Catholic girl, who is trying to keep her sexuality a secret from everyone. After sneaking out one night to party with her friends, she meets Carmen Blakely, a 17-year old who has a very vague background, and is also keeping a secret of her own. The two unknowingly bond, and fall for each other. But knowing that her family would not approve, Addalynne is unsure of what will come of the relationship.