Salem's Scarlet Letter
- Reads 12,872
- Votes 324
- Parts 17
MatureOngoing2h 2m
Last published Wed, Jan 14, 2026
Calling all Wagatha shippers!
Wanda left Agatha trapped as the "Nosy Neighbor" when she took down The Hex. What will happen when they are reunited? Are these two witches destined for tragedy? Or will they save each other?
**This story takes place after Wandavision and SpiderMan NWH
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
You're Not Alone (Wanda Maximoff x Fem Reader)
Y/N, a mutant who was once part of the Avengers but chose to go off the grid after Thanos erased half the universe's population. She decided to live in a cabin far from the civilization. Y/N's living peacefully in her small cabin until she started having visions of a certain person who she thought disappeared. Will she be able to tell the witch her real feelings this time, or will she choose to hide them like what she did years ago? Updates every SaturdayComplete
The true Love
⚠️ spicy ⚠️ Y/n, Wanda and Natasha accidentally fall in love with each other. But who will they all choose to stay with? What will happen in the future.... with the people we love? with our Enemies? Only time will tell! -- X Fem reader (I don't own rights for the characters) Discord : https://discord.gg/HvHB345USfComplete
Indigo Meets Scarlet (Wanda x Y/n)
Y/n was kidnapped by Hydra and exposed to the mind stone, receiving powers nobody quite understood the extent of. After a year and a half under Hydra captivity, she was rescued by the Avengers in Russia on their search for Loki's sceptre. After Natasha's guidance, the rest of the team welcomed her into their ranks and trained her to be an avenger. 6 months later they're scouting another lead on the sceptre in Sokovia when Y/n crosses paths with a witch she can't ignore... Wanda x femreader I do not own any of the characters in this so rights to Marvel for most of it pls don't sue me PSA -she/her pronouns are used but change if you use other pronouns:) sorry! - y/n is a vegan in my books bc i wouldn't feel comfortable writing a meat eater since i'm vegan too! (if u eat meat tho u go for it) - i write similar characters/scenes bc i'm uNoRiGinAl and romanticise shit in my head😃 mature content so 18+ children, go do ur homework book 2 out now🥳Complete
a sad witch and a broken dame (A Wanda Maximoff Fanfic)
Right after Wanda destroys Mount Wundagore, she is transported to another universe where superheroes don't exist, rendering her powerless and making her a normal human being. And then she meets you. (Also, might be worth to mention that Lizzie and Wanda are not the same person. And Wanda jumped to a universe where she didn't exist. 😅) (F/F relationship 🏳️🌈)Complete
The Neighbor (Book 1 Older Version 2023)
21 year old Y/n just moved across the street from the Maximoffs. You are successful at a young age working for Stark Space Administration. Wanda is in a loveless marriage with Vision. For her twin boys, she stays in the marriage thinking it could work out. What happens when Wanda meets you. Will she stay in the loveless marriage? Or will she finally realize what she deserves? Warnings: ⚠️ (triggers could include; Violence/blood/death/explosions/bombs/guns/injuries/panic attacks/mass causalities/ torture, possessiveness, jealousy) please avoid chapters with ⚠️ that may obtain these triggers. There will be cliffhangers!! LOTS OF DETAILED MATURE SMUT/ Sexual content (labeled with * to show intensity) Other dark topics Female Reader (Second book I've written still practicing on my writing skills) This is a non-commercial fan work. I do not own the character Wanda Maximoff or the image used in the cover. All rights belong to Marvel and the respective creators.Complete
Time casts its spell on you || Agthario
"He might live without you here, I know if you stay he won't and I need him Rio, I need him like he's a part of me," she tried to explain. There was a bit of both of them in Nicky but where Rio had given death, Agatha had given life. To loose Nicky would be to loose a bit of her life and what she lost Rio would gain in Death. It was a bargain in which Agatha had more to loose. ~ ~ Inspired by the Agatha All Along Marvel tv series, Here to give an in-depth sapphic backstory into how Rio and Agatha met, how Agatha got her powers and their relationship that led up to the events of the show. First chapter isn't my best writing but it gets better I promise.Complete
Ours Now (The Neighbor Book 2)
The war is over. The world is quiet... but inside your home, everything has changed. You and Wanda are still standing married, in love, and stronger than ever. But the pain of losing what you both wanted has left cracks neither of you know how to fill. Grief lingers like a shadow, and love alone might not be enough to keep it at bay. Just as you begin to find your footing again, a new threat rises one that doesn't come from the battlefield, but could shatter everything you've built together. Can your love survive the weight of loss and the danger ahead, or will this be the fight that breaks you both? Warnings: ⚠️ (triggers could include; Violence/blood/death/explosions/bombs/guns/injuries/panic attacks/mass causalities/ torture, possessiveness, jealousy) please avoid chapters with ⚠️ that may obtain these triggers. This is a non-commercial fan work. I do not own the character Wanda Maximoff or the image used in the cover. All rights belong to Marvel and the respective creators. No
Time Is Limited (Zooey Kern x M!Reader)
Zoeey finds her boyfriend Matt in bed with another woman and decides to move back home with her parents until she gets her own apartment. In that time she is home, she bumps into her ex husband Y/N Y/L/N. They both exchange numbers to catch up with each other and they soon become friends. What will happen, will they both realise that they are both still in love with each other or are just destined to remain friends?Complete
ENEMIES TO LOVERS (N.R. X F.R. (G!P)
Natasha and Y/n were close when they were younger. What will happen when they grow apart because of what happened in the past. Will they warm up to each other and become friends. Maybe even become lovers or will they still hate each other and stay enemies? This is my first story pls don't judge! There might be spelling mistakes. If you don't like it then don't read it... I hope you enjoy!Complete
Our Destiny - The Red Web
Book Two - A year has passed since Wanda heard Y/N call out for her at the cabin. There has been no trace or connection from Y/N since, no matter how hard Wanda has tried to recreate it. Wanda has rejoined the Avengers in the hope that as a team again they can piece together what they know and find Y/N. Y/N isn't the same anymore. Her memories are gone. Her mind no longer belongs to her. All she knows is what the Red Web want her to know. The Avengers are the enemy, they must be destroyed. Can destiny be put back on the right path? Some chapters will be 18+ and will have a ⚠️ warning attached.Complete
Y/N, a mutant who was once part of the Avengers but chose to go off the grid after Thanos erased half the universe's population. She decided to live in a cabin far from the civilization. Y/N's living peacefully in her small cabin until she started having visions of a certain person who she thought disappeared. Will she be able to tell the witch her real feelings this time, or will she choose to hide them like what she did years ago? Updates every Saturday
More detailsContent Guidelines