My Sister's Best Friend
  • Reads 526,193
  • Votes 17,210
  • Parts 34
  • Time 5h 30m
  • Reads 526,193
  • Votes 17,210
  • Parts 34
  • Time 5h 30m
Complete, First published Apr 17, 2022
Mature
I've been in love with Maya Garcia since I saw her for the first time in seventh grade. I know it's cliche, and I know it sounds unrealistic, but I swear it's the truth. 

She was everything I wanted in a girl and more, and It didn't take more than three hours for me to figure that out. Maya was feisty, outspoken, confident, and she didn't change herself for anyone. She was undoubtedly herself, and it was intoxicating. She was perfect. 

But there was just one tiny thing getting in the way of having her all to myself: Maya Garcia just so happened to be my sister's best friend, which made her completely, one hundred percent off limits. 

What are the fucking odds, right?

_____

Part of the Hidden Attraction series! 

You do NOT need to read the other books beforehand, however, I recommend it to avoid spoilers in the comments :)

1. My Brother's Best Friend
2. In Five Years
3. The Perfect Timing
All Rights Reserved
This story contains Extras.Learn more.
Sign up to add My Sister's Best Friend to your library and receive updates
or
Content Guidelines
You may also like
A Poet's Secret by ookayooh
16 parts Complete
Being in love with your best friend isn't the ideal life situation but for Zora, it's her only life situation. Secretly harboring her feelings for her best friend, Sierra, Zora pours her emotions into her journal in the form of poetry. After years of keeping her attraction for her friend at bay and trying to deny her feelings by forcing herself to love a boy who unconditionally loves her, Zora's favorite emotional outlet becomes the cause of her life falling apart as the truth finally comes out. ***** It was happening again. It was dark, sunset, I waited for her to be done with volleyball practice 'because she was my ride'. Somehow we wandered from the gym to the football field and we were sitting at the very top of the bleachers staring at each other. Her dark hair mirrored the direction of the wind, the setting sun being replaced by the brightness of her smile. We were sitting so close I could feel her warmth. It was an unusual situation. Friends don't do this. We held eye contact for a long time before I couldn't take it anymore and just closed my eyes. It wasn't real, she was just my friend. Then, I felt her tuck a strand of my curly hair behind my ear. That with the chill of the night sent shivers down my spine and a swarm of butterflies attacked my stomach. I reopened my eyes. If she didn't want me, why did she look at me that way? I held her hand and I held it for so long because I didn't know if we'd have another moment like this. We talk and laugh and she tells me I'm pretty and I ask her if she'd just noticed that and we laugh again. I realize the feelings I felt in that moment were not just the intense feelings of attraction that I felt every time I was with her. Warmth flooded to my face and if it wasn't for my dark complexion, my blush would be noticeable. I look into her dark-colored eyes and I come to the conclusion that I'm royally fucked and I'm probably also in love.
Life long with you? by thewrittenHE4RTS
31 parts Ongoing Mature
"**Whispers of a new beginning**" "How could I forget that getting girls is just like getting another mission-if you don't get one, you try to get another-again?" It was obvious from her voice that she was hurt. "How can I help? It's only an everyday thing." His response simply shattered the broken pieces of her heart. "I don't want you to show these cheap habits of yours to my employees." This time, she spoke a little too loudly and appeared to be jealous when she saw her husband flirting with her own employee. "Knowing me, I don't think it should bother you." He replied "But it is. You should be within your limits as my husband, at the very least in my office."She noticed that her employee's attention had strayed towards them, so she warned him in a firm yet hushed voice. "Husband, Do you "personally" agree with this statement?" Utsav asked in mockery. Maya went on in an agitated voice, "At least for them, you are so behave like one." "Do you really want me to behave like "husband"?" Utsav questioned, gazing directly into her eyes. When two people who were best friends before becoming husband and wife are compelled to marry because of unforeseen circumstances, despite having completely different personalities and values. Let's join their journey and witness how their love blossoms, whether they can hold onto their priceless friendship, which they both treasure and how their relationship evolves. Start : Jun 15- 2024
[excerpt] Chaos & the Geek (Grace Grayson Security Book 1) by writeriz
4 parts Complete Mature
*now available on all retailers* Amber How do you politely refuse when the only guy to star in any of your dirty fantasies has just offered to put you up for the foreseeable future and your brother's just accepted like you were in fact still thirteen and couldn't make decisions for yourself? You don't. And, you end up with a roommate who wears a very good elegant mask over the rough and tumble, bad boy core I remember far too well. Only, it's ten years later and I'm even nerdier than I used to be. It's ten years later and I couldn't look worse. It's ten years later and I can't keep one guy. It's ten years later and my brother still teases me mercilessly in front of him. It's ten years later and Kit somehow looks even better than the guy I spent my formative years crushing on. Except, there might just be a smouldering heat in Kit's eyes that suggests he's not quite as out of my league as I thought. Just maybe, this geek is about to get a whole lot of chaos. Kit When I find out about my best mate's little sister's situation, the offer is out of my mouth before I can stop it; Hawk's like a brother to me even if Amber's never looked twice at me. I could never tell if she was scared of me or hated me. But the deal is done. She's going to bring her bedraggled self upstairs to my penthouse and live with me for as long as she needs. I see the pain she hides away, I see the lack of confidence despite how smart she is, how good. If there's something I've learned, it's that confidence makes all the difference. So, it becomes my mission to help Amber find her confidence. But I find more than confidence in her and suddenly I'm seeing my best mate's little sister completely differently. Except, there might be something in the way she smiles at me that gives me hope I'm not as far out of her league as I thought. It might just be time that this chaos gets a little geek.
Riley and Devin by RoseAndBone
83 parts Complete Mature
"How many romance books do you read?" Devin asks me. I shrug. "I like them," I say. I keep browsing, running my fingers along the spines. "So, you like romance then?" he asks me. I nod. "What's your favorite part of a love story?" "I like the very first kiss, but I like the second one even more," I say. I bite my lip and look at him. Oh. My. God. What the hell am I doing? Am I flirting? I think that I'm actually flirting. With Devin. Devin, my best friend. I have officially lost my mind. I should probably stop. But I can't seem to. "Will you grab me that one?" I ask. I point above my head, my back's pressed against the bookcase. He locks his gaze on mine and reaches over me to grab the book I asked for. "Thanks." I don't move and neither does he. Riley and Devin have been best friends forever-since Kindergarten. It's Senior year of high school, now. And it's always been simple, Riley's got his back, he's got hers. But as life goes on Riley can't help but wonder if maybe he's not just her best friend, if she likes him as possibly something more. As her feelings deepen and become something greater it becomes more evident that she's falling, really hard. No matter how hard Riley tries she can't stop falling, she can't stop from loving him. Even if it tears her to pieces or even if it destroys their friendship. Pretty soon Riley is going to have to choose between walking the safe line of friendship or taking the unpaved path of love. Will she risk everything for love?
My Shades of Gray by SnowWhite1309
64 parts Complete Mature
Isabella Harper, a nineteen-year-old, lost her color vision after her sister's suicide. She shut down herself from everyone and remained in her world until her parents force her to go to college. She couldn't get into a hotshot university since she was home-schooled. Isabella settled with a community college in Dunwoody, Georgia. Trying to live a normal life with her vision, Isabella is dragged into a whole new world. Everything happens for a reason. She met new people, experiences new emotions, and discovers secrets and the reason behind her sister's death. Now she wants revenge. Battling demons from her past, going to underground fights and nightclubs, hacking into a porn site, and on top of everything, there's Hunter Armstrong. Warning ⚠️ This book contains dark themes, mature and triggering content, i.e. description/talk of suicide, rape, porn, and mature language. ~^~^~^~ His lips cupped mine, and a swell of warmth unfurled in my heart. It was gentle and soft, something I never expected from a guy like him. He moved his right hand from my cheek to my waist, tugging me against him, and molded our bodies together. A wave of electricity went down to my core when he licked my lips. "Open your mouth, Bella." His commanding husky voice against my lips jolted my heart, and I followed his order like a slave. With no control, a moan erupted from my throat as his tongue met mine. It was barely audible, but I knew he heard it when he smiled against my lips. He swept my hair from my face to my back and gathered them in his fist. He tugged my head back, deepening the kiss, and my heart thrashed in my chest. At that moment, I didn't need drugs to know what being high felt like because his lips were enough to send me on nine clouds. Just once and I was addicted to it. If this is how being kissed feels like, then fuck, I've wasted a lot of time. ~^~^~^~ FEATURED ON: @Romance (Romantic Suspense) HIGHEST RANKINGS: #1 Goodgirl, Darkpast #2 Badboy #5 Newadult
Loving Kali Daniels (StudentxTeacher) (GxG) by JTB291
66 parts Ongoing Mature
Kali Daniels is a 19-year-old student at Westview High School. She is half-Italian, loyal, and protective. She can be girly and tomboyish. She would go to any lengths to protect her younger sister Lily, who is her best friend and confidante. She fiercely defends those she cares about and those who are defenseless and she is slowly learning how to let people in and trust people, particularly Ms. Amore. Kali's temper flares at certain times, leading to impulsive and aggressive reactions. Isabella Amore is a passionate 24-year-old, the new Biology/Chemistry teacher at Westview High School. Her bitter breakup ultimately led her to the decision to move to a new town. Half-Italian, she inherited her grandparents' warmth and fiery spirit, radiating an aura of kindness and intelligence. Isabella is a dedicated teacher with a thirst for knowledge and a genuine love for teaching her students. Sparks fly when they interact with each other and Lily makes it her mission to bring the two together. Will their journey be drama-free or drama-filled? *** "Kali," I whispered, "I want you." A faint blush spread across her cheeks. "I want you too," she replied. In that instant, time seemed to stand still. We kissed in a slow, passionate embrace that ignited every nerve in my body. She pulled me against her, her hands roaming my curves. I melted into her touch, my breath ragged. Before we went any further, Kali stopped me. "Wait," she said, looking directly into my eyes. "What is it?" I asked, concerned. "I need to know that you're sure about this," Kali said, her eyes filled with uncertainty. I looked into her beautiful eyes and knew that she was being sincere. "I'm sure," I said, my voice unwavering. "I'm very sure, Kali." Kali smiled a radiant, breathtaking smile. "Okay Bella," she whispered into my ear. She nibbled my earlobe, earning a moan from me. "Can you keep quiet or are you a screamer?" "Fuck me and find out," I demanded.
You may also like
Slide 1 of 20
A Poet's Secret cover
Life long with you? cover
[excerpt] Chaos & the Geek (Grace Grayson Security Book 1) cover
Finally (m.h. x l.f.) cover
Meet Me After Class cover
Spencer and the Bad Boy cover
My Depressing Life cover
to live for the hope of it all. cover
To Love Your Best friend [B×B]  cover
Riley and Devin cover
My Shades of Gray cover
A Kiss for Maya  cover
Loving Your Imperfections cover
His Heart (COMPLETED) cover
Every Little Thing cover
'M' is For... cover
Loving Kali Daniels (StudentxTeacher) (GxG) cover
The Perfect Timing cover
An Unexpected Moment cover
Blame The Weeds (gxg) cover

A Poet's Secret

16 parts Complete

Being in love with your best friend isn't the ideal life situation but for Zora, it's her only life situation. Secretly harboring her feelings for her best friend, Sierra, Zora pours her emotions into her journal in the form of poetry. After years of keeping her attraction for her friend at bay and trying to deny her feelings by forcing herself to love a boy who unconditionally loves her, Zora's favorite emotional outlet becomes the cause of her life falling apart as the truth finally comes out. ***** It was happening again. It was dark, sunset, I waited for her to be done with volleyball practice 'because she was my ride'. Somehow we wandered from the gym to the football field and we were sitting at the very top of the bleachers staring at each other. Her dark hair mirrored the direction of the wind, the setting sun being replaced by the brightness of her smile. We were sitting so close I could feel her warmth. It was an unusual situation. Friends don't do this. We held eye contact for a long time before I couldn't take it anymore and just closed my eyes. It wasn't real, she was just my friend. Then, I felt her tuck a strand of my curly hair behind my ear. That with the chill of the night sent shivers down my spine and a swarm of butterflies attacked my stomach. I reopened my eyes. If she didn't want me, why did she look at me that way? I held her hand and I held it for so long because I didn't know if we'd have another moment like this. We talk and laugh and she tells me I'm pretty and I ask her if she'd just noticed that and we laugh again. I realize the feelings I felt in that moment were not just the intense feelings of attraction that I felt every time I was with her. Warmth flooded to my face and if it wasn't for my dark complexion, my blush would be noticeable. I look into her dark-colored eyes and I come to the conclusion that I'm royally fucked and I'm probably also in love.