Heroes (We Could Be)

Sam and Dean Winchester save Beck Lindsey, a young woman from an alternate reality, from drowning. Beck must decide how much her story will change, if she wants to return to her old life, and how to navigate falling for the "bad boy" of Supernatural, while also figuring out her willingness to change and her desire to return to her old life.

I have previously posted this story on fanfiction.net and ao3 under the name Ordinary Day!, but was unsatisfied with the way it turned out and abandoned those attempts with the story incomplete. So if this story seems familiar to you that's why.