Sanders Sides Pirate Au

Joan is a pirate captain on the search for treasure when one of their crew mates, Thomas, informs them about an island, seemingly in the middle of nowhere, full of gold and unimaginable and fascinating creatures. But the island is rumored to be dangerous and no man has ever fully gotten to the island and made it back.

Joan, blinded by their greed and curiosity, orders the ship to go towards the island. unfortunately for them and their ship, a storm completely destroys their ship, crew and materials on there, leaving them and Thomas and his brothers; Remus and Roman, stranded in the middle of nowhere. after a few days they end up waking up inside an unfamiliar house. Turns out, a lonely whitch named Talyn found them and took them into their home to help heal them of their injuries. While Thomas is frantically trying to find a way to get back home, Joan has been struck by cupid's bow and has fallen deeply in love with Talyn. Roman has sort of started a cult and Remus has gone missing.

On top of all this, they're stuck on an unfamiliar island that's the equivalent to a "tropical" Bermuda triangle.
Dealing with the guilt of causing their crew to die, a homesick friend, and their one and only soulmate, they find themselves conflicted and need to decide who to choose and to actually trust.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sanders sides characters are in this, they're just not the main part of the plot. They are important. Also I don't know if I'll add ships. I don't plan to right now.

Trigger warning(s): death, toxic relationships, transphobia, homophobia

Nothing too bad but I'll mention them to be safe