The Angel Butcher of Rio Bravo: An RDR2 Story
goodbyelisahoney
  • Reads 26,734
  • Votes 1,050
  • Parts 44
  • Time 7h 7m
  • Reads 26,734
  • Votes 1,050
  • Parts 44
  • Time 7h 7m
goodbyelisahoney
Complete, First published Jul 12, 2022
Mature
arthurmorgandutchvanderlindehoseamatthewsjohnmarstonlovetrianglerdrrdr2reddeadredemption2smutwarningvanderlindegang
[ Arthur Morgan / John Marston x OC love triangle ] 

"Let me be sweet to you," she murmured, nuzzling into his neck. "I'm always giving you such a time, aren't I?"

*

Tine Nilsen, known outside of the law as the Butcher of Rio Bravo, is a fearsome member of the Van der Linde gang when they run afoul of the Pinkerton detective agency in Blackwater. But will she help steer the gang and its two key gunslingers - Arthur Morgan and John Marston - right? Or will she be responsible for its downfall?

*

Well, here I go again, folks! Tine Nilsen was an OC cooked up for an otherworldly short story in my RDR2 collection, BELLICOSE (that story is called "Left Behind"). I liked her and her dynamic with Arthur and John so much, I thought I'd give this a spin! It will follow events of the game for the most part, but with the omission of a certain character, expect things to change, some. 

This story was completed on February 23, 2023. Hopefully you'll like it! 

This is a mature story written for mature, 18+ audiences: violence, swears, smut will all be within, reader beware. 

RDR2 and related characters/settings belong to Rockstar Games.
All Rights Reserved
arthurmorgandutchvanderlindehoseamatthewsjohnmarstonlovetrianglerdrrdr2reddeadredemption2smutwarningvanderlindegang
Table of contents

44 parts

Sign up to add The Angel Butcher of Rio Bravo: An RDR2 Story to your library and receive updates
or
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Under The Eyes of The Wolf (an rdr2 Arthur Morgan x oc story) by reddfoxx29
52 parts Complete Mature
The van der Linde gang has taken shelter deep in the snowy mountains in an old mining camp known as Colter, following their botched robbery in the town of Blackwater. They are cold, hungry and unsure of what their futures hold. As Arthur Morgan is out desperately trying to track down game to bring back and feed to the starving gang he stumbles across an animal unlike any even he, in all of his travels, has ever seen before. In the process of finding out the unique story behind it he meets a woman. He can't decide if this woman's presence in the same desolate, snow covered wilderness as he and the gang are in is mere coincidence or if there's more behind it than she's letting on. If it is pure coincidence that she's there than what is she doing alone on this frozen mountain? Whatever has brought her into his life he isn't sure but what he does know is he can't get her image out of his mind. Her bright red hair along with her piercing gaze that seems to stare right through him. As he attempts to find out more about her he convinces himself it's strictly out of caution. It's his responsibility to make sure that she's harmless and poses no threat to them but somehow deep down he already knows the only thing she poses a threat to is his heart. Warnings: will contain adult themes, adult language, sexual situations and dialogue, smut, violence, mentions of sexual abuse and other topics not suitable for children under 18. MATURE CONTENT. 18+ only. If you are under 18, do not read this. All characters besides my own are property of Rockstar Games. I do not claim ownership of any of the characters in this story other than K, Tacoma and Orion and I thank Rockstar for their amazing creative team and all of their work.
MY OUTLAW ↛ JOHN MARSTON by billyscigarette
31 parts Complete Mature
❝ 𝐼𝑑 π‘π‘œπ‘’π‘™π‘‘ π‘™π‘Žπ‘ π‘‘. βžπ‘€π‘Žπ‘–π‘ π‘–π‘’ π‘ β„Žπ‘Ÿπ‘’π‘”π‘”π‘’π‘‘, π‘™π‘’π‘Žπ‘›π‘–π‘›π‘” π‘π‘Žπ‘π‘˜ 𝑖𝑛 π‘‘β„Žπ‘’ π‘β„Žπ‘Žπ‘–π‘Ÿ. ❝ 𝐼𝑑 π‘€π‘œπ‘›'𝑑. 𝐼 𝑗𝑒𝑠𝑑 β„Žπ‘œπ‘π‘’ β„Žπ‘’ π‘π‘Ÿπ‘’π‘Žπ‘˜π‘  𝑖𝑑 π‘œπ‘“π‘“ π‘π‘’π‘“π‘œπ‘Ÿπ‘’ 𝐼 β„Žπ‘Žπ‘£π‘’ π‘‘π‘œ. ❞ ❝ 𝐻𝑒 π‘€π‘œπ‘›'𝑑. ❞ *‒𓆙‒* A 24 year old named Amara Findlay was born into a wealthy family along with her sister, Maisie Findlay. Her life seemed so perfect to everyone else but in reality her parents, Sandy and Micheal Findlay were toxic people, wanting their children to do things for their business whether the two sisters like it or not. Amara's mother pushes her to find a suitor, as being the eldest in the family that is her duty to find a wealthy man to settle down with. But, Amara refuses to settle down with anyone for everyone that has interest in her isn't good enough. In 1899, on a sunny afternoon, Amara goes to Valentine with her sister, Maisie. They meet a man there named John Marston. Maisie introduces herself and Amara to the man and become acquainted with him, Amara doesn't fully trust the man, despite her slight attraction to him. John is immediately attracted to Amara and tries to become closer with her, but Amara still keeps up her guard. Will Amara Findlay learn to trust John? And if so, what will happen? Started: September 6, 2020 Finished: June 20, 2021 COMPLETED [THE STORY IS THE ONLY THING THAT BELONGS TO ME I DONT OWN RDR2 OR ANYTHING ASSOCIATED WITH IT! SOME EVENTS IN THE GAME WILL BE CHANGED TO GO ALONG WITH THE STORY LINE]
Unplanned - A RDR2 Fanfic (OCxArthur) by ponyboygrimes
61 parts Complete Mature
[[A slow burn OCxArthur story with both new and original characters]] They say the best things in life are unplanned. But sometimes... they're the worst. After the Blackwater catastrophe, Arthur feels the heavy weight of responsibility; being one of the gang members looked up to and relied upon to get them out of this mess, he's strained by the notion that they may not be getting out this time. With the West slowly transformed into a civilized hellhole, they are forced to move in all directions despite the place they wanted to return to most. Grimly aware that the age of outlaws may be up, Arthur does what he can under Dutch to get money for their escape, all according to plan... Until a detour. Stuck in a rut of her own, the independent, God-fearing, and wistful Summer Grace Monroe has been searching for her own place in life. After being scorned by lovers and in and out of jobs, she feels amiss her late twenties without a true home. She finds the most peace in her church and helping those in need, especially the local Native population. Her father, Captain Monroe, works within the Army as a voice for those being silenced. She helps others find their story, but what would be her own? Things all seem to take a turn when fate brings a chance encounter, permanently altering whatever path her life was going to take and intertwining her destiny with that of a notorious group of outlaws - yet she would not be the only one whose path would be changed. **This story will contain mature content such as violence/gore, sexual themes, and language. Do not read if you are under 18** [These characters all belong within the Red Dead Redemption universe/Rockstar, but I have made a few original characters and altered storylines.]
NOTHING GOLD CAN STAY: RDR2 by GingerBaggins
53 parts Complete Mature
Nora has spent most of her life in solitude, travelling only with her business partner JB Cripps. Always on the move, never allowing herself the time to face the past that threatens to consume her. That is until she meets a particularly irritating outlaw at a bounty board and her life suddenly bursts into tremendous colour. But when the pendulum swings one way, eventually it'll swing the other. COMPLETE This is a work of fanfiction, with characters from Rockstar's Red Dead Redemption 2 and Red Dead Redemption 2 Online. I do not own this world, nor any character beyond the main OC. Neither do I own any of the literature and titles taken from the works of Robert Frost. (While this story follows along with the timeline and the main plot of the game, there will be divergences in the canon. Mainly that Arthur will not contract TB. As for who else lives and dies, I'm afraid you'll have to find out.)
Joy & Woe - An Alternate RDR2 Story | Arthur Morgan x OC | by ponyboygrimes
49 parts Ongoing Mature
[A Slow Burn Arthur Morgan x OC Story] ~ By 1897, Joyce Robbins is a petty criminal in her late 20s due to a series of unfortunate events - the common denominator for most like her, it seems. Having tragedy struck at a young age, Joyce finds herself plunged into the life of a single woman desperate for work and money to help provide for her and her siblings - and in this world, that only gives you about two options: stealing or selling yourself. So, she opted to steal. Simple memories she'd made long ago seem to determine her fate, however, as some familiar faces show up and completely alter her sullen trajectory. When a fateful meeting goes much differently than expected, Joyce is again left with two choices: die, or keep moving forward. So again, she opts for the latter. ~ [THIS STORY WILL INCLUDE MATURE CONTENT SUCH AS VIOLENCE, GORE, SEXUAL THEMES, ETC. THIS STORY USES CHARACTERS AND INSPIRATION FROM ROCKSTAR'S RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2 AS WELL AS ORIGINAL CHARACTERS.]
π“πŽπ”π†π‡ π†πˆπ‘π‹ | π’π€πƒπˆπ„ 𝐀𝐃𝐋𝐄𝐑 𝐗 πŽπ‚ by bbrea-
41 parts Complete Mature
GOING THROUGH EDITS !! Rosa JuΓ‘rez is a member of the Van Der Linde gang. She's been an outlaw for most of her life. One harsh winter night, the gang rescues a poor widowed woman. This woman makes Rosa realize that there's more to life than what she's been shown. ROSA: A hopeful, overworking, and loudmouth thief, Rosa follows in the footsteps of her gunslinging father. Her father ran away from Mexico in attempt to get away from law when Rosa was six. At thirteen, her father was later hanged leaving Rosa alone. A year later, Dutch, Hosea, and Arthur found her pickpocketing people on the street and immediately took her in. Obsessed with Dutches approval, Rosa does everything in her power to be useful to the Van Der Linde gang. Rosa prides herself in being a hard worker. Despite her compulsive manner of speech, Rosa is a charmer and loyal to those she loves. Maybe even too loyal. Sadie Adler x Fem!OC Told in 1st person
The Rebellious Rescuer COMPLETED!βœ” by RaysInDark
19 parts Complete Mature
COMPLETED!!βœ”οΈ This is an Arthur Morgan X reader story, with you as the main character. You work as a brothel lady in the town called Valentine, and you stumble upon a notorious man that got you to grow feelings for this unknown man. But something comes in between and you get kidnapped by the O'Driscolls, what happens afterward? Well, this is where we let the story tell us... OBS! Some important info; 1. My native language isn't English, misspellings appear. Pls, maintain respect, thanks in advance! 2. Contains mature content, you are forewarned in the chapter! 3. More information in the AN chapter. 4. I'm not the owner of the cover photo or any other pictures in this story!
Guns and Flames (RDR2) by Millugold48
30 parts Complete Mature
❝Charlotte is a strong woman who's not afraid of death. She's been taught how to fight properly and doesn't hesitate to protect those who she loves. But something changes when she moves into the village in the valley... The cold mountains have had an impact on her and it's not easy for her to let go of that lifestyle. Will a certain someone be able to give her the care she's been needing for ages?❞ ------------------------- 【ーCURSING, BLOOD, AGGRESSIVE BEHAVIOR AND ACTIONS ー】 Started: September 4th 2022 Finished: September 16th 2024
//BEARING ARMS//RDR2//ARTHUR x READER by S0UP66
47 parts Complete
Arthur Morgan, a crucial gunslinger of the Van der Linde Gang, joins in on the usual coach robbery, when suddenly, unexpected guests drop by. All before was going according to plan, until hell broke loose and the upper-class Lady (Y/N) stepped into his life. Can the wanted Arthur Morgan finally be able to prove himself that he is capable to love and be loved by another? [Highest Rankings] #1 - arthurmorgan #1 - ps4 #1 - arthurmorganxreader #1 - rockstargames #1 - reddeadredemption2 #1 - reddeadredemption #1 - wildwest #1 - rdr2xreader #1 - playstation #1 - rdr2 #2 - cowboy #3 - dutch #1 - southern #1 - western -Note: Contains violence, suggestive themes, and mature language. -Thank you for voting, commenting, and/ or reading -S0UP66
VANDERMORGAN - THE TRUTH UNTOLD by dark_headspace
7 parts Complete Mature
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ A C T 1 Just cowboys that found eachother and are made for one another. This can even be red if you don't know red dead redemption! I only used The characters and Locations from the game. The story is original. It plays in 1899. You can find the characters in the description! This also deals with the situation of realizing that you are gay/pan/etc. and how others deal with it. The good and the bad way. This is the real struggle people have to live through so be ready for an emotional rollercoaster! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Description: text = narrator : * ... * = actions name: = person, that talks '...' = sarcasm : (...) = persons thoughts ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ contains: - romance - smut - adventure ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Characters: Main: Dutch van der Linde (Gang Leader) Hosea Matthews (Co-Leader) Arthur Morgan (First Member of the gang) Molly O'shea (Member) Side: Susan Grimshaw (Member, "Mother") Pierson (Member, Cook) Micah Bell (Member, sadist) Charles Smith (Member, Native and Hunter) Bill Williamson (Member, Fighter) Leopold Strauss (German, Helps the Gang to get money) John Marston (Member, Married to Abigail and Arthurs best friend) Abigail Roberts (Member, Married to John, used to be a whore) Jack Marston (Member, Son of John and Abigail) Karen Jones (Member, Alcoholic and hates Dutch) Javier Escuella (Member, Mexican and Fighter) Tilly Jackson (Member) Uncle (Member, funny Alcoholic and gets called Uncle from the whole gang) Mary-Beth Gaskill (Member, In love with Dutch) Lenny Summers (Member, Hispanic and smart) Josiah Trelawny (Like Strauss; is helping the gang) Reverend Swanson (Member, saved Dutchs life once and depressed) Sean Macguire (Member, Scottish and funny) Sadie Adler (Gang rescued her, Fighter and in love with Arthur) Pinkertons (They are after Dutch and his gang, something like the police) Ol' Driscoll's (Rival gang, Dutch hates them )
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
Under The Eyes of The Wolf (an rdr2 Arthur Morgan x oc story) cover
MY OUTLAW ↛ JOHN MARSTON cover
Unplanned - A RDR2 Fanfic (OCxArthur) cover
NOTHING GOLD CAN STAY: RDR2 cover
Joy & Woe - An Alternate RDR2 Story | Arthur Morgan x OC | cover
π“πŽπ”π†π‡ π†πˆπ‘π‹ | π’π€πƒπˆπ„ 𝐀𝐃𝐋𝐄𝐑 𝐗 πŽπ‚ cover
The Rebellious Rescuer COMPLETED!βœ” cover
Guns and Flames (RDR2) cover
//BEARING ARMS//RDR2//ARTHUR x READER cover
VANDERMORGAN - THE TRUTH UNTOLD cover

Under The Eyes of The Wolf (an rdr2 Arthur Morgan x oc story)

52 parts Complete Mature

The van der Linde gang has taken shelter deep in the snowy mountains in an old mining camp known as Colter, following their botched robbery in the town of Blackwater. They are cold, hungry and unsure of what their futures hold. As Arthur Morgan is out desperately trying to track down game to bring back and feed to the starving gang he stumbles across an animal unlike any even he, in all of his travels, has ever seen before. In the process of finding out the unique story behind it he meets a woman. He can't decide if this woman's presence in the same desolate, snow covered wilderness as he and the gang are in is mere coincidence or if there's more behind it than she's letting on. If it is pure coincidence that she's there than what is she doing alone on this frozen mountain? Whatever has brought her into his life he isn't sure but what he does know is he can't get her image out of his mind. Her bright red hair along with her piercing gaze that seems to stare right through him. As he attempts to find out more about her he convinces himself it's strictly out of caution. It's his responsibility to make sure that she's harmless and poses no threat to them but somehow deep down he already knows the only thing she poses a threat to is his heart. Warnings: will contain adult themes, adult language, sexual situations and dialogue, smut, violence, mentions of sexual abuse and other topics not suitable for children under 18. MATURE CONTENT. 18+ only. If you are under 18, do not read this. All characters besides my own are property of Rockstar Games. I do not claim ownership of any of the characters in this story other than K, Tacoma and Orion and I thank Rockstar for their amazing creative team and all of their work.

More details