Story cover for The Angel Butcher of Rio Bravo: An RDR2 Story by goodbyelisahoney
The Angel Butcher of Rio Bravo: An RDR2 Story
goodbyelisahoney
  • WpView
    Reads 34,640
  • WpVote
    Votes 1,296
  • WpPart
    Parts 44
  • WpHistory
    Time 7h 7m
  • WpView
    Reads 34,640
  • WpVote
    Votes 1,296
  • WpPart
    Parts 44
  • WpHistory
    Time 7h 7m
goodbyelisahoney
Complete, First published Jul 12, 2022
Mature
arthurmorgandutchvanderlindehoseamatthewsjohnmarstonlovetrianglerdrrdr2reddeadredemption2smutwarningvanderlindegang
[ Arthur Morgan / John Marston x OC love triangle ] 

"Let me be sweet to you," she murmured, nuzzling into his neck. "I'm always giving you such a time, aren't I?"

*

Tine Nilsen, known outside of the law as the Butcher of Rio Bravo, is a fearsome member of the Van der Linde gang when they run afoul of the Pinkerton detective agency in Blackwater. But will she help steer the gang and its two key gunslingers - Arthur Morgan and John Marston - right? Or will she be responsible for its downfall?

*

Well, here I go again, folks! Tine Nilsen was an OC cooked up for an otherworldly short story in my RDR2 collection, BELLICOSE (that story is called "Left Behind"). I liked her and her dynamic with Arthur and John so much, I thought I'd give this a spin! It will follow events of the game for the most part, but with the omission of a certain character, expect things to change, some. 

This story was completed on February 23, 2023. Hopefully you'll like it! 

This is a mature story written for mature, 18+ audiences: violence, swears, smut will all be within, reader beware. 

RDR2 and related characters/settings belong to Rockstar Games.
All Rights Reserved
arthurmorgandutchvanderlindehoseamatthewsjohnmarstonlovetrianglerdrrdr2reddeadredemption2smutwarningvanderlindegang
Table of contents

44 parts

Sign up to add The Angel Butcher of Rio Bravo: An RDR2 Story to your library and receive updates
or
Content Guidelines
You may also like
NOTHING GOLD CAN STAY: RDR2 by GingerBaggins
53 parts Complete Mature
Nora has spent most of her life in solitude, travelling only with her business partner JB Cripps. Always on the move, never allowing herself the time to face the past that threatens to consume her. That is until she meets a particularly irritating outlaw at a bounty board and her life suddenly bursts into tremendous colour. But when the pendulum swings one way, eventually it'll swing the other. COMPLETE This is a work of fanfiction, with characters from Rockstar's Red Dead Redemption 2 and Red Dead Redemption 2 Online. I do not own this world, nor any character beyond the main OC. Neither do I own any of the literature and titles taken from the works of Robert Frost. (While this story follows along with the timeline and the main plot of the game, there will be divergences in the canon. Mainly that Arthur will not contract TB. As for who else lives and dies, I'm afraid you'll have to find out.)
π“πŽπ”π†π‡ π†πˆπ‘π‹ | π’π€πƒπˆπ„ 𝐀𝐃𝐋𝐄𝐑 𝐗 πŽπ‚ by bbrea-
41 parts Complete Mature
GOING THROUGH EDITS !! Rosa JuΓ‘rez is a member of the Van Der Linde gang. She's been an outlaw for most of her life. One harsh winter night, the gang rescues a poor widowed woman. This woman makes Rosa realize that there's more to life than what she's been shown. ROSA: A hopeful, overworking, and loudmouth thief, Rosa follows in the footsteps of her gunslinging father. Her father ran away from Mexico in attempt to get away from law when Rosa was six. At thirteen, her father was later hanged leaving Rosa alone. A year later, Dutch, Hosea, and Arthur found her pickpocketing people on the street and immediately took her in. Obsessed with Dutches approval, Rosa does everything in her power to be useful to the Van Der Linde gang. Rosa prides herself in being a hard worker. Despite her compulsive manner of speech, Rosa is a charmer and loyal to those she loves. Maybe even too loyal. Sadie Adler x Fem!OC Told in 1st person
Dutch's Daughter [[RDR2 Arthur Morgan x OC]] by mmb307
54 parts Complete Mature
After her mother's death, Charlotte finds herself an 11 year old orphan in the quiet town of Strawberry. She is drawn to the dangerous life of stealing to earn enough money to keep herself alive. One day, a tall stranger shows up at her door, introducing himself as Dutch Van der Linde... Her long lost father. She is raised side by side with Arthur Morgan though the two never consider each other siblings but rather enemies, divided by Dutch's favoritism for his un-biological son. As they grow older, Hosea advises Charlotte that it's time to put the rivalry to bed and asks her to look at Arthur from a new angle. She begins having strange dreams about him, spurred by a traumatic event in her life. When she gets stuck with him after fleeing Valentine, they get into a heated fight that twists into something neither of them thought would ever happen... #1 in Dutch Van Der Linde #6 in Wild West #1 in Western Warning: contains heavy depictions of violence, alcohol and drug use, smut and foul language Listen while you read! Look for "Dutch's Daughter" on Spotify by Mmb307! All characters belong to Rockstar's Red Dead Redemption 2 aside from Charlotte Van Der Linde, an original character of mine. This story contains major spoilers so read at your own risk! None of the images used belong to me. Credit goes to original creators.
Arthur Morgan x Reader by imagineyourcreator
58 parts Complete
[Completed] The beginning of the story takes place when they settled in Colter. When everyone was together before they moved to horseshoe overlook. Traveling the wild west can be a hell of a journey! It even gets crazier when you meet a man named Arthur Morgan, your life is going great but as you get into more and more trouble. Things go south really fast. This is my third fan fiction and I played this game like no tomorrow. I absolutely fell in love with Arthur and his big heart. I told myself I had to do a story on this game. Hope you enjoy. I do not own any of these characters. Thank y'all so much for nine thousand reads! 😭 #5 RDR2 #11 Arthur Morgan #52 RDR2 #15 John Marston #1 Arthur Morgan
~The Hunt~ Javier Escuella AU βœ”οΈŽ by Chantelle_Collins
32 parts Complete Mature
"We do more than hunting... We're hunted" "If we have to fight, we fight. If we have to run, we'll run If we must die, we'll die, But... We'll stay free" "You don't hire a Saint to catch a Sinner," "You either die a hero...or you live long enough to see yourself become a villain," Love is strong, it's powerful and keeps everything together. Or so she thought. She knew love was a fools game, no time for it while they were being hunted down from out west. Could her opinion change? Or will it stay the same. SPOILERS TO THE GAME I DO NOT OWN ANY CHARACTERS APART FROM A FEW. ALL RIGHTS GO TO R* CREDITS TO THE OWNER OF THE PHOTO OF JAVIER BASED ON GAME RDR2 BEST RANK #95 IN SPANISH #64 IN ARTHUR MORGAN #22 IN OUTLAW #21 IN WESTERN #18 IN MICAH BELL #12 IN 1899 # 3 IN VAN DER LINDE #1 IN JAVIER ESCUELLA #1 IN RDR2 Started-1/6/20 Finished-9/9/21 ~ "This book is so good, I feel like I could read it all the time. If I could, I might just go back and re read it again." @Mrs_escuella17 "Finally! I was looking forward for this chapter! Epic as always!" @BlackRose126 *** Comments are monitored, so please go ahead and comment what you think don't be a silent reader. Enjoy reading
The Rebellious Rescuer COMPLETED!βœ” by RaysInDark
19 parts Complete Mature
COMPLETED!!βœ”οΈ This is an Arthur Morgan X reader story, with you as the main character. You work as a brothel lady in the town called Valentine, and you stumble upon a notorious man that got you to grow feelings for this unknown man. But something comes in between and you get kidnapped by the O'Driscolls, what happens afterward? Well, this is where we let the story tell us... OBS! Some important info; 1. My native language isn't English, misspellings appear. Pls, maintain respect, thanks in advance! 2. Contains mature content, you are forewarned in the chapter! 3. More information in the AN chapter. 4. I'm not the owner of the cover photo or any other pictures in this story!
Who, Cerberus: An RDR Undead Nightmare Story [ John Marston x OC ] by goodbyelisahoney
30 parts Complete Mature
It's 1911, and undead have swarmed West Elizabeth. John Marston fears his wife and son are the undead horde's latest victims. He heads to Blackwater for help, and meets a stalwart barmaid with a few tricks up her sleeve. Can they team up and break the curse? * Hi gang! This is an action-horror-western fic loosely based on the RDR: Undead Nightmare game - but knowing what we know, I can't resist throwing some RDR2 characters/settings in there, too. And knowing myself, there's probably going to be a li'l romance! Characters/settings belong to Rockstar Games. Editing to say: this is definitely a romance lol. This story was completed January 9, 2022. This story contains mature themes.
Sweetest Sin (Dutch Van Der Linde Fanfic) by noctlight106
30 parts Complete Mature
-* "Now that things have spiraled out of my control, I don't know if what I'm choosing is the correct path...but tsk, who am I trying to kid? I knew what I was signing up for, terrible choice made on my part or no, I can't help it with you and your ways. . .1899 is the year that would change my life for the rest of my days. . ." -To Dutch Van Der Linde, my outlaw ~ Join a young woman as she goes into the declining world of the Wild West and into the gang of outlaws called the Van Der Linde gang, it's leader Dutch Van Der Linde catches her eye and she chooses for herself if he is worth going to hell for and faces very dangerous situations but over all: an adventure, she will never forget and hopefully not regret if she survives --- I'm not expecting anyone to read this story & actually enjoy it. Anyways... disclaimer below: Red dead redemption 2 and it's characters belongs to rock* Original characters along with random moments mixed in with the events of the game are my bits
Vows of Returning: A Red Dead Redemption 2 Story ( Arthur Morgan xOC ) by goodbyelisahoney
28 parts Complete Mature
Arthur Morgan x OC: "Take a boozy short leave of your nymphs on the shore, and silence their mourning with vows of returning, though never intending to visit them more." After a near-deadly shootout in Valentine, Arthur Morgan retreats to a wooded cabin to lick his wounds and recover. But the reclusive woman he meets there causes him to question everything he believes in, and all of the people he holds dear. Does she have secrets of her own that she's hiding? ** Hi all; this is a little RDR2 romance (Arthur x original character) story. It follows the events of the game for the most part (meaning there are some spoilers, if you haven't finished the game yet!), but there are some changes/additions. Of course, all RDR2 characters/settings are Rockstar Games. Hope you all enjoy and would love to hear your thoughts. This story was completed September 18, 2021. A content warning: depictions of sex, violence, swearing, and other mature themes.
MY OUTLAW ↛ JOHN MARSTON by billyscigarette
31 parts Complete Mature
❝ 𝐼𝑑 π‘π‘œπ‘’π‘™π‘‘ π‘™π‘Žπ‘ π‘‘. βžπ‘€π‘Žπ‘–π‘ π‘–π‘’ π‘ β„Žπ‘Ÿπ‘’π‘”π‘”π‘’π‘‘, π‘™π‘’π‘Žπ‘›π‘–π‘›π‘” π‘π‘Žπ‘π‘˜ 𝑖𝑛 π‘‘β„Žπ‘’ π‘β„Žπ‘Žπ‘–π‘Ÿ. ❝ 𝐼𝑑 π‘€π‘œπ‘›'𝑑. 𝐼 𝑗𝑒𝑠𝑑 β„Žπ‘œπ‘π‘’ β„Žπ‘’ π‘π‘Ÿπ‘’π‘Žπ‘˜π‘  𝑖𝑑 π‘œπ‘“π‘“ π‘π‘’π‘“π‘œπ‘Ÿπ‘’ 𝐼 β„Žπ‘Žπ‘£π‘’ π‘‘π‘œ. ❞ ❝ 𝐻𝑒 π‘€π‘œπ‘›'𝑑. ❞ *‒𓆙‒* A 24 year old named Amara Findlay was born into a wealthy family along with her sister, Maisie Findlay. Her life seemed so perfect to everyone else but in reality her parents, Sandy and Micheal Findlay were toxic people, wanting their children to do things for their business whether the two sisters like it or not. Amara's mother pushes her to find a suitor, as being the eldest in the family that is her duty to find a wealthy man to settle down with. But, Amara refuses to settle down with anyone for everyone that has interest in her isn't good enough. In 1899, on a sunny afternoon, Amara goes to Valentine with her sister, Maisie. They meet a man there named John Marston. Maisie introduces herself and Amara to the man and become acquainted with him, Amara doesn't fully trust the man, despite her slight attraction to him. John is immediately attracted to Amara and tries to become closer with her, but Amara still keeps up her guard. Will Amara Findlay learn to trust John? And if so, what will happen? Started: September 6, 2020 Finished: June 20, 2021 COMPLETED [THE STORY IS THE ONLY THING THAT BELONGS TO ME I DONT OWN RDR2 OR ANYTHING ASSOCIATED WITH IT! SOME EVENTS IN THE GAME WILL BE CHANGED TO GO ALONG WITH THE STORY LINE]
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
NOTHING GOLD CAN STAY: RDR2 cover
π“πŽπ”π†π‡ π†πˆπ‘π‹ | π’π€πƒπˆπ„ 𝐀𝐃𝐋𝐄𝐑 𝐗 πŽπ‚ cover
Dutch's Daughter [[RDR2 Arthur Morgan x OC]] cover
Arthur Morgan x Reader cover
~The Hunt~ Javier Escuella AU βœ”οΈŽ cover
The Rebellious Rescuer COMPLETED!βœ” cover
Who, Cerberus: An RDR Undead Nightmare Story [ John Marston x OC ] cover
Sweetest Sin (Dutch Van Der Linde Fanfic) cover
Vows of Returning: A Red Dead Redemption 2 Story ( Arthur Morgan xOC ) cover
MY OUTLAW ↛ JOHN MARSTON cover

NOTHING GOLD CAN STAY: RDR2

53 parts Complete Mature

Nora has spent most of her life in solitude, travelling only with her business partner JB Cripps. Always on the move, never allowing herself the time to face the past that threatens to consume her. That is until she meets a particularly irritating outlaw at a bounty board and her life suddenly bursts into tremendous colour. But when the pendulum swings one way, eventually it'll swing the other. COMPLETE This is a work of fanfiction, with characters from Rockstar's Red Dead Redemption 2 and Red Dead Redemption 2 Online. I do not own this world, nor any character beyond the main OC. Neither do I own any of the literature and titles taken from the works of Robert Frost. (While this story follows along with the timeline and the main plot of the game, there will be divergences in the canon. Mainly that Arthur will not contract TB. As for who else lives and dies, I'm afraid you'll have to find out.)

More details