Cinderella (and Not So Prince Charming)

Joey was the second most popular sophomore at North High School. The most popular was his best friend, Flynn Peters.

While they looked like opposites, Flynn long and pale, Joey muscled and tan, the two boys were almost the same person. While Flynn's blonde quiff attracted all the girls, Joey had his eyes on no one.
He found a flaw in each girl, too fancy, too pale, too fake, too clingy. This made him even more desirable, which got him a false reputation. Womanizer, Player, and everything he wasn't.  His persona didn't stop Flynn from being those things exactly, but they remained as friends.

Suddenly, the teacher funds amusement in convincing Flynn he's The Frog Prince and everyone will love him while he's pretty. Now, Joey's childish side plays along and the boys find themselves trying out for the musical. No one knows how they got here, but damn Joey's voice... Every girl runs to try out for the lead, except the unpopular girls who hide away. That or Joey just simply doesn't notice them.

Then Joey meets a hidden girl, his "One True Love" in the place he least expects and expects her to take him willingly. Instead she hides from him, ignores him, and turns him down. For once in his life, Joey has to put effort into someone...

Will he win his "Cinderella"? Or will he be stuck as "The Frog Prince"?