I'm Your Papi
  • Reads 11,902
  • Votes 205
  • Parts 23
  • Time 4h 9m
  • Reads 11,902
  • Votes 205
  • Parts 23
  • Time 4h 9m
Complete, First published Aug 03, 2022
Mature
Jared falls for the one and only Tay Conti as he learns that she's recently single so he goes after her to try and win her over 

What will Jared do to gain Tay's love and affection as he balances work from his personal love life with the hottest women in AEW now 

All characters are 18+

(Mature content)
All Rights Reserved
Sign up to add I'm Your Papi to your library and receive updates
or
Content Guidelines
You may also like
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
I Loved Her First cover
WWE Divas Fanfiction cover
A hybrid wolf rejected. (Edited) cover
Mami's Wolf  cover
We Are Your Mami cover
Austin & Kat Gunn cover
Alpha Omega  cover
High Hopes (Alexa Bliss x Male Reader) (Complete) cover
Night Wolf  cover
Golden Gunner  cover

I Loved Her First

15 parts Complete Mature

Adam Cole cashes in a favor with an old friend and brings Jay White to AEW. But he never imagined that Jay would bring so many problems along with him. Adam's been in love with Samantha Jackson for as long as he can remember, but fear of losing both her and her brothers has kept his mouth shut. But now Sam is under Jay's spell, and Adam is losing her every second that he keeps his feelings to himself. Does he keep his mouth shut like he always has and watch the girl of his dreams be swept away by Jay? Or does he take a chance and fight for the woman that he loved first?