But You Like Her Better

(Originally published by iovestories on ao3)

Disclaimer: the events of this story happened on the 80s-90s so be aware that there will be a lot of homophobia, even from characters who are not straight (like Penelope). I didn't changed anyone's sexuality but, since most of them were raised by homophobic parents and taught to be against homosexually, no one is opened about their own sexuality.