Creepypasta Reaction
Most Impressive Ranking
#
74
janethekiller
out of 325 stories
Other Rankings
#
55
proxy
out of 174 stories
#
58
laughingjack
out of 154 stories
#
65
ray
out of 163 stories
#
189
bendrowned
out of 387 stories
#
80
liu
out of 156 stories
#
82
bloodypainter
out of 154 stories
#
116
toby
out of 207 stories
#
58
homicidalliu
out of 103 stories
#
53
nurseann
out of 85 stories
#
481
slenderman
out of 762 stories
#
83
redangel
out of 115 stories
#
77
jasonthetoymaker
out of 95 stories
#
326
hoodie
out of 391 stories
#
280
ticcitoby
out of 333 stories
#
99
ninathekiller
out of 112 stories
#
434
masky
out of 479 stories
#
264
eyelessjack
out of 284 stories
#
687
jeffthekiller
out of 735 stories
#
331
sally
out of 354 stories