I'm Not Your Second Choice

I'm Not Your Second Choice

Reads 125
Votes 5
Parts 1

Ongoing<5 mins

Last published Sun, Apr 6, 2025

Fanfic

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

Tagsangst casey caseyjones fluff ongoing

Raph had feelings for Casey. Those feelings weren't shared. Until April rejected Casey, that is.

All Rights Reserved

Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.

You may also like

Teddy
Raph x FemReader: Raphael saves an ER nurse from a mugging after an argument with Leo. His night isn't going the way he expected and honestly...wouldn't change it for nothin'.
Complete
TMNT In Love(Completed)
What would happen if the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles weren't the only ones?, What if there were females out there just like them, and what happens when they finally find each other? Will Raphael, Leonardo, Donatello, and Michelangelo finally find who they were meant to be with?, Or will Raphael keep his forbidden love for April and not let anyone else in. Read TMNT In Love to find out. This book will contain strong language, read at your own discretion. Dear reader, I want to thank you ahead of time for reading this book considering the fact that I know just how weird this actually sounds. I just hope that you will be supportive of me as I challenge my mind to write something a little more none realistic than my other books. Thanks again and I love you all.
Complete
Firey Love
COMPLETED Raphael x Reader fan fiction
Complete
tmnt one shot
it random story of tmnt. always comment ideas it can always be anything. on of them falling in love. family fight/issues. friend problems, dating, anything you can think of. message me or comment.
Complete
Imaginary Friend
Mikey knew Leo was different. He went by day by day, unseen and unheard. But Mikey loved him anyway. Imaginary friend Leo AU. Fluff and angst in equal measures.
Complete
My Hero
Im April O'Neils sister. April didnt tell her turtle friends about me and that i was related to her, till the day i went with her to see Baxter stockman, but a certain call made one turtle start to have feelings for me. a chance encounter after convincing my sister to let her come with causing me to meet four huge turtles, without noticing because i've never been in love before, that i'd fall for the turtle genius not knowing he developed a crush on me as well (also no this is not an x reader, this is based off my oc)
Complete
The Bravery in his Eyes - A TMNT Leo X Reader Story
Donnie turned around and started for his lab, putting his hands up in surrender. Raph averted his eyes and went over to the training dummy. It was Mikey who screamed, "Dude, is that a hickey?" Y/N's face reddened, and I turned to her slowly. "You have - I gave you-?" She looked away from me as she moved the collar of her shirt slightly to the side, revealing a pretty sizable bruise on her neck. "There's another one on my shoulder," she whispered. Mikey looked away, horrified. Captain Ryan would definitely not be proud. * * * Welcome to my first book, a Leo X Reader story! Let's put you in the TMNT 2012 universe, where you are staying with your grandparents in their New York City apartment and not much is going on. Well, until there are robots on the roof and you spot something strange, like a team of four ninja turtles fighting back? Enjoy the fluff, excitement, and adventure of being Leo's friend and possibly something more! He's a total sweetheart, so there will be tons of cuteness (and a little PG-13 humor!) Leave me lots of comments! I'd love to read what you guys think! *I don't own TMNT or any of its characters, but they're awesome nonetheless! Top ranks so far: #1 in leo #1 in raphael #1 in tmnt #1 in ninjaturtles #1 in tmnt2012 #1 in leoxreader #1 in michelangelo #1 in leonardoxreader #2 in swoon #2 in raph #2 in donnie #6 in teenagemutantninjaturtles #6 in leonardo #9 in donatello Thank you so much for your support!
Complete

Raph x FemReader: Raphael saves an ER nurse from a mugging after an argument with Leo. His night isn't going the way he expected and honestly...wouldn't change it for nothin'.

Content Guidelines