What Comes First:Sequel to Sally's Old Friend - writingdreamer15 - Wattpad

What Comes First:Sequel to Sally's Old Friend

writingdreamer15

Reads 281
Votes 0
Parts 11
Time 46m

Reads 281
Votes 0
Parts 11
Time 46m

writingdreamer15

creepypasta hoodie jeffthekiller korbyn korbynjumpingeagle masky sally slenderman smiley texttospeech theseer tickitoby

It's been a year since the girls became friends again. Sally wants Cassandra to move in with the rest of the creepypastas. As life is going good,a new enemy appears to cause havoc on the pastas. The worst part is,another person of Cassandra's and Sally's past is working with the fiend! Can Cassandra stop them all from fighting or will she pick a side? However the real question is......... Who is worth saving in the end? 
Join Sally,Cassandra and the other creepypasta's in What Comes First:Sequel to Sally's Old Friend.Creative Commons (CC) Attribution

creepypasta hoodie jeffthekiller korbyn korbynjumpingeagle masky sally slenderman smiley texttospeech theseer tickitoby

Table of contents

11 parts

Sign up to add What Comes First:Sequel to Sally's Old Friend to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

The New Girls in the Mansion by Asgardian_Kitty

You've all heard the stories of Creepypasta right? Slenderman, Herobrine, Jeff the Killer, and more? Well, there are two new girls on the block. Sister's Heather and Skylor lived with their abusive father and no mother, as she 'left' a year after Heather was born. Once realizing that Heather and Skylor have powers, their father sent them away to a facility that deals with these type of humans. However, both soon realize that the facility is not as kind as it first seemed and deem the place unlivable. Once escaping the facility, they run into a certain tall man that gives them a place to call home. If you can call a house full of murderers and stalkers a home.

A Demon Love Triangle{A creepypasta fanfic} || Rewrite in Progress || by skullgirl99

Ella is in love with creepy pasta, so is her best friend Sabrina. They are the only ones who actually believe there real so there always there for each other, but then something happens to Ella, causing her world to go upside down. The next day see figures out that Sabrina is missing and wont stop until she finds her. But, she gets caught up in her own drama. 4 demons are in love with her and she cant decide. She loves them all equally. So now she has to stop the fighting and has to find Sabrina, what will Ella do?

Second Family [Creepypasta x Reader] by GhostyGirl666

A Creepypasta x Reader: After the murder of your (first) family you decide you have no where to go. You were a nobody who had to make quick decisions to get out of situations, which led you to meet a group of... colourful characters. You being the creative and quirky person you are decide to stick around and meet them all, family number two. ---------------------------------------------------- Hey! Credit goes to the artists! Hey! Hope you enjoy this, leave your opinions and suggestions! As you know Creepypastas are popular- sidenote. I KNOW Masky and Hoodie are from Marble Hornets... but, proxies man. Proxies. Also, we all know that Creepypasta's mean that there will be some gore, but I will put a gore warning before I speak of it. *light swearing* Thank Chu~ GhostyGirl666

A Dark Mind (sequel to A Sally Creepypasta Story) by BoneyardHorizons

(Sequel to A Sally Creepypasta Story) After Jeff's death everyone is still hating Sally, but she soon gains their trust and love back, from some. One day when she's out killing she finds a new family member? Who is the family member? And will Sally finally kill uncle Johnny? Read to find out! (Cover picture does not belong to me)

Sally the Pasta by Creepypasta_girl15

Sally was just a normal eight year old girl until one day her world came crashing down. Her uncle raped and killed her hoping to never let his crime be uncovered. He thought everything was just fine after what happened. Let's just say he shouldn't have done that because the one person he least expects is back; Sally. She is now ready for the game to continue when she comes back to life as an immortal. She meets the Pastas along the way and they help her out. Now Johnny has the pay as Sally claims her revenge. >:D Goodbye Johnny, hello Sally. He has meet with a terrible fate.

Trapped (A Ticci Toby Story) by Geofox

***This story is told completely through Toby's POV*** My life has stopped... I was supposed to keep training. I was supposed to keep developing the skills that it took to be the slenderman's proxy. I was supposed to be there for Sally when she couldn't sleep. I was supposed to be between Jeff and Ben while they tried to show me a movie I could never sit still long enough for. I was supposed to be standing in front of Masky while he yelled at me about my carelessness. I was supposed to be there to receive Hoodie's reassuring smile. I was supposed to be with them... but I'm not. Something horrible happened to me...

Your Insanity by ratkys

[Jeff The Killer x My main oc] (MAGOR TRIGGER/ADULT WARNING⚠️⚠️: I REALLY recommend 16+ [more 18+] due to the fact there is a lot of cursing and just a lot of triggering factors all together [r*pe, s*icide, ext] Please read at your own risk and Ill put a disclaimer for any 18+ scenes) This is a fanfic but also has some story for my main oc if their next life was as a creepypasta I guess? Please enjoy as I just decided to rewrite it to add more oomph!

I'm Just A Freak (Abandoned) by clear-quartz

||WARNING! THIS BOOK HAS BEEN ABANDONED!|| (Y/N) had always been a seemingly normal guy. Never really causing trouble, had great friends and a loving sister, but he had struggles that little to no one knew about. One day, though, that all changed with a few simple actions done by another. A/N I do not own any of the Creepypastas, art, or videos (unless said otherwise) in this story (sadly). All credit goes to the original creators.

Dollhouse ( A Creepypasta Fanfiction) by AllisonOMara

highest rank - #1!! in creepypasta, #40 in fanfiction Brooklynn may only be 6, but she already hates her life. Her father is cheating on her mother. Her mom knows he is cheating, but just drinks away the pain of a broken heart. Her brother does drugs in his room all day. Nobody wants Brooklynn. The only friends she has are her dollies. They listen to her. They help her through this very tough time. But, they can only do so much. Brooklynn had imaginary friends. The only issue with this is... They weren't imaginary.

Broken(Masky x Reader x Hoodie) by Mr_CookiesAndMilk

"Y/N. Just say one word. Hoodie or me?" "I-I don't-..." I paused. The words wouldn't come out right. My eyes darted from Hoodie to Masky ¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿? Y/N was a young girl who lived a normal life. She had everything she needed and was prepared to graduate from university and find a job, then finally start her life. But.. That would never happen She was home alone one night. Two men broke in and took her far away from her home. They took her into a world of darkness and evil. Creepypåsta's realm. A place where no human could enter without being with another creepy pasta. She was trapped there until she accepted her role as a new creepypasta member and the new proxy of Slenderman. But there are some strange things Y/N has been seeing. There are predators after her. Monsters. Things taken over with insanity and darkness. They want to devour her heart. Masky and Hoodie had been assigned to protect her at all costs. And guess what happens between the three of them? A huge love triangle that seems to be impossible to fix. "T H E Y A R E A L W A Y S W I T H U S" Mature content in this story. Part of the Dead Creepypasta series. Each book can be read alone All photos belong to someone else nothing belongs to me except for the writing Enjoy the story FIRST BOOK :)) Cough cough this will be written as a female reader

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

The New Girls in the Mansion cover

A Demon Love Triangle{A creepypasta fanfic} || Rewrite in Progress || cover

Second Family [Creepypasta x Reader] cover

A Dark Mind (sequel to A Sally Creepypasta Story) cover

Sally the Pasta cover

Trapped (A Ticci Toby Story) cover

Your Insanity cover

I'm Just A Freak (Abandoned) cover

Dollhouse ( A Creepypasta Fanfiction) cover

Broken(Masky x Reader x Hoodie) cover

The New Girls in the Mansion

You've all heard the stories of Creepypasta right? Slenderman, Herobrine, Jeff the Killer, and more? Well, there are two new girls on the block. Sister's Heather and Skylor lived with their abusive father and no mother, as she 'left' a year after Heather was born. Once realizing that Heather and Skylor have powers, their father sent them away to a facility that deals with these type of humans. However, both soon realize that the facility is not as kind as it first seemed and deem the place unlivable. Once escaping the facility, they run into a certain tall man that gives them a place to call home. If you can call a house full of murderers and stalkers a home.