What Should've Happened
- Reads 122
- Votes 2
- Parts 4
Ongoing34m
Last published Sun, Apr 2, 2023
I revamped my previous story, was just easier to make a new one.
Y/N tried everything they could to keep Sebastian from making a horrible mistake. It's just up to them to see how it unfolds from there. If Sebastian still loses his mind or finally finds solace in moving forward with his life like his sister would have wanted him to. Friends find solace in each other seeing what dark magic can do to someone.
Debating on making it a slowburn over a couple years, then maybe offer the alternative ending if people want it enough.
*I do not own the characters or any affiliation. Writing for fun/practice*
All Rights Reserved
#479
hogwartslegacy
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
![A Ballad of Snakes and Shadows [Dark Sebastian Sallow x MC]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/354446960-256-k910279.jpg)
A Ballad of Snakes and Shadows [Dark Sebastian Sallow x MC]
[{COMPLETED}] **PLEASE SEE LIST OF WARNINGS AND TRIGGERS BEFORE READING** It's been three years since Ominis and I made the choice for Sebastian - to send him away. The consequences of our actions have the shadows talking back. Their voices are lovely, alluring, and most of all sinful. With their wicked tongues, they offer a temptation I may not be able to refuse. I can't help but wonder if we made the wrong choice. *** This is a dark enemies to enemy/lovers romance for Sebastian Sallow, and my OC Hyacinth "Hattie" Hills that takes place during her last year at Hogwarts. She is still in the throws of recovering from her first year, heavily stricken with the grief and trauma it caused her. Now that she's begun to heal, there's a shadow stalking the grounds that threatens to undo all of that progress. All participating characters are 18+, as this is set a bit in the future and with an added year at Hogwarts. This work contains many dark themes and triggers. There is some Ominis/OC but this is not for the Ominis girlies, unless you want to see him hurt. This fic is dark... and inspired by an idea of Sebastian being something heinous... TW: Stalking, Obsession, CNC, Death, Trauma, Knife Play, Blood Play, Edging, Cuckhold, Orgasm Denial, Mirror Play, Spit Play, Heavy S&M, Face Fucking, Verbal Humiliation, Primal Play, Breeding Kink, Degradation, Sebastian is Cruel, We are going to traumatize Ominis Gaunt, ect....and will add others down the road, it's a lot to tag. You can find a full list of tags/warnings on the Ao3 copy of this fic and I will be adding warnings to every chapter that involve heavier themes. Each chapter title is based off of songs that inspired them, creating its own ballad - there is a link in the intro/warning chapter. (Cross Posted to Ao3) (Hogwarts Legacy does not belong to me, only the OCs and plot.)Complete
No Choice But You // Ominis Gaunt x Reader
HOGWARTS LEGACY SPOILERS AHEAD!! Ominis x Reader fanfiction is based in their seventh year. All characters have been aged up to 18 years of age where explicit content is involved. Written from the perspective of fem Slytherin y/n. ---------- Sebastian has been sent to Azkaban. Of course, Ominis blames you--it's only natural after everything that happened in your fifth year. For the entirety of your sixth year, Sebastian was at Azkaban. While Ominis understood that it was a necessary action to take considering what Sebastian did, he didn't forget that you encouraged it, or that you partook in the dark arts yourself. It was against everything he stood for. He warned you every step of the way, and neither you nor Sebastian listened to his warnings. By a stroke of luck, the ministry has decided to give Sebastian a second chance. He gets to come back to Hogwarts for his seventh year of schooling. Ominis is still Sebastian's friend, but he wants to keep you away from him at all costs. He hates you for what you did to his best friend. On a happy note, St. Mungos finally found a cure for Anne Sallow's curse, and she's back at Hogwarts for her seventh year as well. Your friendship with her blossoms, and makes it even harder for Ominis to stay away from you. Even though he hates you, he can't deny the attraction between the two of you. Everything changed one night at a party in the Slytherin common room when you two come in close contact. But can he fight his feelings and stay away from you? ---------- TRIGGER WARNINGS: Sexual Content: 5/10 Mental Illnesses: 7/10 Violence: 3/10 Self Harm: 6/10Complete
Dark Sacrifices
Sebastian Sallow would do anything to save his sister. Even lie to, manipulate, and abandon his friends. Nearly a year and a half after the events of Hogwarts Legacy, Sebastian returns to Elia and asks her to use her ancient magic to help Anne, 'one more time'. But when it comes to Sebastian Sallow, is there ever an end to the number of favors he requests? After all, he likes having friends in his debt *Recently re-written and re-uploaded ** Cross-posted on AO3
what if? // sebastian sallow
When Sebastian Sallow ghosted Jasmine Malfoy at the end of their fifth year at Hogwarts, she was left confused and heartbroken. Years later, she finds herself still unable to move on, haunted by nightmares of the traumatic events they experienced together, and a desperate longing for his presence. When Jasmine suddenly receives an owl from Sebastian, she is caught off guard. Will she be able to reconnect with Sebastian and finally discover their unrealized potential together from their earlier years at Hogwarts? SPOILER WARNING: Will contain major spoilers from the Hogwarts Legacy game. This will be a slow-burn, deeply emotional story that seeks to fill in the gaps that Hogwarts Legacy left in Sebastian's relationship with MC. I will take some liberties with the characters, plot points, etc to fit in with my plan for the story. I really hope you guys enjoy it, and please leave feedback! :) Thank you soo much to those of you on Tiktok that said they'd be interested if I posted a fanfic!!
Unbroken Bonds | Sebastian Sallow x Reader
"You think shutting me out will fix everything?" My voice trembled, frustration and hurt bubbling to the surface. "That disappearing, keeping secrets, pushing everyone away, that it'll somehow make this right?" Sebastian's jaw clenched, his gaze fierce. "I'm doing what I have to do. You wouldn't understand." I took a step closer, refusing to let him slip away this time. "Then try me," I shot back. "Don't just stand there and say I wouldn't understand when you won't even give me the chance." For a moment, neither of us moved, the charged air between us feeling thick enough to choke on. His dark, angry eyes bore into mine, flickering with something I couldn't quite place. It was as if he was silently pleading, trying to find an answer in me, searching for a lifeline he couldn't put into words. I felt my breath hitch as his shoulders dropped ever so slightly, the fight in him faltering. Then, as though some unseen barrier had shattered, he closed the distance between us in a single, unguarded moment. His hands gripped my arms, steadying me as his lips met mine in a collision of emotion that left no room for hesitation. --- As their final year at Hogwarts begins, Y/N is determined to leave the past behind--until Sebastian Sallow returns, bringing with him the weight of a cursed artefact and a desperate mission to save his sister, Anne. Bound by loyalty and a shared history, Y/N and Sebastian must navigate a treacherous web of dark magic, strained friendships, and their own haunted hearts, confronting not only the secrets of the artefact but also the unyielding bond that ties their fates together. --- Disclaimer: The characters, settings, and world featured in this story are based on the game Hogwarts Legacy. All rights to the original material belong to their respective creators. This is a work of fanfiction created purely for entertainment and not for profit.
The Facade of Us | Sebastian Sallow x Reader
"We can't keep tipping the scale of friendship, Sebastian." I say, my voice trembling as I meet his gaze. His expression falters, vulnerability flickering across his face. "Then tell me, Y/N-what do we call this?" ────⋆⋅☆⋅⋆── Returning to Hogwarts for your seventh year, you're still celebrated for your heroic deeds during fifth year. But fame comes with its challenges, and nothing complicates life more than unspoken emotions. Over the summer, you, Ominis, and Sebastian made a solemn pact: no matter what, nothing would break your trio apart. One condition, however, left you uneasy-Ominis forbade any romance between you and Sebastian, convinced it would only bring chaos. You agreed, believing your feelings for Sebastian were purely platonic. But as the new school year begins, the line between friendship and something deeper began to blur. Leander Prewett, persistent as ever, refuses to take no for an answer when it comes to his infatuation with you that started in your fifth year. Desperate for a solution, you turn to Sebastian for help, thinking it might finally end Leander's advances. Little did you know, this small request would set the stage for a far more tangled web of emotions and forbidden feelings.Complete
Waking of Shadows
After the chaos of her fifth year at Hogwarts, Luna Lestrange thought the storm had finally passed. But ancient magic, bound to her very soul, has awakened something far darker than she ever imagined-a force that threatens the wizarding world. This time, she finds herself drawn into a perilous battle against the shadow she unwittingly unleashed. Alongside Sebastian Sallow-a wizard whose charm is as dangerous as his secrets-they must unravel the mystery of her power before it consumes everything. [...] "People are definitely going to get the wrong impression about this." I said, gesturing between us with my free hand. "Would that be so bad?" Sebastian shot back, grinning as he turned to glance over his shoulder at me, clearly enjoying my frustration. I raised my eyebrows, my expression dripping with "seriously?" "Relax," he said, his grin widening. "They've been speculating about us since fifth year. You're a bit late to start worrying now." [...] ─── ⋅ ⋅ ∘ ☽ ༓ ☾ ∘ ⋅ ⋅ ─── Hi! This is my first time writing, and English isn't my first language, so I apologize if there are any grammar mistakes! I'm trying my best Hope you have fun reading!
ONLY YOU || Sebastian Sallow
After navigating her Sixth Year at Hogwarts without her charming (and hot) best friend Sebastian Sallow, who was dragged away to Azkaban for murder, Hazel Hythe is shocked when he returns to school unannounced and unexpected at the beginning of their final year. Not only does his story not add up, her unspoken feelings for him are messier than ever... as she has a new boyfriend now. Why is Sebastian back and where has he really been? How much does their bestie Ominis Gaunt know, and where is Sebastian's twin sister Anne Sallow in all of this? More importantly... does Sebastian still see Hazel as just a friend - or something more? Caught between giving her new relationship a go while secretly pining for an old crush she can't seem to let go of, Hazel battles with complicated decisions of the heart, while trying to unravel the mystery that shrouds Sebastian's sudden return and bizarre behaviour. ONLY YOU is a Hogwarts Legacy fanfic romcom packed with humour and spice and a touch of drama. Follow Hazel and Sebastian as they embark on an epic journey of romance, friendship, rejection, sex, and self-discovery - all while trying to keep their grades (and sanity) in tact! MAGIC CAN'T REPAIR ONE'S EMOTIONS... OR CAN IT? Characters aged 18+ Mature audience (*smut warning*!) Contains sex, violence, strong language, and other mature themes HL spoilers within. Cover artist: DMESCA [DVNA on Pinterest]
In the Shadow of You | Hogwarts Legacy
After the turmoil faced in your fifth year, you want nothing more than a normal life. After spending a quiet summer in Hogsmeade, trying to outrun the shadows of the past, you return to Hogwarts excited (and slightly apprehensive) for your sixth year. But being back at Hogwarts has stirred up trouble... Not only are you still trying to live down your reputation as "Hogwarts' Savior," but rumors have begun circling about your...relationships? And to make matters worse, your sleep has been plagued by nightmares, your ancient magic gone dormant. Just when you suspect your desperate attempts at normalcy couldn't get any worse, you begin to have a war in your mind with an unknown enemy, seeking an object with the potential to cause irreversible damage. There's another ominous threat to the safety of Hogwarts, but you've had your fair share of heroism. The wizarding world is in the capable hands of a sixth year student. What could possibly go wrong? ⋆｡°✩ * FMC, Ravenclaw House (she/her pronouns used) * Self-insert! No name/descriptions given * Romance subplot with Sebastian Sallow (friends to lovers, mutual pining, slow burn, fluff, sfw!!!) * CONTAINS SPOILERS FOR HL: Story deviates from the events of the main quest after Ranrok's defeatComplete
The Death Wish: Book One (Hogwarts Legacy)
**MAJOR PLOT SPOILERS FOR HOGWARTS LEGACY*** POV: Second Person, Girl - Great for Role-Play Read Hogwarts was falling. Fig was dead. Lodgok was dead. Sebastian in Azkaban. You had lost. But what if you could do it again? What if you could start off differently-right from the beginning? What if you trusted your friends more? What if you found a family to love and protect you? What if you decided that just this once....everyone lives? What would you say to yourself...to save yourself? -- A very detailed re-write of entire main story line with severe canon divergence. This is gonna be a long, long one folks, so grab a snack ;) For lovers of all the happy endings. (Cross-Post from AO3 - Chapters get significantly longer as it progresses)Complete
[{COMPLETED}] **PLEASE SEE LIST OF WARNINGS AND TRIGGERS BEFORE READING** It's been three years since Ominis and I made the choice for Sebastian - to send him away. The consequences of our actions have the shadows talking back. Their voices are lovely, alluring, and most of all sinful. With their wicked tongues, they offer a temptation I may not be able to refuse. I can't help but wonder if we made the wrong choice. *** This is a dark enemies to enemy/lovers romance for Sebastian Sallow, and my OC Hyacinth "Hattie" Hills that takes place during her last year at Hogwarts. She is still in the throws of recovering from her first year, heavily stricken with the grief and trauma it caused her. Now that she's begun to heal, there's a shadow stalking the grounds that threatens to undo all of that progress. All participating characters are 18+, as this is set a bit in the future and with an added year at Hogwarts. This work contains many dark themes and triggers. There is some Ominis/OC but this is not for the Ominis girlies, unless you want to see him hurt. This fic is dark... and inspired by an idea of Sebastian being something heinous... TW: Stalking, Obsession, CNC, Death, Trauma, Knife Play, Blood Play, Edging, Cuckhold, Orgasm Denial, Mirror Play, Spit Play, Heavy S&M, Face Fucking, Verbal Humiliation, Primal Play, Breeding Kink, Degradation, Sebastian is Cruel, We are going to traumatize Ominis Gaunt, ect....and will add others down the road, it's a lot to tag. You can find a full list of tags/warnings on the Ao3 copy of this fic and I will be adding warnings to every chapter that involve heavier themes. Each chapter title is based off of songs that inspired them, creating its own ballad - there is a link in the intro/warning chapter. (Cross Posted to Ao3) (Hogwarts Legacy does not belong to me, only the OCs and plot.)
More detailsContent Guidelines