To Kill A Killer
- Reads 7,202
- Votes 321
- Parts 19
Ongoing3h 35m
Last published Sat, Nov 15, 2025
Nightmare's gang always knew that their job was risky, but they never expected to actually die.
Then Killer was killed.
Nightmare found a replacement quickly enough, but this new Killer isn't the same as the old one, and the gang are having a hard time adjusting.
Inspired by a comic by darkxsoulzyxcaliberx. Something New belongs to rahafwabas. Dusttale belongs to Ask-Dusttale. Dreamtale belongs to Joku. Horrortale belongs to Sour-Apple-Studios. Xtale and Underverse belong to Jakei. Underswap belongs to p0pcornPr1nce/the Undertale AU community. Ink!Sans belongs to Comyet. Any other characters and AUs mentioned belong to their original creators. All art by me. A huge thank you to my partner for beta-reading.
All Rights Reserved
#885
badsanses
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Feelings Are Overrated ~Killer X Nightmare~
In order to be seen as not soft Nightmare buries his feelings down deeper than his soul. What will happen when those feelings start to rise to the surface. Will there be kindness in his soul, or will his soul forever be a pile of goo. Killer and you will have to see!Complete
Inktober but it's written stuffs
It's a little thing of written stuff about Undertale and it's aus. Some for a day might be short and others might be longer. It'll have angst and fluff or just complete chaos. It'll also switch from human to skeleton, just a heads up there. Also the prompts are made up by me so..yeah. Anyway, hope y'all enjoy this!Complete
Fallen (ErrorInk)
I dunno wut im doing, sorry if its bad ;~; Some Background: Most alternate sanses are attending a highschool, call the school whatever you like. This takes place in an AU thats not really an AU, seeing as there are no undertale characters. There is a "Gang" in this school, it is comprised of Nightmare, Error, Cross, Killer, Horror, and Dust. Everyone is afraid of them, except for the Star Sanses. Eventually, one of the star sanses, Ink, is able to befriend one of the bad guys, Error. Error starts to develop feelings for the artist, but, when something bad happens to Ink, error wonders if he'll ever get a chance. {This is an extremely slow-burn! You have been warned.}Complete
Frenemies ~ an Error X Ink fanfic
After a battle in an AU has left error pretty badly wounded. ink unable to finish him off takes him back to his place healing him, and trying to redeem him. but soon they become friends but who nows? maybe more? art not mine characters do not belong to me error belong to crayon queen ink belongs to comyetComplete
dumb skeletons in a dumber highschool
this is prob cringe but I think im funny lol ships are in tags none of these characters belong to me this might be funny might be triggering, be warned characters belong to: -Cross belongs to Jakei95 (aka. JakaeiArtworks) -Error and Geno (and Fresh who isn't in this story LOL) belongs to Lover of Piggies(also known as Crayon Queen or CQ for short) -Dust belongs to an Ask-DustTale Blog (idk if this is correct or not) -Horror belongs to Sour-Apple-Studios -Killer belongs to Rahafwabas -Blue belongs to P0pc0rnPr1nce -Ink belongs to Mye Bi (Comyet) -Nightmare and Dream belong to Jokublog -Lust belongs to NSFWShamecave -Reaper belongs to Ren Shout out to my brother's fic https://www.wattpad.com/story/381274408-vergessentale, go check it out!Complete
Bad guy Sans's
Dust's fiance is Blueberry Cross's husband(/wife) is Dream Nightmares boyfriend is Killer Horrors boyfriend is Lust Errors husband(/wife) is Ink Samuel, Scrooge, and Dark are Nightmare and Killers kids Lurro, Tacky, Desire, and Luxath are Horror and Lusts kids Nightmare, killer, Lust, Horror and the kids all live in Nightmares mansion in Dreamtale. Dust and Cross used to live here until they moved in with their boyfriends. Error live here for less than a week befor he decided that he preferred to do his evil business alone. Now all the bad Sans's(including error) are retired and living the rest of their lives with the ones they love.... That doesn't mean that they're nice or good or non murderous. It just means they're not looking for trouble any more. It tends to come to them. But boardom is their worst enemy now. Nightmare likes to stay in his non corrupt form, it attracts too much attention for obvious reasons.Complete
Unwanted protection
Everyone knows the Star Sanses: they're the Guardians of the Multiverse, and protect it from Nightmare and his minions, who only want to spread chaos and destruction. They're kind, strong, brave, the good guys! How can you not love them? You can't. They deserve the world. They're perfect and selfless and precious, and must be protected at any (and I do mean ANY) cost. Not that they couldn't protect themselves, of course! It's just, the Multiverse doesn't give them the appreciation and respect they deserve, not really. But Nightmare, Error, Horror, Killer, Dust, Cross... they know how much Dream, Ink and Blue are worth. And they'll keep them safe. Forever. The credit of this story partially belongs to Stargazer_Aldroth, who created a prompt on AO3 and helped me flesh out the story before I started writing. If you're interested, you can check out the comment chain where we discuss ideas for this oneshot and eventual follow-up (for now this story is marked as complete, but I could write other chapters, who knows?) on AO3 from author Stargazer_Nebula "Undertale Writing prompts" (it's the chapter with this same title)Complete
Given An Unwanted Second Chance
(TW: unaliving thoughts and memories at the beginning. It gets better over time, don't worry! Trauma is difficult to overcome...) You didn't want a second chance. You didn't want to survive. You wanted the sweet release of death. But it seemed like the universe was far too cruel to allow you even that. It took away your memories, your free will to choose whether you live or die...hell, it took the one thing in life you owned! Your own name! And now it seemed like you had to live yet another cruel life, doing things you never wanted done to others. But...at least you could do things your way. Maybe this second chance wouldn't be so bad... (Reincarnated as Nightmare Sans, but unlike other stories, you have no clue what Undertale even is) (WE REACHED NUMBER 1 IN THE UNDERTALE TAG YOOOOOOOO) (9/13/25)Complete
In order to be seen as not soft Nightmare buries his feelings down deeper than his soul. What will happen when those feelings start to rise to the surface. Will there be kindness in his soul, or will his soul forever be a pile of goo. Killer and you will have to see!
More detailsContent Guidelines