In an alternate universe, 17 year old Elizabeth Afton struggles with her father's return from prison, after the murder of her childhood friend Charlie Emily, 9 years prior. Still struggling with grief and blaming her father for the death of Charlie, her little brother Evan, and three other children, Elizabeth will butt heads with not only WIlliam Afton, but also her mother, Clara, and brother Michael. Has William really changed or is it all just an act to get her to trust him before he strikes again?