what if? // sebastian sallow - sadgirl9276 - Wattpad

Story cover for what if? // sebastian sallow by sadgirl9276

what if? // sebastian sallow

Reads 36,779
Votes 1,313
Parts 28
Time 2h 52m

Reads 36,779
Votes 1,313
Parts 28
Time 2h 52m

enemiestolovers fanfiction harrypotter hogwarts hogwartslegacy hogwartsromance ominisgaunt originalcharacter romance romancefanfiction sebastian sebastiansallow sebastiantok slowburn slytherin

When Sebastian Sallow ghosted Jasmine Malfoy at the end of their fifth year at Hogwarts, she was left confused and heartbroken. Years later, she finds herself still unable to move on, haunted by nightmares of the traumatic events they experienced together, and a desperate longing for his presence. 

When Jasmine suddenly receives an owl from Sebastian, she is caught off guard. Will she be able to reconnect with Sebastian and finally discover their unrealized potential together from their earlier years at Hogwarts?

SPOILER WARNING: Will contain major spoilers from the Hogwarts Legacy game. 

This will be a slow-burn, deeply emotional story that seeks to fill in the gaps that Hogwarts Legacy left in Sebastian's relationship with MC. I will take some liberties with the characters, plot points, etc to fit in with my plan for the story. I really hope you guys enjoy it, and please leave feedback! :) Thank you soo much to those of you on Tiktok that said they'd be interested if I posted a fanfic!!All Rights Reserved

enemiestolovers fanfiction harrypotter hogwarts hogwartslegacy hogwartsromance ominisgaunt originalcharacter romance romancefanfiction sebastian sebastiansallow sebastiantok slowburn slytherin

Table of contents

28 parts

Sign up to add what if? // sebastian sallow to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

A new threat by Elorcan95

A Hogwarts Legacy story. Focused on the relationship of reader x Sebastian. After all the traumatic events of your fifth year in Hogwarts, you hoped that this year would be normal. Focussing on your studies, hang out with friends and most importantly rekindle your friendship with Sebastian Sallow. Despite everything that happened, you still believe that the connection you once shared was strong enough to overcome anything. Unfortunately you discover soon enough that you're in way over your head again. A new enemy has arisen, friendships are tested to their limits and with your power seemingly growing you must rise to the challenge once again. The story will be written as a Sebastian X Reader fanfic using first person POV for both Y/N and Sebastian. !!Beware for spoilers of the game!!

For The Love Of A Snake by ElviraRyzmec

Heat.Passion.Lust.Danger. Four words she never thought she'd use to describe her first year at Hogwarts. Starting as a 6th year student wasn't ideal for Ruby. Just when she thought she'd be the loner of the school, Sallow walked into her life like the raging fireball he was. The heat between them was addicting and lustful. Something about this boy kept her hanging on for more. Even though the love was toxic she couldn't help herself. Would she continue this passionate fling? Or take a path she never thought she'd even consider? NFSW 18+ (in some areas) Some triggers such as abuse,violence, language, sex and graphic images. [This is a fully fleshed out story, not just one shots or dependent on time skips. This story is not like other Sebastian Sallow stories out there and there are plot twists around every corner] I don't own Hogwarts Legacy Characters. I do however own the characters I have created such as Ruby and other various implemented characters throughout the story.

for the hope of it all // Sebastian Sallow x reader by incendio22

''You seriously need to stop calling me your friend,'' Sebastian tells me in a low voice. ''Then what should I call you?'' I ask curiously. My stomach is fluttering like never before. ''I haven't quite figured it out just yet. But 'friend' is not it.'' He says as he squeezes my hand harder. ---- Sebastian Sallow x reader, a love story. When the summer between Y/n's 5th and 6th year at Hogwarts, she cannot stop thinking about Sebastian Sallow, despite the horrible things he did last year. She knows that what happened should have been the end of their relationship, but for some reason she does not consider it to be over. In fact, Y/n is unsure of her feelings towards him. Something about him just makes her feel like home. During their 6th year their relationship develops further, while facing new obstacles. One night Y/n discovers something that could mean the end of the wizarding world that requires help of Sebastian as well as Ominis. This is a story about love, friendship, betrayal and sacrifices. ---- Note: This takes place after the end of the game Hogwarts Legacy, but uses characters from the game. I do not own any of the characters. In this story Y/n was put in Slytherin and chose to become a keeper. This fanfiction also takes some inspiration from the Harry Potter-books, I do not own these characters either. Spoiler warning: Contains spoilers from the game Hogwarts Legacy as well as some potential spoilers from the Harry Potter-books. Book cover is made by ketto-art on tumblr, really recommend their services ♡

Allurement | Sebastian Sallow by ColetteNing

The year is 1892. Liya Chang, a Slytherin student in Hogwarts, possesses a rare ability to harness ancient magic. Yet, as the powerful force surges within her, she realises that this power is a double edged sword - she must quickly learn to control it, before it controls her. On the other side of the spectrum, Sebastian Sallow will do whatever it takes to find a cure for his sister, Anne, who was brutally cursed - even if that meant meddling in the dark arts. An unlikely friendship was forged between two fierce academic rivals. Liya and Sebastian, like two moths drawn to the flame, find themselves navigating a dangerous path together. Can they defeat the adversaries that lie in their way, or will they succumb to the magic they failed to control? Surely they should know that power corrupts... Power absolutely corrupts. Sebastian Sallow x Female Slytherin OC Third person POV | 7th Year | 18+ characters | Academic rivals to lovers [ This story loosely follows the plot of Sebastian's quest line and will contain spoilers to the Hogwarts Legacy game. All characters except for Liya Chang belong to Portkey games, Warner Bros. Games, Avalanche software and the wizarding world franchise. All rights belong to them. Some dialogue and scenes are taken directly out of the game, and some will include additions that I have made, again, all rights to the creators. ] The cover is commissioned by ME and is drawn by @/stpchn Highest Ranking: #1 in Fanficromance out of 1000+ stories #3 in Fandom out of 1000+ stories

In The Shadow of Our Choices by Harrow_7

After Elizabeth's fifth year at Hogwarts ends, she finds her return to normalcy isn't quite what she had hoped. Despite battling her own inner demons, Elizabeth finds herself once again embroiled in her friends' struggles. While Sebastian's relentless search for a cure leads the trio to delve into ancient secrets once more, Ominis also faces the return of family he abandoned. Amidst these other dramas, a formidable new threat emerges, casting a shadow over their lives - a consequence of Elizabeth's past choices. This story picks up where the main quest of Hogwarts Legacy ends. What happens next? Will they be able to overcome their challenges and find the answers they seek, or will they be led down another dangerous path? How does the MC deal with the actions taken in the game? And of course, what of romance? Book 1/Part 1 now completed! Covering their sixth year and the above blurb. Book 2/ Part 2 now also completed! Book 3 / Part 3 will be continuing in the same work

Sebastian Sallow x MC! OC: Songbirds Love by BR7566

Emmalee Calderon hasn't spoken to or seen her former boyfriend Sebastian Sallow in over a year. After everything that happened he left Hogwarts for a year and has returned for his seventh year. Emmalee has become a sort of celebrity around Slytherin House and the whole school for her voice. She frequently performs at parties that are hosted my Slytherin. At the start of school party for Slytherin she performs and her eyes meet Sebastian's. She knows those chocolate brown eyes anywhere. She doesn't react well when he approaches her during a break. Will Sebastian be able to redeem himself to her? Will she forgive him and eventually accept that he never stopped loving her? Book is currently on permanent hiatus due to personal reasons. If someone would like to continue this they are welcome to just please credit me

Order of Shadows | Sebastian Sallow Love Story by SallowsKeeper

Everything changed that night. Anne was cursed. Sebastian lost the warmth in his eyes when he looked at her. Ominis lost his soft smile. And Séraphine was struggling not to drown in guilt. How do you live with yourself when you're the reason Sebastian was going to lose his twin sister? Everyone was starting to lose hope until a mysterious new Witch with strange magic entered Hogwarts. Hope returned, but Séraphine was still drowning. Something was off about the new Witch. Then an accident happens and suddenly the Shadow Trio is sent over 100 years into the future. Follow Sebastian, Ominis, and Séraphine as they navigate the future while still trying to find a cure for Anne and understand their new roles in a Wizarding World on the brink of War. //Everyone is aged up due to mature content / spicy scenes

Waking of Shadows by lunasterin1

After the chaos of her fifth year at Hogwarts, Luna Lestrange thought the storm had finally passed. But ancient magic, bound to her very soul, has awakened something far darker than she ever imagined-a force that threatens the wizarding world. This time, she finds herself drawn into a perilous battle against the shadow she unwittingly unleashed. Alongside Sebastian Sallow-a wizard whose charm is as dangerous as his secrets-they must unravel the mystery of her power before it consumes everything. [...] "People are definitely going to get the wrong impression about this." I said, gesturing between us with my free hand. "Would that be so bad?" Sebastian shot back, grinning as he turned to glance over his shoulder at me, clearly enjoying my frustration. I raised my eyebrows, my expression dripping with "seriously?" "Relax," he said, his grin widening. "They've been speculating about us since fifth year. You're a bit late to start worrying now." [...] ─── ⋅ ⋅ ∘ ☽ ༓ ☾ ∘ ⋅ ⋅ ─── Hi! This is my first time writing, and English isn't my first language, so I apologize if there are any grammar mistakes! I'm trying my best Hope you have fun reading!

In the Shadow of You | Hogwarts Legacy by ravenclaair

After the turmoil faced in your fifth year, you want nothing more than a normal life. After spending a quiet summer in Hogsmeade, trying to outrun the shadows of the past, you return to Hogwarts excited (and slightly apprehensive) for your sixth year. But being back at Hogwarts has stirred up trouble... Not only are you still trying to live down your reputation as "Hogwarts' Savior," but rumors have begun circling about your...relationships? And to make matters worse, your sleep has been plagued by nightmares, your ancient magic gone dormant. Just when you suspect your desperate attempts at normalcy couldn't get any worse, you begin to have a war in your mind with an unknown enemy, seeking an object with the potential to cause irreversible damage. There's another ominous threat to the safety of Hogwarts, but you've had your fair share of heroism. The wizarding world is in the capable hands of a sixth year student. What could possibly go wrong? ⋆｡°✩ * FMC, Ravenclaw House (she/her pronouns used) * Self-insert! No name/descriptions given * Romance subplot with Sebastian Sallow (friends to lovers, mutual pining, slow burn, fluff, sfw!!!) * CONTAINS SPOILERS FOR HL: Story deviates from the events of the main quest after Ranrok's defeat

Sebastian Sallow: Duel of Hearts by sweetnass

A mysterious new transfer student from Durmstrang Institute, Hunter Woods, who enters Hogwarts in his 6th year. With his piercing blue eyes and jet-black hair, Hunter captures the attention of everyone in the Great Hall, including Ella Jones, but Sebastian Sallow senses something is off. As Ella and Sebastian's feelings towards each other grow, Hunter's true intentions begin to unfold, and it becomes clear that he is not just any ordinary transfer student. Will Ella and Sebastian be able to uncover the truth before it's too late? __ Please note: I do not own any of the characters from the Hogwarts Legacy game. This takes place after the end of the game Hogwarts Legacy, but uses characters from the game. Spoiler warning: Contains spoilers from the game Hogwarts Legacy.

Side Effects |a Sebastian Sallow story| by slytherinlives

Kathryn Knight returns to Hogwarts for Seventh Year after struggling to put herself back together after the events of Fifth Year. Kathryn spent her Sixth Year focusing on her studies and making accomplishments for herself such as being awarded house prefect and making the Hufflepuff Quidditch team as their Seeker, but even new titles and achievements can't fill the empty space that was left in the wake of Sebastian Sallow disappearing without a word. Sebastian Sallow left Hogwarts after the end of Fifth Year and no one has heard from him or knew of his whereabouts. But now, he too has returned for his Seventh Year. Will Kathryn be able to move on with her life and accept that Sebastian no longer seems to need her? Or will she dive into the deep end and entertain his antics once again? *All Characters except Kathryn are owned by Warner Bros. and WBGames. These characters are simply used for entertainment purposes.* *This story will contain some explicit mature content, themes such as PTSD, Depression, Anxiety and Alcohol Use. Explicitly Mature chapter will be marked with a (*), Please use caution when reading.*

Into Sallow's mind // Sebastian Sallow by theangrypanda

Sneak peek into Sebastian Sallow's thoughts during the events of the game. I created this story to add more depth to his character, and a little bit of Ominis too. This story follows the timeline from Hogwarts Legacy, but from the perspective of Sebastian Sallow. I add the initials of the characters before every dialog, I find it makes it easier to imagine the voices and interactions. I didn't want to be repetitive so I skip most part of the actual quests from the game, which might make it feel a little awkward sometimes. I wrote the quest line in a way that I think makes more sense to the story. Some dialogs might be different depending on what you chose during your gameplay. ps: this is my first story ever and I'm really proud of it, so I hope you enjoy, any feedback would be very much appreciated. At the end of this one there are some references from the 6th year story that I'm writing called "Broken", I have published a few chapters already if you'd like to check it out. I do not own any of the IP from Hogwarts Legacy or anything related to it.

In the Shadows - Sebastian Sallow x reader (English) by Miss_Pegasus

Already in the fifth year, the tension between Sebastian Sallow and the new fifth year student was intense. But they didn't admit their feelings for each other. This FF takes place after the events of Hogwarts Legacy. Slow burn Due to less free time, a new chapter will appear only irregularly. This story covers themes such as sexual acts, assault, violence, bullying, PTSD and self-harm. Please excuse possible errors, english isn't my first language. Not historically accurate, otherwise the men in the story would faint at the sight of a female ankle :D

ONLY YOU || Sebastian Sallow by StarryEyesJewel

After navigating her Sixth Year at Hogwarts without her charming (and hot) best friend Sebastian Sallow, who was dragged away to Azkaban for murder, Hazel Hythe is shocked when he returns to school unannounced and unexpected at the beginning of their final year. Not only does his story not add up, her unspoken feelings for him are messier than ever... as she has a new boyfriend now. Why is Sebastian back and where has he really been? How much does their bestie Ominis Gaunt know, and where is Sebastian's twin sister Anne Sallow in all of this? More importantly... does Sebastian still see Hazel as just a friend - or something more? Caught between giving her new relationship a go while secretly pining for an old crush she can't seem to let go of, Hazel battles with complicated decisions of the heart, while trying to unravel the mystery that shrouds Sebastian's sudden return and bizarre behaviour. ONLY YOU is a Hogwarts Legacy fanfic romcom packed with humour and spice and a touch of drama. Follow Hazel and Sebastian as they embark on an epic journey of romance, friendship, rejection, sex, and self-discovery - all while trying to keep their grades (and sanity) in tact! MAGIC CAN'T REPAIR ONE'S EMOTIONS... OR CAN IT? Characters aged 18+ Mature audience (*smut warning*!) Contains sex, violence, strong language, and other mature themes HL spoilers within. Cover artist: DMESCA [DVNA on Pinterest]

Return of Sebastian Sallow | 10 Yr After Hogwarts by JuneyMont

Ten years after I began at Hogwarts, Sebastian Sallow is back. And he's Professor Sallow now. He disappeared after the fall of Ranrok and Rookwood, after I lost Professor Fig, and after Ominis and I couldn't keep him from losing himself. But I never forgot him. As students his darkness kept us apart, and as adults his quest to make amends took him around the world and off the radar while my career with the Ministry kept me close to home. With the unexpected opportunity to reconnect, a wildfire of emotions threatens to bring us close once more. And a mysterious, imminent threat from another land threatens to keep us apart...forever. A story about love, loss, and redemption. CH. 1 Snippet: "I can hear Sebastian's breath grow shallow as he grabs ahold of one of my wrists tightly and I notice a familiar shift that brings a strange glisten to his eye and dark shadow to his brow. I've know that look from before, long ago, in the catacombs and the undercroft. But here it has an intensity that I've never seen. He is voracious and wild --primal, even. Like an old familiar melody, I can almost hear the subtlety of his metered self control that prevents him from becoming completely unhinged. And, oh my god, the realization of how badly he wants me nearly send me off." ---- WARNING: NSFW, Mature | Hogwarts Legacy Fan-fiction | Romance | Contains Hogwarts Legacy Spoilers | F Gryffindor OC / Sebastian Sallow. | M OC / Ominis Gaunt | Steamy Start, Slow Burn

Serendipity [Sebastian Sallow] by shewritesanonymously

18+ aged up, slow burn, Sebastian Sallow x Original Character book. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ It had been years since Scarlett Axford had last laid her eyes on Sebastian Sallow, the boy who she had held very close to her heart for as long as she could remember knowing him. After graduating from Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, their friendship had become distant. In the last few years since drifting further apart, by a stroke of serendipity, both Scarlett and Sebastian find themselves in each other's company again, with Sebastian recently accepting the new position of Arithmancy Professor at Hogwarts. Slowly, and with hesitation, their friendship begins to rekindle when Sebastian arrives at Hogwarts with a shocking discovery. As they spend more time together, they discover that their feelings for each other have developed into something deeper. However, their romance is not without challenges as they both try to overcome the past they have shared, the distance that had been created and the residue of pain left behind. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ All copyright remains with the creators of the Hogwarts Legacy Franchise, minus my original character, Scarlett Axford. Warnings: Slow burn book Rated Mature/NSFW (smuttier as time goes on) Contains Hogwarts Legacy Spoilers Please proceed with caution.

What Lies Between Us | A Sebastian Sallow Story by kelseyreads22

Hogwarts has opened its doors to Muggles for the first time in history. Five were chosen. Four were welcomed. One was not. Amelia Blossom never wanted to be part of the Ministry's experiment, but being sorted into Slytherin makes her an outcast in both worlds-hated by her housemates for being a Muggle and resented by the other Muggle students for ending up in the "wrong" house. Alone, powerless, and relentlessly tormented, she has no way to fight back. Then there's Sebastian Sallow-charming, dangerous, and utterly exhausted by the attention he can't escape. Girls whisper his name, boys challenge him to duels, and he's grown tired of playing the role everyone expects of him. He needs an out. She needs protection. A deal is struck: a fake relationship to keep Slytherin's wrath at bay and free Sebastian from his relentless admirers. Because in a house where loyalty is conditional and betrayal is inevitable, pretending to love someone might be the most dangerous game of all. •••••••• *all photos of Sebastian from Pinterest and full credit goes to their lovely creators* *partially inspired by The List* ••••••••• RANKINGS: #34 in sebastiansallow #44 in hogwartslegacy #165 in fakedating #26 in enemiestofriendstolovers

For the Love of a Slytherin by BurritoBeans1

Hufflepuff reader, Adelaide Adonis has just started at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. Little did she know, she would meet a student who would challenge her to the very core of her beliefs, and yet still make her fall in love with him along the way. Spoilers for the game. It's a telling of the players thoughts/feelings towards the different Sebastian scenarios throughout the game, along with slight changes to the storyline. I don't own anything. Thanks for reading :) Update: I added a new book titled 'For the love of Sebastian Sallow.' This will contain more romance since I will have more creative freedom without following the storyline of the game. It follows the same characters, and some of Adelaide's other friends, only two years later in their final year at Hogwarts.

Of Cunning Minds: Sebastian Sallow by WrenTravers

Thea Fields faced a plethora of dangers during her fifth year at Hogwarts. Leave it to Ominis Guant to come knocking at her door seven years later asking her to help him conquer even greater challenges. Little does he know that it's not the evil wizards and dark magic that scare her, it's the idea of coming face to face with Sebastian Sallow again after all this time. Kind of enemies to lovers. Post HL story line. A very slow burn :)

You may also like

Slide 1 of 19

A new threat cover

For The Love Of A Snake cover

for the hope of it all // Sebastian Sallow x reader cover

Allurement | Sebastian Sallow cover

In The Shadow of Our Choices cover

Sebastian Sallow x MC! OC: Songbirds Love cover

Order of Shadows | Sebastian Sallow Love Story cover

Waking of Shadows cover

In the Shadow of You | Hogwarts Legacy cover

Sebastian Sallow: Duel of Hearts cover

Side Effects |a Sebastian Sallow story| cover

Into Sallow's mind // Sebastian Sallow cover

In the Shadows - Sebastian Sallow x reader (English) cover

ONLY YOU || Sebastian Sallow cover

Return of Sebastian Sallow | 10 Yr After Hogwarts cover

Serendipity [Sebastian Sallow] cover

What Lies Between Us | A Sebastian Sallow Story cover

For the Love of a Slytherin cover

Of Cunning Minds: Sebastian Sallow cover

A new threat

A Hogwarts Legacy story. Focused on the relationship of reader x Sebastian. After all the traumatic events of your fifth year in Hogwarts, you hoped that this year would be normal. Focussing on your studies, hang out with friends and most importantly rekindle your friendship with Sebastian Sallow. Despite everything that happened, you still believe that the connection you once shared was strong enough to overcome anything. Unfortunately you discover soon enough that you're in way over your head again. A new enemy has arisen, friendships are tested to their limits and with your power seemingly growing you must rise to the challenge once again. The story will be written as a Sebastian X Reader fanfic using first person POV for both Y/N and Sebastian. !!Beware for spoilers of the game!!