Stan Marsh has been hiding his feelings for Wendy Testaburger, avoiding her and causing confusion. His friend Kyle Broflovski tells Wendy the truth, and the two start dating, talking every day. But when Kyle confesses his own feelings for Stan, he realizes he has competition. Desperate to win Stan's heart, Kyle turns to Tolkien for help, leading to consequences that threaten to destroy their friendships. In this tale of love and friendship, Stan, Wendy, Kyle, and their friends must navigate the awkward road to love, confront their hidden feelings, and learn to forgive and trust each other again.