With Steven coming back to Beach City after a long absence, the crystal gems and friends decide a party should be in order. After much deliberation on how the party should be held, they decide a late night party filled with smores, drinks, and good stories in the beach house will be the perfect way to spend it. When Steven arrives, he greets everyone with hugs, laughter, and old memories being shared. With snacks now being shared and people now settled, it becomes story time as many share spooky, fictional stories, or historical, non-fiction stories. When it reaches Garnet, she has a story to tell that may end up not being so fictional than she had previously thought with an uninvited guest making his own appearance to add to the tale...