Secrets and Lies - Hogwarts Legacy
- Reads 17,908
- Votes 537
- Parts 35
MatureOngoing77h 58m
Last published Thu, Dec 18, 2025
SECRETS AND LIES.
Almost two years after the chaos of Hogwarts Legacy, Fiona "Fi" Grey has found more than friendship in Sebastian Sallow and Ominis Gaunt - she's found the family she never had, bound by the battle to save The Repository, cure Anne and the harrowing trials they've faced together along the way. But when loyalties start to fracture and hidden truths claw their way to the surface, Fiona realises that even the strongest bonds can shatter.
Entangled in a love triangle that's pushing her to the brink and haunted by a growing crisis of identity, Fiona is forced to confront a painful truth: trust is fragile and betrayal cuts deep. As danger returns to shatter her peace and deception thickens, Fiona must decide who she is, what she stands for - and whether the friendships she's built can survive the secrets threatening to tear them apart.
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
In the Glow of Your Eyes | Sebastian Sallow
After a year away from Hogwarts, Marin Arlette returns still carrying the heartbreak of losing her beloved professor. Grief drove her to run, but it also left things unfinished-especially with Sebastian. Something had shifted between them before she left, something she never had the courage to face. Now, seeing him again, she can't tell if her heart is urging her closer or warning her to stay away. His teasing smirk, his stubborn loyalty, the way he still sees through her-it's all achingly familiar, and impossible to ignore. As old feelings resurface, Marin dares to believe she might finally heal what was broken. But shadows gather quickly, and someone seems determined to pull her back into darkness. With danger closing in, every choice risks more than just her heart. In a world of magic, secrets, and betrayal, Marin must decide if trusting Sebastian-and trusting love-is the key to moving on... ...or the risk that could shatter everything. !CONTAINS HOGWARTS LEGACY SPOILERS!
Love's Not Time's Fool // Ominis Gaunt x Anne Sallow
[COMPLETE] {Ominis Gaunt x Anne Sallow} Love at first sight? Maybe not exactly. Doomed from the start? Only time will tell. This spin-off story occurs before, during, and after the events of 'Like Moths to a Flame' and 'Burning Bright.' Chapters span the years of 1886 through 1891. There will be spoilers for the full 'Like Moths to a Flame' series thus far, but it can also be read as a standalone. Anne & Ominis POV. *** When Anne thought about Ominis, her heart fluttered in her chest in a way that caught her completely off guard. She wasn't supposed to feel this way about her twin brother's best friend. It was all quite maddening, really.Complete
The Facade of Us | Sebastian Sallow x Reader
"We can't keep tipping the scale of friendship, Sebastian." I say, my voice trembling as I meet his gaze. His expression falters, vulnerability flickering across his face. "Then tell me, Y/N-what do we call this?" ────⋆⋅☆⋅⋆── Returning to Hogwarts for your seventh year, you're still celebrated for your heroic deeds during fifth year. But fame comes with its challenges, and nothing complicates life more than unspoken emotions. Over the summer, you, Ominis, and Sebastian made a solemn pact: no matter what, nothing would break your trio apart. One condition, however, left you uneasy-Ominis forbade any romance between you and Sebastian, convinced it would only bring chaos. You agreed, believing your feelings for Sebastian were purely platonic. But as the new school year begins, the line between friendship and something deeper began to blur. Leander Prewett, persistent as ever, refuses to take no for an answer when it comes to his infatuation with you that started in your fifth year. Desperate for a solution, you turn to Sebastian for help, thinking it might finally end Leander's advances. Little did you know, this small request would set the stage for a far more tangled web of emotions and forbidden feelings.Complete
The Virginity Pact {Sebastian Sallow x Ominis Gaunt x You}
We were the perfect trio of friends. Ominis Gaunt, Sebastian Sallow and I. We became bound through our grief, our friendship flourishing extravagantly as we became more like a family for one another as our real families stayed sheltered in the dark. The protagonist intends on dating this year being her 7th one at Hogwarts, this has caused a lot of jealously and feelings to arise from the shadows within the Slytherin boys. Hormones sky rocket, first's are taken and lessons are taught as goblins are seeking their revenge hungrily. How will she cope when she's secretly in love with them both, will their friendship survive another uprising of goblins and dark wizards when it nearly broke them the last time? ~ Ominis and Sebastian navigate the waters of this tricky love triangle as they learn to share her, softening as they begin to realise their true feelings for her. If you can't decide between your favourite Slytherin boy, why not have them both? ~ This story takes place in the hogwarts legacy universe, several years later. There is 18+ content throughout this book. Please read the triggers in my authors note. Thank-you so much for your support.Complete
Unforgivable
After Y/N's fatal choice to end Solomon Sallows life, Sebastian disappears. With Sebastian gone, Y/N must now lean on Ominis Gaunt to help her through the loss of her beloved Professor and the guilt that festers deep within her heart. Y/N believes Ominis is the only one she can truly trust but even he has his secrets and when Sebastian unexpectedly returns for her, the secret is revealed. A secret that will threaten to tear the once-unbreakable trio apart. But once a new threat emerges, the three must put Ominis' deceit aside and work together. Disclaimer: This story contains spoilers for Hogwarts Legacy. Mentions of smoking, drinking, and themes of childhood abuse. Very important plot points are used. In addition, there will be fluff, smut, spice, violence, TOTAL AND UTTER BETRAYAL, and mentions of PTSD. This starts very Ominisxreader heavy but Sebastian is ENDGAME, I promise.
Imperio | Sebastian Sallow
𝐄𝐥𝐞𝐧𝐚 𝐑𝐞𝐢𝐧𝐡𝐚𝐫𝐭 is a young woman who has settled into a peaceful life with her fiancé, Ominis Gaunt. After a quiet engagement, Elena enjoys the calm of her routine, until a headline shakes her world: "Sebastian Sallow, Notorious Fugitive, Escapes Azkaban." Suddenly, her past comes rushing back, Sebastian, her high school boyfriend, a love that once consumed her, and a promise that still haunts her. But when Elena finally comes face to face with him, something is wrong. This isn't the Sebastian she remembers. ₊‧ʚ ❤︎ ɞ‧₊ Mature content (18+). Please read the introduction for trigger warnings and additional information before diving in. Cover Creds: Audra1890 Ratings: #1 Triangledrama #1 OminisGauntComplete
When The Devil Falls In Love
After Hogwarts, MC has become a powerful wielder of Ancient Magic, helping those in need across the Hogwarts Valley. She is in a comfortable, if unexciting, relationship with Garreth Weasley, who is part of her best friend Ominis Gaunt's Auror team. As Lead Auror, Ominis is determined to take down a dangerous dark wizard organization-until Sebastian Sallow, his former best friend turned infamous dark wizard, unexpectedly returns. Reuniting with MC after years apart, Sebastian's presence stirs up old tensions, unresolved emotions, and undeniable chemistry. As MC is drawn deeper into Sebastian's world, she struggles between the life she planned and the one her heart craves. With betrayals, power struggles, and a dangerous game of morality unfolding, Ominis and Sebastian battle for control-not just over the Auror team, but over the fate of MC's heart. When love and darkness collide, can Sebastian truly change, or will he drag MC into the abyss with him?Complete
Faded memories | Ominis Gaunt
Warning: explicit content, smut, NSFW 🔞 After the final battle with Ranrok, Dari Goldstein comes back to Hogwarts to her Slytherin common room to get some rest and finally speak with Ominis about her feelings and then the story of two lovers begin... Dari jumps from one reality to another to be with her loved one - Ominis Gaunt, no matter how much it costs. The friendship between silver trio is growing further and their interactions in the future may be vulnerable by the things they have to face in the magic world. (In this version all characters are older than 18 years old.) P.S. The story contains a lot of dialogues and mostly focused on that. P.S.S. I don't own any characters expect my OFC and OMC. *Started on the 17th of February* *Finished on the 26th of April* #3 in « Ominis Gaunt » 02.22.2023 🐍 #2 in « Mutual Feelings » 03.13.2023 🫂 #3 in « Softcore » 03.25.2023 🥰 #4 in « Worship » 04.14.2023 🛐 #6 in « OMC » 04.23.2023 🚶🏼Complete
Legacy | Hogwarts Legacy
Hogwarts 1892. Sabrina Lewis, the Gentle Slytherin. Ominis Gaunt, the Determined Son. Sebastian Sallow, the Loyal Brother. Anne Sallow, the Ambitious Sister. It's their seventh and final year at Hogwarts for our Shadow Group, but instead of being excited for the future, Sabrina is forced to deal with a terrifying secret - and her ancient magic might just be the key to solving it. At the same time, the threat of Marvolo Gaunt is forever in the back of her mind as he threatens to try and kill her and Ominis. Will the strength of her found family, as well as her love for Ominis, be enough to keep everyone from falling apart? A Hogwarts Legacy sequel. CHARACTERS ARE AGED UP. 18+ TW: Mentions of family abuse, torture, smut, and death. I have warnings on specific chapters. CHARACTERS ARE BASED ON HOGWARTS LEGACY VIDEO GAME. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.Complete
Forever & Again | Sebastian x OC x Ominis | Mature 18+
Dark Romance | When Mira seeks refuge at Hogwarts, she soon becomes entwined in a dangerous web of desire and secrets: Sebastian, a fierce and passionate new love driven by wild devotion, and Ominis, a loyal flame, rooted in the nostalgia of her youth. As her boundaries between temptation and ruin are tested, Mira quickly faces impossible choices between love and ambition, trust and betrayal, freedom and damnation ~ decisions that threaten not only her body and future, but her very soul. ~~~ MATURE 18+ | Themes of sex, abuse, suicide, physical assault, emotional and mental abuse, depression, domestic violence, ritual sacrifice... This story is a dark romance involving a love-triangle: sebastian x oc x ominis Fandom Familiarity is Optional | Apart from names and setting, everything else can stand alone in the alternate magical universe. All characters are adults 18+ Enjoy~ ✨ Highest Rankings: #1 hogwartslegacyfanfic 02/21/25 - 05/15/25 #1 sebastiansallow 03/06/25 #1 sebastianxoc 03/03/25 #1 hogwartsromance 02/26/25 - 03/28/25 #1 ominis 12/13/24 #1 sallow 12/15/24 - 03/28/25Complete
After a year away from Hogwarts, Marin Arlette returns still carrying the heartbreak of losing her beloved professor. Grief drove her to run, but it also left things unfinished-especially with Sebastian. Something had shifted between them before she left, something she never had the courage to face. Now, seeing him again, she can't tell if her heart is urging her closer or warning her to stay away. His teasing smirk, his stubborn loyalty, the way he still sees through her-it's all achingly familiar, and impossible to ignore. As old feelings resurface, Marin dares to believe she might finally heal what was broken. But shadows gather quickly, and someone seems determined to pull her back into darkness. With danger closing in, every choice risks more than just her heart. In a world of magic, secrets, and betrayal, Marin must decide if trusting Sebastian-and trusting love-is the key to moving on... ...or the risk that could shatter everything. !CONTAINS HOGWARTS LEGACY SPOILERS!
More detailsContent Guidelines