Between Good and Evil~ Hogwarts Legacy
- Reads 1,323
- Votes 40
- Parts 5
Ominis and MC started dating recently, but when Sebastian confesses his feelings for her Ominis is left wondering if he is just getting in the way of true love.
He is ready to let her go since the doubts that plague his mind won't allow him to trust her.
MC, on the other hand, is fighting a different kind of darkness, and she needs them both to get through it.
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
The Cost of ME(SebastianSallow X MCX OminisGaunt fanfic)
After saving Hogwarts and curing Anne Sallow, MC feels used and abandoned by Sebastian and Ominis. Despite her sacrifices, they barely acknowledge her and move on with their lives, with Sebastian and Ominis dating other girls. As the silence grows between them, MC decides to leave Hogwarts, using ancient magic to block the Trace and start a new life in a quiet hamlet, opening an apothecary. Three years later, Sebastian and Ominis show up at her door, seeking her forgiveness. They admit their mistakes and regret not being there for her, but MC, who has healed and moved on, tells them it's too late. She has built a life without them, and their apologies come too late to undo the damage. In the end, she closes the door on the past, having found peace without them. ***This is crossposted on my ao3 sebominis0708*** ***Chapters few BUT LONG***Complete
Enchanting, Enchanted ✧ Sebastian Sallow x Y/N x Ominis Gaunt
After the fiasco that had occurred at the end of your fifth year, you no longer have contact with either Ominis or Sebastian. As you enter your sixth year in Hogwarts you predict they'd want nothing to do with you after all the trouble that had been caused since you arrived, however to your astonishment this year they are closer to you than you'd fantasized. ˚ ✦ . . ˚ . . ✦ ˚ . ★⋆. ࿐࿔ . ˚ * ✦ . . ✦ ˚ ˚ .˚ ✦ . . ˚ . ੈ✧̣̇˳·˖✶ ✦ [Love Triangle] [Explicit Content & Violence] [Post Gameplay]Complete
The Facade of Us | Sebastian Sallow x Reader
"We can't keep tipping the scale of friendship, Sebastian." I say, my voice trembling as I meet his gaze. His expression falters, vulnerability flickering across his face. "Then tell me, Y/N-what do we call this?" ────⋆⋅☆⋅⋆── Returning to Hogwarts for your seventh year, you're still celebrated for your heroic deeds during fifth year. But fame comes with its challenges, and nothing complicates life more than unspoken emotions. Over the summer, you, Ominis, and Sebastian made a solemn pact: no matter what, nothing would break your trio apart. One condition, however, left you uneasy-Ominis forbade any romance between you and Sebastian, convinced it would only bring chaos. You agreed, believing your feelings for Sebastian were purely platonic. But as the new school year begins, the line between friendship and something deeper began to blur. Leander Prewett, persistent as ever, refuses to take no for an answer when it comes to his infatuation with you that started in your fifth year. Desperate for a solution, you turn to Sebastian for help, thinking it might finally end Leander's advances. Little did you know, this small request would set the stage for a far more tangled web of emotions and forbidden feelings.Complete
Unforgivable
After Y/N's fatal choice to end Solomon Sallows life, Sebastian disappears. With Sebastian gone, Y/N must now lean on Ominis Gaunt to help her through the loss of her beloved Professor and the guilt that festers deep within her heart. Y/N believes Ominis is the only one she can truly trust but even he has his secrets and when Sebastian unexpectedly returns for her, the secret is revealed. A secret that will threaten to tear the once-unbreakable trio apart. But once a new threat emerges, the three must put Ominis' deceit aside and work together. Disclaimer: This story contains spoilers for Hogwarts Legacy. Mentions of smoking, drinking, and themes of childhood abuse. Very important plot points are used. In addition, there will be fluff, smut, spice, violence, TOTAL AND UTTER BETRAYAL, and mentions of PTSD. This starts very Ominisxreader heavy but Sebastian is ENDGAME, I promise.
In the Shadow of Hogwarts: A Hogwarts Legacy Story
What if Ominis and Sebastian had more than just friendly feelings for each other? What if the tale of the relic took a completely different turn? A tale of enduring love and the consequences of wrong choices. "His fingertips descended onto the smooth, warm skin. Lightly fluttering, they traced Sebastian's eyebrows, eyes, and nose before abruptly halting. He had touched his friend's smile before, but had never given it much thought. Now, Sebastian tilted his head back ever so slightly, and Ominis' fingers effortlessly slid to his lips. Soft, slightly moist, with a small crack from the cold, they slowly stretched upward at the corners and then retreated slightly. "Are you afraid?" Sebastian asked. "I'm afraid we'll regret this tomorrow," Ominis whispered, tracing the contours of Sebastian's lips with his fingers." ⚠️Warnings⚠️ - Fluff-to-angst narrative shift - 18+ scenes (all characters are over 16 years old) - Scenes of violence, non-consensual acts, suicides and murders - Partial canon divergence English is not my native language, so I would appreciate any feedback and corrections regarding grammar, vocabulary, and other aspects. Of course, I would also be delighted to receive any other comments, evaluations, and feedback. Each one of them would brighten my day.Complete
Forever & Again | Sebastian x OC x Ominis | Mature 18+
Dark Romance | When Mira seeks refuge at Hogwarts, she soon becomes entwined in a dangerous web of desire and secrets: Sebastian, a fierce and passionate new love driven by wild devotion, and Ominis, a loyal flame, rooted in the nostalgia of her youth. As her boundaries between temptation and ruin are tested, Mira quickly faces impossible choices between love and ambition, trust and betrayal, freedom and damnation ~ decisions that threaten not only her body and future, but her very soul. ~~~ MATURE 18+ | Themes of sex, abuse, suicide, physical assault, emotional and mental abuse, depression, domestic violence, ritual sacrifice... This story is a dark romance involving a love-triangle: sebastian x oc x ominis Fandom Familiarity is Optional | Apart from names and setting, everything else can stand alone in the alternate magical universe. All characters are adults 18+ Enjoy~ ✨ Highest Rankings: #1 hogwartslegacyfanfic 02/21/25 - 05/15/25 #1 sebastiansallow 03/06/25 #1 sebastianxoc 03/03/25 #1 hogwartsromance 02/26/25 - 03/28/25 #1 ominis 12/13/24 #1 sallow 12/15/24 - 03/28/25Complete
Old Habits Die Hard
You find yourself once again in the arms of Sebastian Sallow, but with the added complication of your unexpected feelings towards your friend, Ominis Gaunt. Reader pov (MC), set in final year at Hogwarts. Angsty love triangle/rivalry filled with jealousy and complicated feelings. THIS IS NOT A POLY FIC!Complete
In the Shadow of Azkaban
UPDATE AS OF 08/14/2026: Due to the new terms of service with this platform, this story has been transferred from Wattpad and published on Archive of Our Own (AO3). You will need an account to view it, and my username there is under Anonymous. It has been such a pleasure to see how far we have come with this fic, and I'm so happy you all have enjoyed it. Again, if you want to read it again and again, head over to AO3. I'm sure this fic will be taken down shortly by Wattpad. It's been real. :) I do not own any of these characters. All credit goes to Warner Bros. Characters are 20 in this novel.Complete
After saving Hogwarts and curing Anne Sallow, MC feels used and abandoned by Sebastian and Ominis. Despite her sacrifices, they barely acknowledge her and move on with their lives, with Sebastian and Ominis dating other girls. As the silence grows between them, MC decides to leave Hogwarts, using ancient magic to block the Trace and start a new life in a quiet hamlet, opening an apothecary. Three years later, Sebastian and Ominis show up at her door, seeking her forgiveness. They admit their mistakes and regret not being there for her, but MC, who has healed and moved on, tells them it's too late. She has built a life without them, and their apologies come too late to undo the damage. In the end, she closes the door on the past, having found peace without them. ***This is crossposted on my ao3 sebominis0708*** ***Chapters few BUT LONG***
More detailsContent Guidelines