A Heart Divided
- Reads 98
- Votes 7
- Parts 7
When Sunrise Shutter finds herself torn between two possible lovers, she must make a decision that may forever alter the course of her life.
A "choose your own adventure" style My Little Pony story where the readers will weigh in after each chapter and decide what path Sunrise will take. Each decision will be permanent, and there will be no alternative endings. Choose wisely...
This story consists fully of My Little Pony OCs, and no interactions with canon characters.
(This story contains some scenes including light drinking, cursing, and references to adult topics. There are no scenes containing adult content in this story- only brief mentions. Read with caution.)
All Rights Reserved
#183
alcohol
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
In The End? I Love You.
Starry Specter had loved once, jaded by plans she could have never expected, she finds herself alone and without a family to give her guidance. She finds herself alone in a town outside of the life she knew and without a home or food to put in her belly. So when she finds herself at the mercy of a bat pony with a missing wing, she doesn't expect to find solace and love in him of all ponies. Stone River never had love, born in raised in a small town and displaced by the ponies he swore to protect, he finds himself with no wife, no family, and no reason to try. The owner of a small apartment building in Ponyville finds a devastating unicorn at his doorstep, he takes a step in kindness he did not even know was there. He does not expect to find a friend in this mare but in the end? He finds so much more. This romance tells the tale of two ponies who find themselves with nothing but each other, secrets, and the secrets of an elite society dragging ponies into lives they never expected for themselves. Can these two jaded and hopeless ponies find true love in each other? Or are they meant to fall to the society that was built to topple them?Complete
Mlp New Generation: The Flames of Mayham
disclaimer: I don't own Mlp or it's characters, I only own my Oc and my other Ocs in this story There once was a pegasus filly who dreamed three dreams each unique and was mocked on by her peers. Her first dream was to fly in the night sky within the moonlight but her peers told her it shall never happen for everypony knows only the royals can fly. Her second dream was to be able to cast spells to help thoses she cared about but she was told that only unicorns can cast spells. Her third and final dream was to have a family that wouldn't judge her for her flaws but her peers told her that it would never happen because she was too flawed for anyone to not judge her. the filly's heart broke more and more each day she was told her dreams won't come true until one day she ran away from the place she once called home to try to escape her pain after loosing her only friend Zipp Storm. the filly then found others that were without families like her and she lead them to create their own home but her pain stayed as she grew, she became cold and untrusting towards thoses around her. Will Sunny and her friends be able to help her with her pain? or will they fail to stop her plans of making everypony know the pain she's felt her whole life.Complete
Friendship Is Possession (Yandere Equestria Girls)
Fresh off the farm and into the chaos of Canterlot High, Y/N thought city life would be a simple change of pace. But when he catches the attention of the school's most popular girls, things take a darker turn. Beneath their friendly smiles lie dangerous obsessions, and Y/N soon finds himself trapped in a web of twisted love, possessiveness, and hidden madness. In this school, friendship isn't magic-it's a trap. (Warning contains murder, mentions of suicide and violence) 1k votes 07/08/25 #1 mylittleponyfriendshipismagic (08/28/25) #1 again mylittleponyfriendshipismagic From (09/17/25) To (09/23/25) #1 Equestria girls tag (08/28/25) #1 PinkiePie tag (09/25/25) to (10/13/25) #1 Twilightsparkle tag (10/19/25)
Songs of Innocence: Night
In the human world mirroring Equestria, magic scarcely seeps through. But when it does, it's bad. And college newcomer Innocent Sun gets the worst of it. The tale of the Equestrian Innocent Sun is finished. For now, at least. A brand new tale, featuring her human counterpart, is about to unfold! Nothing will be quite the same as before. Weird happenings twist the mundane, symbols of cryptic gods obsess the innocent, and normalcy slips away to reveal uncanny fortresses designed by the demons of nightmare. Can Innocent Sun survive it all? And even worse... can she survive college? No reading of the first two SoI stories is needed! This is a fresh slate. Expect a mix of light moments and the occasional scene of pseudo-horror (it's my thing, I gotta do it!). I do not own concepts from Hasbro's My Little Pony: Equestria Girls, such as characters like Fluttershy, or general concepts such as Equestrian magic.
Mostly Routine Patrol
Shadow and Sterling are sent on a simple mission by the guard, a boring mission neither of them want to go on; patrol a trade route path. Sterling is a unicorn and is prepared to do his duty to the crown and uphold the standards set before him by his predecessors, he won't waver in his conviction to the task. He isn't ready for the happy and energetic mare he's sent with. Shadow, on the other hand, is a happy thestral mare who only wants to live to the idea dream of being a guard. Spending her youth reading books about gallant mares rushing into battle and saving the day, she hopes for her moment to shine. She doesn't know how little fun it's going to be working with such a stoic stallion, while barely repressing her diestrus urges.Complete
The lost bet - (Appledash)
The two students on Canterlot High likes competitions, bets and challenges. Both of them are really concered to winning. Who wins the bet to not fall in love first? - appledash fanfiction The universe and characters are not mine, credit goes to Hasbro. Also the fanart on the cover is not mine, credit to whoever made it.Complete
A lesson about friendship (My little pony x male earth pony oc)
Silver Wood, an earth pony who doesn't have any time for friendship. But was moving to ponyville the right desicion for that? When helping some pony's and getting friends... somehow? He finds himself stuck into countless of adventures and choices to make for his friends. How much will his point of view change of friendship? (I don't own My little pony, it is owned and produced by Hasbro, Bonnie Zacherle & Lauren Faust, and of course all the other studio's Picture/ that I am probably gonna use aren't mine too, the cover of this story goes to their original creator/artist. The only thing that is mine is my oc and the other oc's I'm gonna use now and in the future.)Complete
Punk Girl - HERMIONE x OC/READER
What dose a selective mute become when she chooses to speak. And oh, dose she speak her mind away. Adora is a clasified: Punk, mess, Slytherin, and all the opposites of Hermione's: clean girl, neat, Gryffindor --- An awake call from Adoras most deeply hated Gryffindor girl may rewrite everything she had set out for herself. How can one event change it all?Complete
Hold up, Why the frick am I in My Little Pony?! (Mlp x Male reader) (HIATUS)
Any who, Greetings! Yep just like the title says this will be another story of a 16-year-old boy called Y/N (aka Your Name in case you didn't know) and he finds himself in the world of My Little Pony, fun... right...? I'm going to let some things clear first. First, the character will be someone who is always kindhearted and fun, but when needed to he will get serious. Two, he will not be an extremely OP character like in most stories, but he will still have various tricks up his sleeve, or hooves in this case I suppose. Finally, I just want to make it clear that I am still in school and might not post very often, but I make a Pinkie promise to you guys that in the scenario in which I need to stop the story, it will at least be at the end of a season and not in the middle, like I see it happen in some stories ;-;. FYI, this is my first time writing a story, so there might be mistakes every once in a while, alright enough of that, time for the story.Complete
love is in the air
Rainbow Dash and Soarin' start as professional teammates, each with their own strengths and quirks. As they train together, they begin to understand each other more deeply, finding common ground between their differences. Their growing connection goes beyond just flying, as they learn to rely on each other in ways they hadn't expected. As they face challenges, their bond deepens, leading them to realize that their relationship might be something more than they initially thought. Disclaimer: I don't own the art coverComplete
Starry Specter had loved once, jaded by plans she could have never expected, she finds herself alone and without a family to give her guidance. She finds herself alone in a town outside of the life she knew and without a home or food to put in her belly. So when she finds herself at the mercy of a bat pony with a missing wing, she doesn't expect to find solace and love in him of all ponies. Stone River never had love, born in raised in a small town and displaced by the ponies he swore to protect, he finds himself with no wife, no family, and no reason to try. The owner of a small apartment building in Ponyville finds a devastating unicorn at his doorstep, he takes a step in kindness he did not even know was there. He does not expect to find a friend in this mare but in the end? He finds so much more. This romance tells the tale of two ponies who find themselves with nothing but each other, secrets, and the secrets of an elite society dragging ponies into lives they never expected for themselves. Can these two jaded and hopeless ponies find true love in each other? Or are they meant to fall to the society that was built to topple them?
More detailsContent Guidelines