"Just Like Me" {Eyeless Jack x Reader} (sequel to "All Eyes") - Spooker - Wattpad

Story cover for "Just Like Me" {Eyeless Jack x Reader} (sequel to "All Eyes") by XannVe

"Just Like Me" {Eyeless Jack x Reader} (sequel to "All Eyes")

Reads 2,997
Votes 104
Parts 12
Time 48m

Reads 2,997
Votes 104
Parts 12
Time 48m

creepypasta eyelessjack homicidalliu jeffthekiller memories remember romance slenderman ticcitoby zalgo

Being a server to someone isn't an easy life. You don't have free will, you don't get paid, you live in poor conditions, and above all you're trapped. And it makes it even harder when you're serving the God of chaos itself; Zalgo. This is the only life I know, or have known... I'm not even sure anymore who I am... They call me Bunny, but I know for a fact that's not my real name. And there's this empty spot in my heart which I can't seem to fill whatever I do. That's what I thought until I met him once again...

-=÷=-

HIYA! I'M BACK! It took a hot half year for me to start writing the sequel, but oh well! It's best if you've read "All Eyes" beforehand but you can still read it if you haven't, so no worries!All Rights Reserved

creepypasta eyelessjack homicidalliu jeffthekiller memories remember romance slenderman ticcitoby zalgo

Series

Creepypasta

20 parts
13 parts
10 parts
23 parts
7 parts
12 parts
3 parts

Table of contents

12 parts

Sign up to add "Just Like Me" {Eyeless Jack x Reader} (sequel to "All Eyes") to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Bloody Flowers [TicciJack] by MaskedmenMaruaders

⚠︎There will be mental health struggles, suicide, attempted suicide, death, abuse, violence, and other triggering topics. If any of this is a trigger, please do not read this fan fiction.⚠︎ [insert description] I did not come up with Ticci Toby or Eyeless Jack, they aren't my ocs. Credit to their creators (Azelf500 & Kastoway) 💪 The art isn't mine either 😞 (Yasmim.Killer_UwU) #1 in Marble Hornets - Nov. 8th 2025 #1 in ticcitobyxeyelessjack - Dec. 12th 2025

𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢? [✔] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader} by Lesbesbean

In order to save your life, Slenderman does what he swore he'd never do - he makes you his proxy. Little did you know how much it would change your life... - - - The reader is kept gender-neutral throughout the whole story and smut chapters always have two versions (one for male and one for female anatomy). Tldr; this is a creepypasta x reader fanfic, let's not take it *too* seriously. Characters here are probably very OOC, I shaped them as I wish to create a fun story ;3

The Cannibal and The Mute | Eyeless Jack x Mute! Male! Reader by Lucifers_Gentleman

(M/N). A young boy who is unable to speak. Not able to make a sound. To make up for it he has amazing art skills. His parents hated it. They didn't want to pay for lessons to speak.They wanted a child who could talk. Not someone who "waists their time on childish things like drawing." They didn't want to have this.... mistake of a child. They thought they deserved a normal child. So they had another child. Who COULD speak. And they absolutely spoiled and loved him. So Rick naturally was a jerk. Which caused (m/n) to one day crack and lose his sanity after a long beating. He becomes the true demon inside him when it comes to killing. His inner psychopath. As (m/n) walks through the forest, unsure of what to do next, he meets a tall man. A man who could enter (m/n)'s mind. A man who had no face. That man took (m/n) in, into a mansion of killers just like himself. And (m/n) couldn't feel more like at home. (M/N) makes lots of friends. But one caught his eyes the first time they met. The tall man was introducing (m/n) to the rest of the killers. (M/N) saw that most of them had masks. But one particular blue mask caught his eyes. He walked over to the taller male and stared at him in curiosity. He then lifted his hand and reached for the mask. Only to be stopped by a strong hand. "What are you doing?" The taller male lowly growled. (M/N) backed up in fear. Will (m/n) and Jack become friends? Enemies? Or.... Lovers?

She's Mine. (Creepypasta x Reader Fanfiction) by AwkwardSunset

My name is Y/N, and I guess you can say I'm not normal. I met Slenderman one day, while running through the woods, and since then my whole world changed. The reason I'm not normal is because of what happened just a few weeks after I became a pasta. I find out who I really am, and who I love. ----------------------------------------------------- WHO WILL YOU CHOOSE? Ben Drowned? Eyeless Jack? Homicidal Liu? Hoodie? Jeff the Killer? Laughing Jack? Masky? Offenderman? Slenderman? Splendorman? Ticci Toby? Trenderman? [COMPLETED]

Masky X Reader X Hoodie by WildChild289

Alone in the forest, A runaway from your abusive ex bf, A savior named hoodie takes you to a mansion.... An outgoing guy and a cold hearted killer. 2 guys 1 heart... Who will you choose?.

ᴸᴼᵛᴱ ᴮᴵᵀᴱˢ by Queen-Of-Weird

Proxies X Fem Reader ~~~ Oh blood, oh blood Why must you bleed? Oh blood, oh blood Why must I feast? Oh blood, oh blood, Why can I never find an never ending course..? Zalgo, he is my operator. I am his proxy. Though I hate being controlled, I can't help but listen. I owe him. I'd much rather have to hunt for my food than have him hand it to me every time he gets what he wants. I don't want to be his proxy, I despise it. I even despise the feuds he has with Slender Man and his brothers as there is no point to them. No point in having me fight them. Such a waste of time. Such a waste of my hunger. That is till one day, during a lock down from another one of Zalgos feuds with Slender, something strange happened. Slender Doesn't ᴷᴵᴸᴸ ᴹᴱ. ~~~~~~~~~~ First Published: December 3, 2021 Book 1: ᴸᴼᵛᴱ ᴮᴵᵀᴱˢ Book 2: ᴸᴼᵛᴱ ᴸᴵᶠᴱ

The Innocent Eyes (Jeff The Killer X Reader) by MusicIsGreat678

*100,888 words* Strange things happen under strange circumstances and sometimes the most unsafe people make you feel the most safe. When you meet Jeff, he's not exactly like the stories you've heard. Perhaps he's just broken, but aren't we all? Can you fix each other? Will he finally be able to love something, despite his insanity? What are the true stories of him and other creepypastas?

My New Family (Creepypasta x Reader) by ginghamandgreentea

[Creepypasta x Reader] ❝ I was walking in my woods, hanging up my pages on trees, when I heard someone calling out 'Mommy?'❞ Cover art is not mine, it rightfully belongs to @/PslenDy on DeviantArt. I did, however, edit the cover. ••• 6 year old (Y/N) was found by Slenderman after her alcoholic mother abandoned her in the woods. He adopts her as his own child. 9 years later, he gets a note from Zalgo. Either he creates an army to fight, or he loses everything and everyone that he loves. ••• !!WARNING!! MATURE THEMES AHEAD. STORY INCLUDES: - gore - murderers - serial killers - several mental illnesses (mentioned and displayed) - kidnapping - child abandonment ••• HIGHEST RANKS !MOST IMPRESSIVE! #46 in jeffthekiller 2/20/19: #17 in eyelessjack 2/20/19: #2 in thebloodypainter 2/20/19: #12 in thepuppeteer 2/20/19: #18 in lostsilver

Rose Petals - Eyeless Jack x Reader by Afflicted-Alibis

You always wanted a way out of town and away from the trauma of your every day life, but who knew it would come to you in a blue mask? Your life was certainly troubled. You had no parents- they were stripped away from you by a faceless thing in the woods one night when you were a small child. You had a troubled friend group. You had a stressful, mind-numbing minimum wage job. You had a broken home, completed by the drunken, careless uncle who had once promised to take care of you and your siblings. It made you want to disappear. The grey man dressed in black was a surprise to you after a chaotic night at home, and it was just his luck you even found him. However, what you thought to be a strange new friend was lethal and full of old horrors, and you soon come to find that he wants to be much more than just friends. (Cover art belongs to me!) Started: 8/26/2022 First Published: 10/15/2022 Finished: [Pending]

You may also like

Slide 1 of 9

Bloody Flowers [TicciJack] cover

𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢? [✔] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader} cover

The Cannibal and The Mute | Eyeless Jack x Mute! Male! Reader cover

She's Mine. (Creepypasta x Reader Fanfiction) cover

Masky X Reader X Hoodie cover

ᴸᴼᵛᴱ ᴮᴵᵀᴱˢ cover

The Innocent Eyes (Jeff The Killer X Reader) cover

My New Family (Creepypasta x Reader) cover

Rose Petals - Eyeless Jack x Reader cover

Bloody Flowers [TicciJack]

⚠︎There will be mental health struggles, suicide, attempted suicide, death, abuse, violence, and other triggering topics. If any of this is a trigger, please do not read this fan fiction.⚠︎ [insert description] I did not come up with Ticci Toby or Eyeless Jack, they aren't my ocs. Credit to their creators (Azelf500 & Kastoway) 💪 The art isn't mine either 😞 (Yasmim.Killer_UwU) #1 in Marble Hornets - Nov. 8th 2025 #1 in ticcitobyxeyelessjack - Dec. 12th 2025