One Wrong Choice - PrimaryQ - Wattpad

Story cover for One Wrong Choice by PrimaryQ

One Wrong Choice

Reads 9,188
Votes 28
Parts 1
Time 9m

Reads 9,188
Votes 28
Parts 1
Time 9m

Mature

arthurmorgan dead fanfiction mature rdr2 red reddeadredemption2 redemption rockstargames romance xreader

This is a Red Dead Redemption 2 Fan-fic. 
Arthur Morgan x Female Y/n (Reader)

   Life is pretty simple as a rich woman. No, let me try that again. Life is pretty simple as woman married to a rich man. Stay silent unless spoken too, dress with only the latest fashion, don't do anything unlady-like, and remain faithful to your husband. No matter what.
   
   Heaven forbid a happily married, high society woman of any respectability be found going against any of these rules. Good thing then, you are not a happily married woman; and when a group of outlaws makes a sudden appearance in your dreary city of Saint Denis, you happily break every single rule in the book.


This story will not follow strictly along the lines of Red Dead Redemption 2 but I will do my best to do every character the justice they deserve. However, I'm a sucker for happy endings so I will be adding my own spin on it.

DISCLAIMER: I do not own rdr2 or any of its characters.
This is a non-profit fan made story.All Rights Reserved

arthurmorgan dead fanfiction mature rdr2 red reddeadredemption2 redemption rockstargames romance xreader

Table of contents

(REWRITE) I've Got A Favor To Ask
Fri, Dec 26, 2025

1 part

(REWRITE) I've Got A Favor To Ask
Fri, Dec 26, 2025

Sign up to add One Wrong Choice to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Arthur Morgan x Reader by imagineyourcreator

[Completed] The beginning of the story takes place when they settled in Colter. When everyone was together before they moved to horseshoe overlook. Traveling the wild west can be a hell of a journey! It even gets crazier when you meet a man named Arthur Morgan, your life is going great but as you get into more and more trouble. Things go south really fast. This is my third fan fiction and I played this game like no tomorrow. I absolutely fell in love with Arthur and his big heart. I told myself I had to do a story on this game. Hope you enjoy. I do not own any of these characters. Thank y'all so much for nine thousand reads! 😭 #5 RDR2 #11 Arthur Morgan #52 RDR2 #15 John Marston #1 Arthur Morgan

A Long Ride Home by Charlie242017

!TW! contains mention of SA (briefly through flashbacks) (Also contains sex scenes scattered throughout) This is a fanfic that does not follow the storyline, it takes certain parts from it. Arthur x female OC ***** Arthur Morgan's life has been a series of struggles, but nothing could prepare him for the moment he finds a woman left broken by violence. Determined to help her heal, Arthur discovers that her strength rivals even the toughest gunslinger. Together, they navigate a path of survival, trust, and the fragile hope for a new life. As danger lurks and the past threatens to resurface, can two scarred souls find peace in each other-or will the unforgiving frontier claim them both?

Vows of Returning: A Red Dead Redemption 2 Story ( Arthur Morgan xOC ) by goodbyelisahoney

Arthur Morgan x OC: "Take a boozy short leave of your nymphs on the shore, and silence their mourning with vows of returning, though never intending to visit them more." After a near-deadly shootout in Valentine, Arthur Morgan retreats to a wooded cabin to lick his wounds and recover. But the reclusive woman he meets there causes him to question everything he believes in, and all of the people he holds dear. Does she have secrets of her own that she's hiding? ** Hi all; this is a little RDR2 romance (Arthur x original character) story. It follows the events of the game for the most part (meaning there are some spoilers, if you haven't finished the game yet!), but there are some changes/additions. Of course, all RDR2 characters/settings are Rockstar Games. Hope you all enjoy and would love to hear your thoughts. This story was completed September 18, 2021. A content warning: depictions of sex, violence, swearing, and other mature themes.

//BEARING ARMS//RDR2//ARTHUR x READER by S0UP66

Arthur Morgan, a crucial gunslinger of the Van der Linde Gang, joins in on the usual coach robbery, when suddenly, unexpected guests drop by. All before was going according to plan, until hell broke loose and the upper-class Lady (Y/N) stepped into his life. Can the wanted Arthur Morgan finally be able to prove himself that he is capable to love and be loved by another? [Highest Rankings] #1 - arthurmorgan #1 - ps4 #1 - arthurmorganxreader #1 - rockstargames #1 - reddeadredemption2 #1 - reddeadredemption #1 - wildwest #1 - rdr2xreader #1 - playstation #1 - rdr2 #2 - cowboy #3 - dutch #1 - southern #1 - western -Note: Contains violence, suggestive themes, and mature language. -Thank you for voting, commenting, and/ or reading -S0UP66

NOTHING GOLD CAN STAY: RDR2 by GingerBaggins

Nora has spent most of her life in solitude, travelling only with her business partner JB Cripps. Always on the move, never allowing herself the time to face the past that threatens to consume her. That is until she meets a particularly irritating outlaw at a bounty board and her life suddenly bursts into tremendous colour. But when the pendulum swings one way, eventually it'll swing the other. COMPLETE This is a work of fanfiction, with characters from Rockstar's Red Dead Redemption 2 and Red Dead Redemption 2 Online. I do not own this world, nor any character beyond the main OC. Neither do I own any of the literature and titles taken from the works of Robert Frost. (While this story follows along with the timeline and the main plot of the game, there will be divergences in the canon. Mainly that Arthur will not contract TB. As for who else lives and dies, I'm afraid you'll have to find out.)

Ghosts of the Past [ RDR2 - Arthur Morgan ] by Kindcube

COMPLETE When Arthur met Rosemary at the young age of 25, he was pretty much a goner. It seemed Arthur had a thing for kindly little women. Maybe because deep down all he really wanted was an honest life on a ranch, with a lady he could worship and provide for like a real man should. And in his short time with Rosemary he allowed himself to play make believe that that could ever happen. But like most good things in Arthur's life - that came to a crashing end when Dutch uplifted the gang from that town to move on again. But people from the past always have a way of showing up when you least expect it.

Arthur Morgan x Reader by thefanfictioncorner

You own a saloon in a town you wish to leave for good. One day, a group of outlaws decides to settle nearby. You decide to use them to your advantage to get out. Driven by his greed and the hunger for prestige, Dutch takes the deal you offer and puts his most trusted man, Arthur, up for your protection. However, even though Arthur seems like a fine fella, he has issues of his own and a lifestyle he can't seem to shake off.

The Rebellious Rescuer COMPLETED!✔ by RaysInDark

COMPLETED!!✔️ This is an Arthur Morgan X reader story, with you as the main character. You work as a brothel lady in the town called Valentine, and you stumble upon a notorious man that got you to grow feelings for this unknown man. But something comes in between and you get kidnapped by the O'Driscolls, what happens afterward? Well, this is where we let the story tell us... OBS! Some important info; 1. My native language isn't English, misspellings appear. Pls, maintain respect, thanks in advance! 2. Contains mature content, you are forewarned in the chapter! 3. More information in the AN chapter. 4. I'm not the owner of the cover photo or any other pictures in this story!

LAST CHANCE → sean macguire ✔ by ssadboyhours

r.d.r.2 " outlaws 'til the end, boys " the story of how a foolish girl winds up in the worst predicament of her life -- being in love with an outlaw or in which a dying light finds out why it's best to never play with fire ... ocxsean I do not own anything related to the titles of Red Dead Redemption, and am not attempting to claim any rights with this story. This story was made for the public's enjoyment, giving me an opportunity to share my loves and interests with fans who can relate. Cover's base photo not mine Cover is mine Do not copy my characters Respectful Constructive Criticism welcome Personal pleasing aesthetics ahead Gifs used not mine

Mud and Gold [Arthur Morgan] [RDR2] by catharsxs

➵ ❝Y'know... I ain't a good man.❞ ❝You're good to me, and that's enough.❞ ➵ Arthur Morgan had heard many tales about grand treasures hidden all over the Heartlands, yet he wasn't one to believe in mere rumors as such, most claimed by drunken lowlifes spending their miserable lives in rundown saloons. Until the day the Van der Linde gang saves a farm girl from Colm O'Driscoll's boys, and something more; with a legitimate treasure map in the girl's possession, the chance to earn a great amount of gold arises, and is far too tempting for Dutch van der Linde to turn down. Arthur takes it upon himself to find this secret stash of gold - and it's during this treasure hunt where the outlaw finds out more than he'd bargained for; the gold is not the only secret that has remained hidden for far too long. ➵ Arthur Morgan x Fem!reader ➵ Warning: this story contains foul language, violence, gore and death. ➵ Credits: RDR2/Arthur Morgan belongs to Rockstar Games, I only own my writing. ➵ Cover edited by @catharsxs ➵ IF YOU HAVE NOT FINISHED RDR2, BE AWARE OF POTENTIAL SPOILERS IN THIS STORY !!

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Arthur Morgan x Reader cover

A Long Ride Home cover

Vows of Returning: A Red Dead Redemption 2 Story ( Arthur Morgan xOC ) cover

//BEARING ARMS//RDR2//ARTHUR x READER cover

NOTHING GOLD CAN STAY: RDR2 cover

Ghosts of the Past [ RDR2 - Arthur Morgan ] cover

Arthur Morgan x Reader cover

The Rebellious Rescuer COMPLETED!✔ cover

LAST CHANCE → sean macguire ✔ cover

Mud and Gold [Arthur Morgan] [RDR2] cover

Arthur Morgan x Reader

[Completed] The beginning of the story takes place when they settled in Colter. When everyone was together before they moved to horseshoe overlook. Traveling the wild west can be a hell of a journey! It even gets crazier when you meet a man named Arthur Morgan, your life is going great but as you get into more and more trouble. Things go south really fast. This is my third fan fiction and I played this game like no tomorrow. I absolutely fell in love with Arthur and his big heart. I told myself I had to do a story on this game. Hope you enjoy. I do not own any of these characters. Thank y'all so much for nine thousand reads! 😭 #5 RDR2 #11 Arthur Morgan #52 RDR2 #15 John Marston #1 Arthur Morgan