Matthew Hudson is a respected primary care physician working in the town of Sassafras, Vermont. While his professional life appears to be pristine and very successful, being one of three partners in a group practice at the age of thirty-three, his personal life where he lives in the nearby town of Sugar Falls, is a far cry from what everyone would expect of the young, reserved, yet friendly professional because of a survival tactic he learned long ago: to compartmentalize everything very neatly.
Trauma from his past has left Matthew a fragile, broken man barely able to function, coping with a revolving door of prostitutes, hookups, alcohol, loneliness, depression, and deep-seated issues with anger, trust, and insecurity. He hasn't been able to maintain any long-term relationships, especially intimate relationships, however, it's that connection and intimacy he craves, with one dream in mind: to fall in love, get married, and have a family of his own.
One day, a mysterious name comes across his desk that catches his eyes, one that's hard to pronounce and belongs to a soft-spoken woman with auburn hair, who recently moved to the United States from Ireland, and opened a bookstore on Main Street in Sugar Falls. Saoirse Maher, with a patience of a monk, and the love and nurturing nature of an angel, unexpectedly enters Matthew's life, captivates him, waking something up inside of him. But does Matthew have the capacity to fall in love and make his dream come true, or is he simply damaged goods?
Rachel had survived the worst kind of heartache and had moved on with her life by following a dream that she had always had, to be a medical relief worker. She would finally be far away from all that haunted her, and she would be able to begin again and leave the past behind her, or so she thought. When she arrived at her new nursing post, her past was there, waiting. Dr. Jack Cooper had believed he was doing the right thing when he left Rachel, but he needed to see her once more to prove it to himself. He needed to see her happy and content before he moved on with his life. Neither one of them realized that the other was less than honest about their true feelings. Now, they are forced to work side by side with other relief workers, hiding their love from each other and those around them. Can they mend their broken hearts once their shocking secret comes to light and their true feelings are exposed?