Evelyn Ferrara has had a crush on her best friend and captain of the lacrosse team, Michael Jacobs, ever since he moved to Florida freshman year. Just as she thinks she's finally starting to only think of him as a friend, Michael begins to worm his way back into her heart. When Evelyn meets Oliver, a handsome and sweet baseball boy the summer before junior year, she thinks she can finally move on from Michael. But Michael seems to be acting strange towards Oliver. Is she simply making it up? Or is he jealous? Stuck in a love triangle Evelyn never wanted to be in she must choose who she wants to be with. Oliver, who has only been anything but sweet to her? Or pick Michael, who is her very best friend in the whole world, and promised to always be there for her?