19-year-old Serena Moore moves to Santa Carla, with her mother and father, and three twin sisters. Serena, spends her time babysitting, her siblings, as a normal teenager would. She loves taking pictures, journaling, and recording with her recorder, about her travels. Serena has a love for animals and spends her time, daydreaming, with a book in hand, about romance. Her love for playing the cello, her favorite instrument, and her love for school. She starts to enjoy the boardwalk, with her siblings, however, Serena and her siblings start to become stalked by The Lost Boys. Out for just fun, while her parents are working, she catches the eye, of two of them, David and Dwayne. On David's orders, Dwayne can't get enough of pursuing Serena. He even attempts, to try and snare her and lure her to the dark side, of temptation, to rejoice, in the fountain of youth. Serena pleads, for the boys to stop, but all David and Dwayne want to do is pop her cherry!
After being gone for four years, Emmy Johnson moves back to her hometown of Santa Carla, with her mother. She meets four mysterious strangers, who seem very familiar. Emmy begins to fall for one of the mysterious men, but will he be able to love Emmy? Will Emmy be able to handle his deepest, darkest secret?