Which side to choose?

This is a DC comic story, no hating on it. If you hate the story then just leave because I'm warning you now this story has Yaoi and a whole lot of it.

For future reference:
Stray-Tim Drake
Catfang-Damian Wayne
Redhood-Jason Todd
Nightwing-Dick Grayson
Batman-Bruce Wayne
Superman-Clark Kent
Superboy-Konnor Kent
Catwoman-Selena Kyle
The Witch-Grace Winters(from 'United as one' by CJfrymam)