The Wrong Choice~ Dean Winchester
- Reads 51
- Votes 5
- Parts 3
MatureOngoing46m
Last published Fri, Jul 25, 2025
A long time ago, Rosabelle King had chosen the wrong brother to fall in love with and realized the mistake may be a little too late. The Winchester brothers are opposites. Sam was kind, empathetic, intelligent, and independent, but he can be arrogant and stubborn. Dean was the bad boy, but he is understanding, kind (when he wants), funny, mischievous, and immature.
Sam had been the right choice at 17, but she always knew deep down maybe he wasn't. She couldn't get past every way Sam had hurt her, yet she forgave him so easily. He was supposed to be her right choice. I mean, he never sleeps around. He was loyal.
Dean had been her best friend. He was always there for her, and she would always be there for him. There was something about that she couldn't get past, some type of feeling, and it wasn't just about the time they had together. It was more, but her brother warned her it would hurt her in the long run.
How many times could she forgive Sam before she had enough? Was it too late to make the right choice? How could she move these feelings to the side for so long? Could she make things right for herself?
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Reawakening || Book 1 of 'Reawakening Series'
I felt sick to my stomach, nerves overcoming me at the thought of seeing him again after all these years. I know he's going to be angry, furious in fact and I know this will be one of the most difficult moments of my life, which is big seeing what I've been through. But I will see him again, and that is something I've only ever dreamed of. Addison Jones wasn't born a hunter, she was thrust into it against her will. After John Winchester was involved in hunt that left Addy an orphan at the age of fourteen, he took her in and made her apart of the family, t aching her the family business. There she met Dean Winchester, where the two madly fell in love. But after unforeseeable circumstances overcoming her, she was forced to leave behind the one man she would ever love. Three years on and now she's back due to orders, much to the confusion and anger of Dean. Old feelings emerge mixed with anger and resentment. Will the two ever get back together? Will they ever make it past this incident? Will Addy ever tell Dean the reason she left and broke his heart? I do not own any of the 'Supernatural' characters or plot lines, however I do own my original characters and plot lines and I will not tolerate them being stolen. This is the first book of the 'Reawakening' series, Fortitude is Book 2, and Denouement is Book 3. Copyright ree_louiseComplete
Dean X Reader: Dear Old Choices (DOC) (Might be Rewritten)
Your a 4 year old girl playing when all of a sudden your father gets killed by a unknown creature you are yet to discover at this young age. A man with a baseball cap named Bobby takes you and raises you as his own and teaches you what their is to be known. When you turn 19 you meet two brothers. The Winchester boys. One of the brothers take an interest in you and you take an interest in him. What will you do? Carry on your life and let your hunting consume you? Or will you let your feelings take controle and get In the way of your working? What will happen... !ENDED. Not a good ending though!Complete
Take Control (Dean x Reader)
I was taken by a vampire about 10 years ago. He made me stay on his nest. Everything ended when those two hunters came in the town. They killed 10 vampires and took me in so they could protect me from the last one that escaped. They taught me about the supernatural and how I could protect myself if I need to. But in the meanwhile I fel in love with the older one. We stayed together for 3 years. But it didn't work out, despite the fact that I was madly in love with him. It's been 2 years since I left and I still can't forget about him. I never understood why we broke up... ..."Dean?" "Hi, sweetheart" he says and smiles but something is different...Complete
right where you left me -- supernatural rewrite
Karolina had always been a little tougher than everyone else. Losing her parents as a kid, getting taken in by Bobby Singer, and growing up with two guys who thought "normal" was a pipe dream would do that to a girl. She was a force to be reckoned with, no doubt about it. But here's the thing-they don't tell you how hard it is when you want out. When you want something more, something different. Like, say, a life that doesn't involve demons and salt lines and always looking over your shoulder. Like a life at Stanford, where the biggest dangers are midterms and forgetting to set your alarm. But walking away from the only life you've ever known? Yeah, that's one thing. Walking away from him? From the guy who's your whole heart, the one you've fought beside, laughed with, loved? That's something else entirely. And then there's the kicker-because of course there's a kicker: she dreams about him. She dreams about him and his brother (her best friend), showing up at her new life, dragging her back into the world she thought she left behind. So, the question is, what do you do when the guy you love is the one pulling you back into the very thing you were trying to escape?![Confessions Are For Fresh Starts [Destiel - AU]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/152495120-256-k508947.jpg)
Confessions Are For Fresh Starts [Destiel - AU]
[Fanarts by me] Dean Winchester and Castiel Shurley are childhood friends for 25 years. For Dean it's like to have an older brother, since the two families are so close as if they are really related. But one day Castiel just came out of the closet and tells Dean that he is gay. The fact that he is homosexual is not the disturbing part for all this. No. The part which pisses Dean off is that Castiel got himself a 'perfect' boyfriend. The friendship is now dominated by confusion, misunderstanding and jealousy. Dean is about to loose his best friend because of a stupid relationship with this stupid rich British guy, or is there maybe more? [Storyline is made up by myself and upcoming characters are owned by CW's television show Supernatural]Complete
Shattered Memories. (Castiel x reader)
It was an ordinary night of studying when you get a call from your friend. She had met two devilishly handsome men at the bar and wanted you to come by. You had been approaching finals, you had been writing papers non stop and she wanted you to come take a break. Something about the night seemed off when you arrive. Was it because of exhaustion? This would be the night that forever changed your life. All the books and studying no longer mattered. Your life had evolved and so had you. I don't own characters, plot or anything directly related to the Supernatural show. This story is dedicated to a friend who has been asking me to make a Supernatural story for her. It's more of an AU story. I hope you enjoy this story. Comment, vote and let me know if you like it. :3 *my first supernatural fic. So hopefully it's not too shabby. I do not own the pic for the cover, nor do I know who to credit for it. If you don't like me using it, let me know.* Cover by @takemetotulsa thank you so much!Complete
Long Way to Nowhere (Dean Winchester x Child!Reader)
You've lived in the orphanage for as long as you could remember. You had no idea what happened to your parents, but you've always been here. You've watched as the other kids left, whether it be by adoption, they turned eighteen, or, heck, even running away. You never expected for yourself to be taken in by a loving family. So when a man comes in to adopt you and takes you home, what do you do? Sure, the family that you're living with might be a broken one, but it's a good one nonetheless. You love them and they love you, and that's all that matters, right? | To Clarify: This is a Dean x Daughter!Reader | | | Disclaimer: I don't own any characters from Supernatural | |Complete
Can't Catch A Break (Castiel Fanfic)
"Not only do I not like people, I cannot stand the life I'm living. This was not what I had planned whenever teachers asked me what I wanted to be. Can you believe I wanted to be a doctor so I could help people? I'm helping some people, but not in the way that I wanted. I wanted to be able to help people, have a nice family with a pet, safety, and security. As of right now, I can only do one of those things, and it is the very first thing on that list. I can't even make sure I'm safe, but as long as other people are, I should be happy. Right? Wrong." _______________________________________________________________________________ Addyson Taylor finally gets her life back on track, and she's happy after she never thought she would be again. After an incident and abandonment, she prayed, but quickly found that her prayers were going unanswered. She lost faith, found her current boyfriend, and rebuilt everything that had gotten destroyed. She thought she could finally breathe until he comes back, bringing back every memory she tried to suppress.Complete
Remember me, Dean Winchester? ~ Dean x Reader
Night after night after night. Sweating. Shaking. Sleepless nights tossing and turning. Can't sleep. The dreams. The nightmares. They keep coming back again and again. I roll over and pick up my phone and hit call. "Vicky they keep coming back. I can't ever sleep anymore." "It's alright just try to read a book or watch a movie tonight. Drink some tea to calm your nerves." "Alright thanks for answering I know it's so late." "No worries, Jess. Goodnight!" I get up to go boil some water for some tea. I head back to my room to read a book as Vicky suggested while I wait on my tea. But all I can see are flashing images from my dreams. Nothing makes sense. The dreams started a year ago and I can't get them to ever stop. Sometimes I feel like they are real. The images are so vivid and the feelings are so intense. Almost feels like lightning striking through my body that wakes me up every time. Once I wake up, all I ever remember is him. Dean Winchester.
The Start Of It All (Castiel x Reader) (Discontinued)
This is a season rewrite with the reader inserted into the story. It starts at season 4 because that's when Castiel comes in. You were adopted by Bobby Singer when you were seven years old because your parents were killed by demons and you were an only child. You've lived with him ever since and you loved it. He taught you how to shoot a gun and how to fight and also how to hunt. He never let you go on hunts, until you met Sam and Dean Winchester. After you met them, you went on every hunt with them, and they were basically brothers to you. When Dean makes a deal with a demon to save Sam, your heart is torn in pieces. You tried to stop Lilith and the hellhounds but she was stronger than you and Sam. Four months later when Dean shows up on your doorstep, you don't know what to think. Warning: Explicit content! No worse than Supernatural. I'm only using the quotes said in Supernatural and the main storyline. All credit goes to the creaters and writers of SupernaturalComplete
I felt sick to my stomach, nerves overcoming me at the thought of seeing him again after all these years. I know he's going to be angry, furious in fact and I know this will be one of the most difficult moments of my life, which is big seeing what I've been through. But I will see him again, and that is something I've only ever dreamed of. Addison Jones wasn't born a hunter, she was thrust into it against her will. After John Winchester was involved in hunt that left Addy an orphan at the age of fourteen, he took her in and made her apart of the family, t aching her the family business. There she met Dean Winchester, where the two madly fell in love. But after unforeseeable circumstances overcoming her, she was forced to leave behind the one man she would ever love. Three years on and now she's back due to orders, much to the confusion and anger of Dean. Old feelings emerge mixed with anger and resentment. Will the two ever get back together? Will they ever make it past this incident? Will Addy ever tell Dean the reason she left and broke his heart? I do not own any of the 'Supernatural' characters or plot lines, however I do own my original characters and plot lines and I will not tolerate them being stolen. This is the first book of the 'Reawakening' series, Fortitude is Book 2, and Denouement is Book 3. Copyright ree_louise
More detailsContent Guidelines