Who Do You Love? // Oliver Moy AU

"It's either me or him. Who do you choose?" He said. Oliver looked like he hasn't slept for days, his eyes dark and sunken. He turned around to walk away but I grabbed his arm.

"Oliver! You can't make me choose! Don't do this to me!" I said still holding onto him.

"Sienna...just choose. Who do you love? Me or Ryan?" He turned to walk away but then looked down at me, his brown eyes staring back at mine.

"Ryan." That one name, the one that wasn't his. Why did I say Ryan? "I mean you Oliver, I choose you." His eyes became watery as he looked anywhere but me. I could sense that he was holding in his tears. He slowly peeled my hand from his arm and walked away.

I watched as he walked away, a million thoughts running through my head. "Oli!" He kept walking, ignoring my calls. "Oli! Oliver, don't go! Please!" I yell trying my best to catch up to him. Without thinking I hugged him stopping him from walking any further.

"Sienna, I get it...I made a mistake. I made you my priority when I was your second choice." He gently lifted my arms before getting out of my grip and left. I stood there, broken and empty but it was my fault. My fault I didn't do anything. Why did I let the love of my life walk away?

**Book Cover Image is from Oliver Moy's Instagram.